Parteen post-office provision
The Minister said nearby sub-offices and low local demand did not warrant a Parteen post office, and linked kiosk provision in rural areas to whether a post office was justified. Barrett argued that the growing settlement needed public telephone access, including at night; the Minister said the issue could be reconsidered as development continued but gave no population threshold.
andMr. Daly asked the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs if he is aware of the urgent need for a post office at Parteen, County Clare; and if he has any proposals in the matter.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 36 and 37 together.
I am not aware of an urgent need for a post office at Parteen. The sub-offices at Bridge Street and Thomondgate, Limerick, and at Ardnacrusha are each about two miles away and the very small amount of post office business arising in the Parteen area would not warrant provision of a sub-post office there.
Kiosks are not being provided in rural areas such as Parteen where post offices are not warranted.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that this should not be described as a rural area? It is a rapidly growing village. In fact it is bigger than a village at present, with Clare County Council and private house developers operating in the area. Surely the people there are entitled to a public telephone, even at night, when they have no access to one?
Comment on this
I apologise if I have given any offence by the description "rural area". The information I have from my Department states that Parteen is a village with a population of 500, which seems to me to qualify for the description I used. I agree that approximately 100 of the houses have been built during the last three years. Of course, as development takes place, the matter will be further considered. However, when Deputies press for new post offices in very small areas they should realise that, in relation to population, the number of post offices in this Administration is rather extraordinarily high. On average there is a post office for approximately every 1,300 of the population. Figures for some other countries are: Britain, 2,300; West Germany, 2,400; France, 3,000; Denmark, 3,600; Italy, 4,000 and the USA, 6,400. Therefore, we are well at the top of the league in the matter of post offices. In these conditions, and in the light of the general economic situation, any Government would have to think twice about opening considerable numbers of new post offices. Admittedly, population shifts do from time to time require this, but I am not satisfied that this is the case.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not think it is misleading to give the figures he has just given without, at the same time, giving the relative density of population per kilometre or per square mile?
Comment on this
I do not say they could not deserve further analysis but analysis is, I think, hardly appropriate here.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned 500 people living in Parteen village. Could the Minister say how many inhabitants would be required in a village to warrant a public telephone?
Comment on this
I am afraid I could not give the Deputy that information—I would need notice—but I know it to be very much more than 500.
Comment on this
Surely 500 people living in a village should be entitled to a public telephone. They have no access at night to a telephone and they live some distance from Limerick.