Ill-treatment of children
Deputies questioned the scale of child battering, called for a national system to identify and record cases, and pressed for clear procedures for doctors, nurses and others to report suspicions. The Parliamentary Secretary said the problem was receiving urgent attention and an interdepartmental report was due shortly; he cited 1972 figures on deaths from accidents and violence but gave no detailed reporting procedure. The Chair repeatedly moved the House to the next question.
asked the Minister for Health if his attention has been drawn to reports of alleged child battering by parents; and if he will make a statement on the reports which have aroused widespread disquiet.
Comment on this
I have seen the recent references and comments in the Press on a report on non-accidental injury to children prepared by a committee comprising members from the Irish Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children and the North Dublin Social Workers. I had already received a copy of this report.
While I do not wish to discount the general significance of the problem, the aspect of the report which caused most comment in the Press and which was probably the greatest cause of public disquiet was the reference in the report to the estimate that as many as 100 children per year may die in Ireland as a result of non-accidental injury by their parents. However, the information available to my Department indicates that the incidence of such deaths is nothing of the order of the above estimate.
The problem of non-accidental injury to children has also been under examination by a committee established in May last at the instigation of my Department. The group have a broadly based membership and I understand that their report will be submitted to my Department very shortly.
The problem of non-accidental injury to children will be considered urgently in my Department in the light of the recommendations in the two reports referred to and I will then make a further statement on the matter.
Comment on this
In fairness to the ISPCC, somebody must have misinterpreted their report. Until a national advisory centre has been established we will not know how big this problem is. At present in this city if a mother who is in mental trouble ill-treats her child she can go to 15 different hospitals on 15 different occasions and say that the child fell from a pram or something. This could not happen if there was a national centre at which such things could be registered. The answer given is very vague. We must have far more stringent measures so that remedial action can be taken, but this cannot be done until we have an advisory centre. Then we will know how many are dying as a result of ill-treatment. We have been told that in Britain 300 children are dying per year from ill-treatment. Therefore, our ratio would be 30, but we will not know until a centre has been established.
Comment on this
I want to assure the Deputy and the House and parents that this is a matter that is being taken very seriously by me and the Department. Whether the number who die from ill-treatment is ten, 20 or 100, the fact is the problem exists and the matter is having our immediate and urgent attention.
Comment on this
One report has been published. The other, that of the Departmental committee, will be on my desk shortly and I will let Deputies know what it is.
Comment on this
Like the Deputy, I realise that evil is there and we should all join forces to eradicate it.
Comment on this
There should be closer and more detailed examination by the doctors in order to ensure it is not a mere cut or a bruise but the result of battering.
Comment on this
I would set up a clinic in highly-populated areas where there would be a concentration of such cases.
Comment on this
They have to be identified as being battered. The first thing is to identify a battered child as distinct from a hurt child, a bruised child.
Comment on this
What procedures are applied if somebody is suspicious that a child has been battered?
Comment on this
I should inform the House that in 1972, of a total of 101 children under five years of age who had been certified as dying from accidents and violence, 30 of them died from traffic accidents and 34 from the intake of food causing obstruction and suffocation. If 20 died from battering, the problem is not as big as we see it, but it is a problem and I can assure Deputies the Minister and I are looking after it.
Comment on this
One final supplementary—if a doctor, nurse or somebody at a clinic is suspicious of the fact that a child has been battered, have they been instructed to report such cases and to whom do they report; who instructs them?