Tullamore Hospital’s future role
The Minister said Tullamore would remain open until new acute hospitals were ready, then serve as a community hospital; Portlaoise and Mullingar were chosen for the region’s acute hospitals. Members challenged the decision against the FitzGerald Report and regional population needs, questioned whether it was politically motivated, and the Minister said the plan was final and the hospital’s community functions would be settled with the health board.
asked the Minister for Health if he will make a statement on the future role of the County Hospital, Tullamore, County Offaly, in the light of the recent hospital plan announced by the Government; and the general effect the plan will have on this hospital.
Comment on this
Tullamore Hospital will continue in its present role for some years to come until the necessary additional accommodation is provided at the centres to be developed as acute general hospitals. It will then continue in existence as a community hospital with a role of great importance in the health services. The details of this role will be discussed with the health board.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that on Thursday last more than 8,000 people participated in a demonstration in Tullamore regarding the forthcoming closure of Tullamore Hospital as a surgical hospital? I take it from the reply given by the Minister that this hospital will be turned into a community hospital; in my opinion, it will be better known as an old folks' home.
Comment on this
It will not be regarded as an old folks' home. So far as the demonstration was concerned I was not aware of it but I take the Deputy's word on the matter.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that in the south-eastern region there will be four general hospitals? The population in this area is 320,000 while in the midland region, which has a population of 178,000, there will be no general hospital whatever. Could the Minister explain that?
Comment on this
I can explain it by reason of the fact that it was the Mid-Western Health Board who decided that there would be these hospitals and that they would be located as I proposed.
Comment on this
Will the Minister indicate the considerations that were responsible for his departing from the very firm recommendation in the FitzGerald Report that Tullamore would be the general hospital for the region?
Comment on this
The FitzGerald Report made certain recommendations. It included Tullamore as one of the sites for a major general hospital but I decided I would consult Comhairle na nOspidéal who laid down the guidelines which I am sure are well known to the Deputy. These guidelines were proposed by Comhairle na nOspidéal. All the various health bodies, from An Comhairle downwards, were consulted. The eventual decision by the Mid-Western Health Board was that there would be a hospital at Portlaoise and another at Mullingar.
Comment on this
We are all aware that consultations take place on these matters. The Minister knows that the FitzGerald Report clearly and positively recommended that Tullamore be the general hospital for this region. Can the Minister assure the House that he decided on medical grounds to downgrade Tullamore from being a general hospital to being a mere community hospital, or was he influenced, as is widely suspected, by political motives in this decision?
Comment on this
So far as I was concerned I had made up my mind some time ago. I submitted the proposals to the Government who approved them. As far as the FitzGerald Report is concerned, I do not think anyone is happy with it apart from those towns where the FitzGerald Committee proposed that hospitals be sited. To say the least, when the FitzGerald Report was issued there was no enthusiasm for it from any side of the House. I believe that the FitzGerald Report recommended too few hospitals and I still believe there should be greater facilities at shorter distances for people who need urgent hospital attention.
Comment on this
Would I be right in stating that according to the latest issue of the Medical Journal, Comhairle na nOspidéal were not consulted——
Comment on this
Whether they were consulted or not—well, it does make a difference because Comhairle na nOspidéal are held in high regard—but it was Comhairle na nOspidéal that laid down the guidelines whereby there would be a catchment area of 100,000 and the distance from a hospital would be no more than 30 miles approximately.
Comment on this
I have allowed a lot of latitude on this question. This must be a final supplementary.
Comment on this
I think the Ceann Comhairle will admit that in the opinion of the people of Offaly and the people of the whole region this is a very important matter——
Comment on this
I should like to know if the Minister's decision in regard to the Midland region is open to negotiation of any kind or is it final? Is it a final plan?
Comment on this
That is the final plan as recommended by me and approved by the Government. I believe the area will be well served in the proposals that have been made and the decisions that have been made in relation to Portlaoise and Mullingar. Neither the Deputy nor anybody in Tullamore should assume that there is this awful downgrading that the Deputy describes. It will be deemed to be a community hospital and its functions will be decided in discussions between the health board and the Department of Health.
Comment on this
Much as the Deputy would like to see it close down completely it will still be there.
Comment on this
——that I attended meetings both in Portlaoise and in Offaly and I did not try to be on the two bandwagons like the Deputy, who fell off. I have great respect for the Deputy but I want to tell him that he got a sweet pill.
Comment on this
The Minister knows my attitude. I was in Tullamore when the Deputy was on the bandwagon.
Comment on this
Order. There are very many questions on the Order Paper and we must move on to other questions. Deputy Connolly may ask one final supplementary.
Comment on this
I want to say that as far as the people in the midland region are concerned this is the worst decision that could be made since the year of the famine.
Comment on this
I should like, with your permission, a Cheann Comhairle, to raise this matter on the Adjournment.