Alleged misreporting of Regional Fund recipients
O’Leary and Colley alleged that firms and local authorities had been named as Regional Fund recipients despite receiving the relevant grants from the Exchequer years earlier. Ryan denied being aware of this and explained that the Fund reimburses national governments for qualifying expenditure rather than making project-specific payments; the dispute remained unresolved.
Is the Minister aware that firms' and companies' names were used during the past year who had already been paid a few years ago and that local authorities' names were used in the list supplied by him——
Comment on this
I am not so aware. I suggest it is time the Opposition and their friends outside this House cease their efforts to denigrate this country. Last week I received a phone call from Commissioner Thomson of the EEC deploring a report which had been issued by one of the friends of Deputy O'Leary purporting to give an account of a meeting which they had with Commissioner Thomson and Commissioner Thomson said that what he said to the persons who met him was quite the reverse of what they gave to the Press when they left him and he was angry that people who had sought an audience with him should have misused that occasion in order to utter untruths about what he said to them. He commended once again the Government's handling of the whole regional fund and he expressed the wish as he has publicly on several occasions in the past, that other countries would handle it as well as the Irish Government.
Comment on this
On a point of order, would the Minister be more specific in the comments he is making about a particular Press release?
Comment on this
As I understood the Minister, he denied in response to a supplementary question from Deputy O'Leary that firms or local authorities had been publicly referred to as having received money from the EEC Regional Fund who, in fact, had received the money some time previously out of Exchequer resources. Am I misrepresenting the Minister in understanding him in that way?
Comment on this
What I said was, and what I now repeat is, that the consent of local authorities to name them in relation to grants for regional fund purposes is not required. The consent of private firms is required before their names may be disclosed to outside authorities and the reason for this confidentiality is to respect the privacy of the private firms in question.
Comment on this
With respect, that is not the question I put to the Minister. Could I ask the Minister if he would either confirm or deny that firms have been named publicly as having received money from the EEC Regional Fund who did not, in fact, receive such money but received their grants and other moneys involved from the Exchequer some years ago?
Comment on this
I have said what is the truth of what the Commission require, that the Exchequer must prove that it has paid out of the national Exchequer moneys for specific purposes before any payment can be received by Ireland under the Regional Fund Scheme. This necessarily requires that payment must be made in respect of the purposes for which regional fund assistance is sought, and, as one year follows another, the amount of money spent in Ireland will increase by virtue of the assistance received from the regional fund.
Comment on this
Yes, sir. May we take it that the Minister is not denying that firms and local authorities were named as receiving EEC Regional Fund moneys who did not receive them, for whatever reason? May we also take it, therefore, that the Minister's denial of this point to Deputy O'Leary, which was followed by his long, and, I would suggest irrelevant reference to Commissioner Thomson, was unjustified, and that the correct position is that such firms and local authorities were so named and did not, in fact, receive any money from the EEC Regional Fund?
Comment on this
——for not understanding the position, but one cannot excuse Deputy Colley, who knows well that Brussels does not make specific payments to particular operations in Ireland, in Italy, in Germany, in France or anywhere else. All it does is to pay out money to the national government in question which amounts to a supplement on what that government would otherwise spend on regional projects in its own country. It can only pay out such money when it receives proof to its satisfaction that the money has already been spent by the national government. Whatever about Deputy Colley or the begrudging Opposition here, the important thing is that the EEC who pay out the money and do not pay it out unless they are satisfied the money has been spent, are paying the money to Ireland, are paying the money to Ireland before anybody else and have urged the other eight member countries of the EEC to follow the example of Ireland so that the regional fund may be got off the ground and operated properly.