Donegal worker’s unemployment benefit appeal
A Donegal shirt-factory worker was refused benefit because a deciding officer found her unavailable for work. Cunningham asks the Minister to accept his late appeal and raises concerns that married women with children are routinely disqualified; the Minister will try to refer the appeal but says he cannot direct the appeals officer and disputes that the practice is automatic.
asked the Minister for Social Welfare the reason for the refusal by his Department of unemployment benefit in the case of a person (details supplied) in County Donegal who is a shirt factory worker and who, due to the recession, is unable to obtain employment.
Comment on this
A claim for unemployment benefit made by the person concerned was disallowed by a deciding officer with effect from 21st August, 1975 on the ground that she did not satisfy the statutory condition for entitlement to benefit which requires a claimant to be available for employment. She has not exercised her right of appeal against the decision.
Comment on this
Would the Minister take this question and letter of appeal which I have written as an indication of this person's wish to appeal? Could I use this case as an indication of a widespread social welfare practice amongst shirt factory workers, married women, who, when working, contribute to the stamp and find means of having any children looked after by a mother or mother-in-law but who, when they cease employment—due to the recession in the shirt industry—are, in the main disqualified by the Minister's Department and debarred from receiving the benefits of the contributions they made while working? This is a widespread matter.
Comment on this
I am using this question as a means of trying to bring home to the Minister a practice which has repercussions in the shirt industry and those who are disemployed in that industry, especially married women.
Comment on this
I will take a chance on taking the appeal from the Deputy; I presume it is on the statutory form?
Comment on this
There is a period during which an appeal must be made. I think it is 30 days. I think there are slight complications here— I have looked at the question again— the deciding officer decided against her on the 21st August, 1975. There is a time within which she must lodge an appeal. Whether or not anybody, including myself, has power to waive that, I do not know, but she has exceeded the 30 days limit. Certainly, I will undertake to take the appeal from the Deputy to see whether it can be put before the appeals officer. On the second part of the question, as far as married women and other workers are concerned, the Deputy knows that I have no function. The appeals officer has statutory power to decide whether or not a person is available and whether or not in certain circumstances unemployment benefit or unemployment assistance should be paid.
Comment on this
I do not want to score any points but would the Minister not agree that, if this practice is widespread and if it is almost automatic for a married woman working in a shirt factory who becomes disemployed to be disqualified because she has a child——
Comment on this
Because she is a mother it is alleged she is not available for employment although she has, in fact, proved that she was employed while she was a mother——
Comment on this
I am asking questions. I am asking the Minister will be intervene in this particular category. This woman has proven in the past that she is available for work when work is available for her despite the fact she has a child but, when she becomes unemployed, the fact that she has a child is put forward as a ground for her not being available for work.
Comment on this
If the practice is as the Minister has indicated then the Minister must take steps to remedy the situation and I am asking him now if he will do just that.
Comment on this
I could not give any undertaking that I would interfere with the present statutory powers of the appeals officer. The circumstances to which the Deputy referred are all put before the appeals officer and he makes the decision. I have no power to interfere with his decision in respect of one category of worker or another.
Comment on this
I have allowed a great deal of latitude and I am calling the next question, Question No. 15.