Donegal transport rates and subsidy
Brennan challenged the higher transport costs in Donegal and argued that the unsubsidised Lough Swilly service disadvantaged the region; the Ceann Comhairle indicated that a sea-port issue was separate.
andMr. Breslin asked the Minister for Transport and Power if he is aware of the serious discrepancy in Donegal transport rates, passenger and freight, in comparison with the rest of the country; and if he has any plans to make Donegal transport competitive.
Comment on this
Road passenger services in the southern part of County Donegal are provided by CIE at normal CIE fares. The northern part of the county is catered for by the Londonderry and Lough Swilly Railway Company which is one of 33 private bus companies operating local services in different parts of the country. The fares charged by these private companies while subject to price legislation vary from place to place according to the economics of their service areas. I do not propose to alter these arrangements. I am of course aware that CIE have been able to reduce their fares by virtue of the special subsidy provided for this purpose in the June, 1975 budget. No such subsidy was provided for private bus companies and, in this connection, I would refer the Deputies to the replies by the Minister for Finance to questions on this subject on 29th October, 1975, and to my reply to a similar question on 6th November, 1975.
Freight services in County Donegal are provided as in the rest of the country by CIE and private operators and I am not aware of serious discrepancies in the freight rates in County Donegal compared with the rest of the country. CIE have informed me that they do not discriminate against County Donegal in their freight charging structure. CIE have always been conscious of the needs of areas such as Donegal and have consistently sought to ensure adequacy of services at the lowest possible cost. For instance, rail freight traffic which is carried by CIE between Dublin and Derry for County Donegal is afforded the most favourable rates possible. The concessionary charging arrangements for sundries traffic to Dublin which were introduced by CIE in February, 1973, afforded particular benefits to the more remote areas, including County Donegal.
Comment on this
One of the most needed incentives in the west of Ireland is subsidised transport due to the fact that transport lines are so extended. The Minister admitted that the Lough Swilly Railway Company do not enjoy a subsidy as does CIE and this leaves that part of Donegal in a most disadvantaged position. I am surprised that the Minister is not prepared to take any action and I would ask him in relation to his answer to Question No. 10—on which I did not wish to anticipate his answer to this question—would he not consider it now as a matter of some urgency that an alternative means of transport be examined which would provide an outlet from Donegal, namely, the development of one or other of the excellent sea ports such as Killybegs or Rathmullen which have not the necessary transit sheds and other facilities which would encourage their use for shipping?