Freight subsidies and western industry
Barry said CIE and private operators did not receive the proposed freight subsidy, while CIE’s uniform bulk-goods rates benefited remote areas. Brennan argued that high transport costs eroded IDA grants and deterred industry in the west; Barry disagreed, citing the grants and the absence of an IDA request for subsidised rates. Brennan sought an inquiry board, but the Chair moved on.
CIE do not enjoy the advantage of a subsidy either in regard to freight rates. They are ad idem in that regard. Under an EEC directive I cannot subsidise CIE road freight and I will not do it.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not consider that there should be any subsidisation of transport to the west at all?
Comment on this
There is a partial subsidy inasmuch as more remote areas get the benefit of the fares structure of CIE that gives a fixed rate to bulk carriers throughout their network. Therefore, the further CIE have to carry anything the more advantage it is to the people at the other end. For instance, a bulk load of cement coming from Drogheda to Dublin is charged at the same per ton rate as that cargo of cement going to Donegal.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that one of the greatest impediments to the industrial development of the west is the transport charges which compare unfavourably with the rest of the country?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that an IDA grant given to a factory on the western seaboard is completely eroded in the course of a few years as a result of extra transport charges and that this militates against decentralisation of industry?
Comment on this
I do not agree. For the bulk carriage of goods CIE quote a constant price throughout the country so that the IDA grants are not eroded.
Comment on this
In my view, the biggest incentive to attracting industry to the west is the IDA grant. These grants are, and have been, the most important incentive and have been very productive.
Comment on this
The Minister, and his colleague, the Minister for Industry and Commerce, must be aware that in relation to any potential project for the west a small calculation will show that the extra transport charges as compared with those for an industry on the east or south coast would erode any grant they would receive.
Comment on this
I do not agree. If this was so the IDA, through the Minister for Industry and Commerce, would be approaching my Department, or the Department of Finance, for a subsidised transport rate. To the best of my knowledge they have not done this. If it was a serious deterrent to industrialists going to the west the IDA would have done something about it.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying he is not aware of any demand for a more advantageous freight rate for the western seaboard?