Borrowing used for social welfare
Asked how much borrowing funded social welfare, the Minister said borrowed funds enter the general Exchequer and cannot be traced to specific spending; he confirmed that borrowing financed some current expenditure, including social welfare. Remaining questions were deferred to the next sitting.
Would the Minister indicate what proportion of the £279 million he mentioned is being devoted to social welfare benefits of one kind or another?
Comment on this
This is an unanswerable question in the sense that this is part of total borrowings to go into the general Exchequer fund so that the applicability of any given borrowings to any particular purpose, such as investment or budget deficit, is of its nature unknowable, and as regards what proportion of the budget deficit is accounted for by any particular expenditure, that also is unknowable, unless one knew which was the last expenditure decision taken. Even if the Deputy's question were not a separate one, I am afraid it would be unanswerable.
Comment on this
Is it not true that a great deal of borrowed money is being used for the payment of social welfare benefits by the Department? If that is the case, how much?
Comment on this
The position is that a great deal of current expenditure is this year being financed by borrowing rather than by taxation and other current revenue sources. Current expenditure includes social welfare expenditure, and for the reasons I have given, the Deputy's question is unanswerable in a more precise form.