Shop assistant’s unemployment benefit appeal
A Donegal shop assistant’s unemployment benefit refusal was upheld after an oral appeal hearing, and the decision is final unless new facts or evidence emerge. Cunningham challenges how availability is assessed for mothers seeking work; the Minister says having a child does not automatically disqualify someone and the appeals officer makes the individual judgment.
asked the Minister for Social Welfare the reason for non-payment of unemployment benefit to a shop assistant (details supplied) in County Donegal.
Comment on this
A claim for unemployment benefit made by the person concerned on 5th November, 1975, was disallowed by a deciding officer on the ground that she did not satisfy the statutory condition for entitlement to benefit which requires a claimant to be available for employment. The decision of the deciding officer was upheld by an appeals officer after an oral hearing at which the claimant attended and gave evidence. An appeals officer's decision is final in the absence of new facts or fresh evidence.
Comment on this
Could I ask the Minister if he is satisfied with the statutory condition under which a married woman who has a child and who, because of the economic circumstances of the factory in which she was employed, loses that employment is ruled as not genuinely seeking work?
Comment on this
That is not the statutory position. The fact she has a child does not automatically debar her.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that one of the questions asked in the investigation is who is in a position to look after the child if the mother gets work? Even if the mother says that her mother, her mother-in-law or her husband will do it—in one case the husband is unemployed and well able to look after the child— the statutory regulation referred to by the Minister is applied and, despite the fact that information is given as to who will look after the child, she is ruled as not genuinely seeking work and she is debarred from getting unemployment benefit?
Comment on this
It is not a statutory condition at all. The appeals officer uses his own judgment as to whether or not the person is available and decides accordingly.
Comment on this
The pattern in this industry is that in every case I know of what I have said obtains.