Telephone directory contract and employment
The Minister said the directory contract required all work to be done in the State and was awarded under standard tender rules, with no preference between Irish firms; he could not say how the change would affect employment. Colley pressed him to consider the jobs at risk, including hundreds of East Wall workers, while the Minister defended the procedure and the Chair repeatedly ruled the exchange out of order as debate.
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs whether the contract recently awarded for the printing of the telephone directory for 1977 to 1981 includes a guarantee that all the work involved will be carried out in the State.
19.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs whether the placing of the contract for the printing of the telephone directory for 1977 to 1981 with a firm other than that previously employed will result in any loss of jobs; and, if so, the number.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 18 and 19 together.
It is a condition of the contract in question that all the work involved will be carried out in the State. The contract was placed in accordance with the standard procedure which has governed the award of State contracts for many years and which does not permit of any preference being given as between Irish firms. Employment content was not, therefore, a factor in the award of the contract and I am not in a position to say what will be the effect on employment of the transfer of the work in question from one Irish firm to another.
Comment on this
Would the Minister agree that the fact that he is not aware of and not concerned with the effect on employment in the award of this contract is symptomatic of the approach of himself and his colleagues to the whole problem of unemployment and that the concern which should be expressed in reality in regard to this problem on day to day affairs by the Minister and his colleagues would make a considerable difference to the unemployment problem if they concerned themselves with it instead of talking about it?
Comment on this
The Deputy's speech in the form of a question is grossly unfair and demagogic. I have set out the position and the Deputy, as a former Minister for Finance, should well understand it. The Government are not in a position to discriminate as between Irish firms which submit tenders for contracts. It chooses the lowest of the available tenders and that would have been so under the Minister and well he knows it. One of these firms will presumably be employing more people, the other presumably fewer, but the efficiency of the companies concerned is a matter which, of course, affects the process of tender and contracts and it ill-befits a former Minister for Finance to make the kind of point he has just made.
Comment on this
May I ask the Minister if he would accept that the question put to him did not ask him to discriminate between one Irish firm and another but did ask him to have regard to the amount of employment provided as a result of the printing of the Telephone Directory for a period of five years? I suggest that the problems of unemployment at this time are so enormous that the position is not at all comparable with that obtaining when I was Minister for Finance and that the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs——
Comment on this
——would do well to pay attention to the areas in which he can ensure that there is not a drop in employment.
Comment on this
I do not know what the Deputy is suggesting here. I am satisfied that the proper procedures were fully complied with here. The Deputy knows that proper compliance with contract procedure is basic to the action of a Government department. Is he suggesting that because of a conjecture about possible effects on employment my Department should have discriminated against the firm which submitted the lower tender——
Comment on this
Why does the Minister persist in trying to allege that I want to discriminate between one Irish firm and another——
Comment on this
Why did the Minister not concern himself with the employment content no matter which firm was given the contract?
Comment on this
May I point out that the persons likely to be affected in this matter are some hundreds of workers employed in a factory in East Wall and I have a direct concern as well as a national concern in this matter?
Comment on this
That performance does the Deputy and his party very little credit indeed, if it is argued that this Government and my Department should discriminate against one Irish firm as against another because the other firm happens to be in East Wall. Is that the Deputy's argument?
Comment on this
The Minister should see that employment is not lost as a result of a contract placed by his Department.
Comment on this
——when you have two Irish firms competing against each other and well the Deputy knows that. This performance is a shameful one.