Beef intervention and deficiency payments
Gibbons argues intervention has failed to protect cattle producers and asks whether deficiency payments would be better. Clinton agrees they could support prices more effectively, but warns of administrative difficulties, higher Community costs, and the risk that the FEOGA budget could not cover a severe market collapse; he says third-country imports and intervention beef sales contributed to the previous year’s recession.
asked the Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries if, having regard to the fact that the European Commission is currently conducting an assessment of the relative value of the existing intervention system and a possible system of deficiency payments, he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
Experience over the past couple of years has shown that the existing beef intervention system is not fully effective in supporting producer prices when the market is over-supplied. A deficiency payments system would be more effective in this respect but it would give rise to very considerable administrative difficulties for most member States, and from the Community point of view would be likely to be far more costly than intervention. In view of the very high proportion of our beef production which is exported, a vital consideration for us is, of course, that any support system should be fully financed by the Community.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that the intervention system as far as cattle are concerned has been, from our point of view, a total failure, especially last year? For that reason, would the Minister not agree that the development of our cattle trade, especially, is absolutely dependent on the producer, and the producer alone, being compensated for depressing drops in the market price, and that the British system, or something like it, in regard to agricultural produce throughout the Community would be better? The practice and the experience gathered by the UK in the last decade must be of great value.
Comment on this
My reply indicates that a deficiency system would be preferable to a system of intervention if it were paid for totally by the Community. That is where the big snag exists. A big snag also exists if in one country you have an intervention system and in another deficiency payments. The Commission indicated at one stage that if there had been a deficiency system last year the burden would have been intolerable. If the bottom fell out of the market, as it did in 1974, FEOGA would not be able to meet the cost from the budget provided.
Comment on this
Surely this is a questionable and hypothetical thesis for the Commission to put forward, if they did put it forward? Was not the real reason for the collapse last year the importation of third country meat and the sale of enormous quantities of intervention beef to third countries?
Comment on this
That was a very large part of the cause of the recession that took place last year but it was not by any means the total cause.
Comment on this
Has any research been done by the Commission into the comparative desirability of the two systems?