We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Housing Grants.

Withdrawal of new-house grants

Summary

Timmons and Burke challenged the withdrawal of grants, arguing it would burden young buyers and harm housebuilding and employment; Tully defended the decision on expenditure-control grounds, citing increased housing investment and saying the grant was too small to affect building output significantly.

asked the Minister for Local Government if he will make a statement on the decision to cut back housing grants; and if he proposes to provide any alternative to offset the higher deposits now facing potential house purchasers.

11.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Local Government if, in view of the recent increases granted by the Minister for Industry and Commerce for building materials, he will reconsider his decision concerning the payment of State grants for new houses; and if he will make a statement on the matter.

Comment on this
James Tully Minister for Local Government (Mr. Tully) Labour Party

With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to answer Questions Nos. 10 and 11 together.

In my recent announcement of the Government decision on this matter, I explained that the amount of capital provided for housing purposes has increased greatly during the past three years. For example, £116 million was provided for housing last year under the public capital programme compared with £46 million in 1972-73.

In view of the present economic situation, however, the need to control the growth of Exchequer expenditure must apply to housing and other priority services. While I anticipate that this year more money than ever before will be provided for housing, the Government have had to examine critically the need for, and the relative benefits of each component part of this expenditure.

In deciding to restrict new house grants to persons eligible for supplementary grants from local authorities, the Government were influenced by the need to channel available resources to sectors where they will be of most benefit nationally and individually. It must also be remembered that the maximum grant of £275, introduced in 1948, was intended to stimulate private housing output at a time when the annual output was less than 1,000. Last year the corresponding figure was approximately 15,750. The continued payment of new house grants on a free-for-all basis, irrespective of an applicant's income, could not be justified.

I have made clear that the substantial ancillary benefits of rates remission and exemption from stamp duty, hitherto enjoyed by grant-type houses, will continue to apply to such houses and proposals for legislation to give effect to this decision are being prepared.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that, with the SDA loan limit at the miserable limit of £4,500 for the past three years, and with the spiralling cost of houses, the decision to abolish the State grant is the final stab in the back for couples trying to buy houses and also for the private sector in the building industry?

Comment on this

Not at all.

Comment on this

In his reply the Minister quoted various figures in relation to the money invested in the building industry by the Government over the past 12 months. Would he not agree that, because of inflation, the same amount of money will not buy what it was possible to buy some years ago?

Comment on this

I pointed out that the figure of £46 million three years ago compares pretty badly with the figure of £160 million last year.

Comment on this

With 120,000 unemployed and the fact that the building industry is capable of rapid expansion and taking on many of the unemployed instead of cutting the grant the Minister should have increased it and the SDA loan limit as we asked on many occasions.

Comment on this

My answer to that is that 25,750 houses were built last year and a lot of people were employed on that work.

Comment on this

That was last year when the grants were available. Does the Minister not agree that the decision he has taken will seriously damage the housing output for the coming year?

Comment on this

It will not and the Deputy knows that.

Comment on this

Of course it will. Does the Minister not accept the figures of the building confederation on this question?

Comment on this

No, I will not because they were so far out in figures they tried to give before on other matters. My figures are not open to doubt; they have been backed up by statistics which can be checked by anybody.

Comment on this

Scraping the bottom of the barrel.

Comment on this

I am sure the Deputy will agree that 25,750 is well up in the barrel.

Comment on this

Would the Minister agree that his decision will mean that more people will look for houses from the local authorities thereby imposing more expense on local authorities?

Comment on this

No, because if local authorities have a housing list they will know who is entitled to be housed. Deputies opposite know that most of the money under that grant scheme went to people who would not worry whether they received the grant or not.

Comment on this

That is not a fact. Apart from the odd exception, these grants were a great help to young couples buying houses and the fact that they will not receive such grants now will mean the price they will have to pay for a house will be increased. At the same time the Minister has not increased the amount of the SDA loan.

Comment on this

It will still be payable to those eligible for a supplementary housing grant. Less than 3 per cent of the cost of expensive houses is represented by this grant and it is ridiculous to suggest that my decision will have a major effect on the building industry.

12.

Comment on this