We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Dáil Sittings: Motion.

Contributions 118–255 of 255. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

The Parliamentary Secretary is discriminating against 45 per cent. It is disgraceful.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I represent two very large countries. With these changes I believe I will be able to provide a better service for the people I represent. I will have a better opportunity to attend to constituents, to visit people in their homes or in various centres, to attend party meetings or gatherings, or to attend at meetings of different associations or groups. On many occasions I will be able to leave here at 7 o'clock on Tuesday evening and I will be able to attend these functions when I get home. A similar situation will arise on Wednesdays. I will be finished in this House at about 8.30 p.m. Up to now Deputies have been able to attend meetings on Thursday evenings.

I do not wish to be selfish and look at this from my personal viewpoint only. It must be looked at from the national viewpoint also. The Parliamentary Secretary set out the position in some detail. It has been made adequately clear to everybody that these changes are experimental. The Parliamentary Secretary and the Government are reasonable and, if it is found that these hours do not work out satisfactorily, a change will be made. I believe they will be satisfactory.

At present the House meets on Tuesday from 3 o'clock until 10.30 p.m. We may have to deal with the Committee Stage of complex legislation. It may be necessary for the Minister to have discussions with his senior civil servants on points raised by the Opposition. If the Minister finishes here at 10.30 p.m. he has until the following morning to have those discussions. He is back in the House the following morning at 10.30 a.m. This means that the Minister has not an adequate opportunity to discuss complex amendments or points put forward by the Opposition with his civil servants. The changes in the sitting hours will allow him to have those discussions and they are worthy of the utmost consideration by the Opposition. Reasonable people in the Opposition will see merit in this proposal.

Senior civil servants come into the House and offer their advice to the House through the Minister. We hear talk about a shorter working week. Civil Servants should have regular hours like other people in different jobs. I want to go on record as saying that the staff of this House have often served trojan hours, unbelievably long hours. They are here in the morning before 10.30 a.m., possibly at 9.30 a.m. and, if matters drag on, they are often here until a very late hour. They are back in again the following morning. Working such long hours under such pressure does not lead to efficiency. It does not lead to the care and attention which are so necessary when we are dealing with legislation which affects the daily life of everyone.

It may be said that there is not a lot of truth in what I am saying but I believe there is. We need adequate time to give thought and consideration to all the legislation which comes before the House. If we believe in what we are saying, if we are to have the exchange of thought and ideas which is so important in a democracy, if we believe in the significance and importance of this House we, the Government, our Ministers, our civil servants, and everybody involved in this process, should have adequate time for consideration and discussion.

This House should be giving a lead to the rest of the country and show that we are transacting our business in a workmanlike fashion. The present hours are not normal business hours, and if the proposed hours are accepted this House will be more in line with the day to day life of the community. As a result, the hours during which Deputies work will be more normal and regular and there will be a similar situation in regard to our civil servants, the staff in this House and also the Press Gallery staff. I believe the people will be pleased to see this House modernising itself.

Deputy Haughey has mentioned tradition. I am as keen on tradition as anybody else here. However, tradition is one thing; keeping in touch with changes in living is another thing. By changing our hours of work we shall be coming more in touch with the day to day life of the people. I am surprised the Opposition are not in full agreement with this proposal. While I appreciate it is the job of the Opposition to oppose, I would have thought they would have regarded this proposal as an improvement.

Comment on this

Why did the Government not get our agreement to it?

Comment on this

On a point of order, Deputy Enright has been talking about a much more normal situation in regard to the proposed hours——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

A point of order, Deputy.

Comment on this

Would he like to refer to the heating going off at 4 o'clock in the day? Is that the proposed hours the Deputy has in mind?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

That does not come within my responsibility.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair regrets very much the lack of heat in the Chamber and in the House generally. I understand it is due to an industrial dispute. The staff involved are under the control of the Office of Public Works. While I am not conversant with all the details, I understand the staff in question are restricting their work. The Whips of the parties have been advised of this matter. I am sorry for the inconvenience it is causing to Members and staff.

Comment on this

Would you consider getting the Minister for Labour back from whatever social function he is attending to settle this dispute?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Out of courtesy I gave this information to the Members, but the matter may not be discussed now. It is essentially a matter for the Office of Public Works.

Comment on this

We will soldier on.

Comment on this

We will generate our own heat.

Comment on this

Is Deputy Allen satisfied?

Comment on this

No, I am not. The Deputy has not enlightened me on that situation. I thought the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach might enlighten us on the situation.

Comment on this

I have expressed my views on this proposal which I believe is a good one leading to efficiency and to business being transacted in a more businesslike way. If a Minister has to be in this House at 10.30 in the morning having been in the House until 10.30 p.m. the previous night, he cannot give of his best involved in long tedious discussions. I believe the hours proposed are reasonable and I am in wholehearted agreement with this proposal.

Comment on this

Is that what is wrong with the Government? They are working too long hours.

Comment on this

The only reason I speak in this debate is that I happen to be a long-distance Deputy. This proposal is arranged to suit Dublin and Leinster. If I could go home at night, I would be in agreement with these hours because we could do a lot at home. Anybody living over 100 miles from Dublin could not go home at night and be here the next morning. It might be said: "It is impertinent of you having been here only two years to express views on this matter. You might not be here at all after the rearrangement of the constituencies." However, if we are here for only a week, we are entitled to make our views known.

A Deputy might have to call on a Department, and the normal hours of sitting enabled him to do that on Wednesday morning. Under the new arrangement, if he is off at half-past eight he can go to no Department at that time. There are times when you cannot do your business by telephone, and Wednesday morning is very important to a rural Deputy if he has to call to the Land Registry or some other Department. When the Dáil is sitting it is a Deputy's duty to be here to listen to what is going on. Deputy O'Malley suggested that we could acquaint ourselves with the culture of Dublin. I often came to Dublin when I was younger and when I was anxious to see the city. After 8 o'clock there are not many places you can get into. If a rural Deputy wants to go to a show he cannot go at that time of night. If you are here until half past eight, it is just as well to stay until half past ten.

Comment on this

Absolute common sense.

Comment on this

It would be better if it could be 6 o'clock in the evening but I do not believe that is on because no rural Deputy would agree to sitting on Friday or Monday. It should be remembered that rural Deputies must meet their constituents and if they do not have Monday and Friday for this they will have to spend Sunday meeting them. This change is all right for the Dublin Deputies and the Ministers. If the Dáil met in Galway, I would like to be finishing at 7 o'clock in the evening and to be home within an hour because I could go to a show or enjoy myself at something else. The change in the hours is detrimental to the Deputy who lives a long distance from Dublin because when the House adjourns at 8.30 p.m. he has nowhere to go except to his hotel. He cannot go to a show or get a chance to see Dublin life.

Comment on this

He could go to Harold's Cross to the dogs.

Comment on this

Dr. FitzGerald's cultural Dublin.

Comment on this

Did the Government consider the Deputies from Cork, Kerry, Mayo or Donegal? Is the change being made to suit the Ministers and the province of Leinster? Rural Deputies in the winter months could not go home when the House rises at 8.30 p.m. because they would have to contend with adverse weather conditions early the following morning in order to be in Dublin for a 10.30 a.m. start. If Deputies from rural areas decide to go home when the House rises at 8.30 p.m. in the winter months, I can see a lot of accidents occurring as they try to make it to Dublin by 10.30 a.m. the following morning.

I do not agree with the change proposed and I was disappointed that the time of the House was taken up on a matter which should be considered by the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. We should be considering legislation rather than discussing a motion of this type. I was sorry that more Mayo Deputies did not speak because they will be affected most by this change. I am not opposing this simply for the sake of opposition but because I believe it is unfair on the rural Deputies. It is convenient for those who live in and convenient to Dublin because they can go home at night.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary's speech strikes me as a patronising piece of parliamentary poppycock.

Comment on this

A super piece of alliteration.

Comment on this

There is no doubt that this script was not written by a civil servant; it has certainly the hallmark of the Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach and that is clearly indicated by this patronising remark:

The Government makes no complaint about the conduct of the Opposition in this regard,

How dare the Government?

Comment on this

The Deputy sounds like an old nanny.

Comment on this

That is exactly what I am trying to deal with here.

Comment on this

Nothing makes you happy.

Comment on this

We are really dealing with the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary is aware that 90 per cent of his Deputies tried to forestall him in bringing this piece of nonsense into the House.

Comment on this

And he forced them into the House to talk on the motion.

Comment on this

I imagine the Deputy would like the new hours.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary also stated:

The proposal will have the specific benefit for members of the Government...

Is that another good reason why the Parliamentary Secretary is introducing this change?

Comment on this

It certainly is.

Comment on this

Is the simple truth of the matter not that the Parliamentary Secretary is introducing these hours to suit the members of the Government and nobody else and the convenience of the other Deputies, Fine Gael, Fianna Fáil or Labour, does not matter? You also make the remark that 55 per cent of all Deputies reside——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should address his remarks through the Chair rather than direct to the Parliamentary Secretary or anybody else.

Comment on this

The Chair can take it that if I am looking at the Parliamentary Secretary I am directing my remarks to the Chair, if that is any consolation.

The Parliamentary Secretary said that a check of the Dáil roll would show that a clear majority, about 55 per cent of all Deputies, reside within about one-a-and-half hours drive of Leinster House. This is a clear piece of discrimination against the other 45 per cent of the Deputies. Have they no rights? Are they not to be considered? Did the Parliamentary Secretary include in this figure members of his own party? Does he not feel that he is discriminating against them?

The Parliamentary Secretary is a member of a Dublin orientated Government and this piece of Dáil timing is for the benefit of those living within the Dublin region. There can be no question about that.

Comment on this

Another Jimmy Tully.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary told us that the Government feels such a change would lead to a more business-like Dáil. Does that mean business-like hours or does it mean business-like methods for dealing with legislation? We all know that the record of the Government, and the Parliamentary Secretary, in respect of reforming legislation is deplorable. Will the changes mean that the House will have a better legislative record in the context of reforming legislation?

Comment on this

I will make the Deputy a present of this: changing the hours alone will not do it but it is a step towards it.

Comment on this

I thought there was a prospect that this was what the Parliamentary Secretary was really after.

Comment on this

The hours are more or less the same as before.

Comment on this

Exactly the same.

Comment on this

Is it not just another trick-o-the-loop job by the Parliamentary Secretary to pretend that the Government are a reforming government? It is another gimmick.

Comment on this

It is not.

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary serious when he says that this in some way will introduce a more business-like method into the lives of Deputies? Which Deputy has the hours of a businessman? Is it the intention to introduce business hours so that Deputies will be more businesslike?

Comment on this

What is wrong with business men?

Comment on this

There is nothing wrong with them, but Deputies lead a far different life and their hours are far longer. If business men worked as many hours as Deputies, the country might not be in the economic mess it is—compliments of the Coalition Government. A Deputy's day begins at 8.30 a.m. when the telephone starts to ring, on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday——

Comment on this

And Sunday.

Comment on this

He may have constituents calling to him on a Sunday, and welcome. We have our clinics on Saturdays and sometimes on Friday nights and sometimes on Sundays.

Comment on this

They now have two extra nights.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary said that is not the reason for the change in the hours—it is to allow Deputies to get back to their families or to attend functions. Where?

Comment on this

Would Deputy Enright enlighten us how many hours of driving he has to do from Dublin?

Comment on this

Two hours.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Andrews must be allowed continue without interruption.

Comment on this

A Deputy's day does not necessarily begin and end in Dáil Éireann. It can begin with meeting constituents; it can entail four or five meetings with departmental officials or local authority officials. If he is lucky enough to get his tea, it can involve two or three meetings—they may be organisation meetings, but they are meetings and part of his work. Now he is being asked to come along at 2.30 p.m. on Tuesday until 8.30 and at 10.30 a.m. on Wednesdays. What about the rural Deputies? Deputy Enright may travel home but what about the man living outside the arbitrary radius suggested by the Parliamentary Secretary, one-and-a-half hours? What about the Deputy who having gone home, the following morning finds himself up to his neck in snow? Will the Dáil then go into suspension? Is not that Deputy putting his life in danger? Have not those living outside the magic one-and-a-half hour radius set down by the Parliamentary Secretary to be considered? They are not being considered.

The Parliamentary Secretary knows that the law should be applied to all equally, but there is no equality here. It is all right to talk about businesslike hours if the Dáil were doing its business as the Parliamentary Secretary suggests. However, I think he will agree that the legislative record of this Government in the past three years has been abominable. Oh, we had the taxation package which has done as much good to the country as nothing —appalling pieces of legislation.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy repeal them when he gets in?

Comment on this

What I should like to see done is the fulfilling of the promises made by the Parliamentary Secretary when he came into Government, all of a sudden and much to his surprise, that he would introduce all sorts of reforming legislation. What reforming legislation has been introduced?

Comment on this

We made it possible for Fianna Fáil barristers to get into the Law Library.

Comment on this

This is a gimmick. What has that got to do with deprived children?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We must get back to the motion before the House.

Comment on this

What has it got to do with family law reform?

Comment on this

I have given the Deputy one example in regard to his own profession.

Comment on this

What has it got to do with deprived children? They have not introduced one iota of reforming legislation.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy should relate more closely to the motion on sittings and business of the Dáil.

Comment on this

If the proposed hours would do anything about the situation I have outlined we would find them acceptable, but this is another piece of soft shoe shuffling to fool the people outside that they are doing something. They are doing damn all. This type of time shifting is a fraud. I was Chief Whip of a Government for almost three years—Deputy O'Malley mentioned it and it was introduced by Deputy Lalor—and I know that to have the work of the House ordered in a businesslike way, to use the Fine Gael expression, it was necessary to have co-operation between the Whips. The Parliamentary Secretary brought along spurious proposals to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges which were opposed vehemently by us, supported with equal vehemence by members of his own party and the Labour Party who do not seem to be concerned with this. I do not wish to take advantage of their absence, but they have not got the guts to come in here and say publicly what they said behind closed doors. Then we are to get the what I may call Deputies' "holy hour"——

Comment on this

We will scrap that if the Deputy likes but the people who will be suffering will be the official reporting staff.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary would love to have that added hardship. This "holy hour" is to be introduced as a concession. I do not think any Deputy has objected to working 12 hours——

Comment on this

Very few Deputies, except Ministers, work here for 12 hours.

Comment on this

I am talking about outside and inside.

Comment on this

The Dáil does not have to be sitting.

Comment on this

Deputy Callanan does.

Comment on this

At the end of his statement the Parliamentary Secretary emphasised to the House "that the hours now proposed are experimental". That is a laugh. The Parliamentary Secretary knows that when these hours become the order they will remain permanently. He continued:

If they are not found generally acceptable, they will not be made permanent,

I do not believe that and I do not believe the Parliamentary Secretary believes it either—widely acceptable to him, but not widely acceptable to members of the Opposition. Is it an umbrella acceptance by the whole House or is it a selective opening of the umbrella to cover the Government benches only? These hours will not be widely acceptable. They will become widely acceptable to the Members constituting the parties in Government because they will be told: "Gentlemen, it has now become widely acceptable to you, and that is it." As far as this side of the House is concerned, we believe these hours will never become widely acceptable

It is, of course, important that account should be taken of the staff. They do an extremely difficult job extremely well and anything we can do to accommodate them should be done. But Members of this House and members of the staff come second to the institution of Dáil Éireann. Let the members of the staff not be fooled by the Parliamentary Secretary's concern for them. They will still have to work the same hours. This is just an exercise in juggling and no one should be taken in by it. Exactly the same number of hours will have to be worked. There will be no decrease in work. The Parliamentary Secretary knows the old adage that talk expands to fill the time available.

Comment on this

The Deputy is giving an illustration of that himself now.

Comment on this

I am just as guilty as the Parliamentary Secretary. There is no question about that. If the Parliamentary Secretary had any real concern about hours he might have thought of bringing in some form of limitation on debate. That would be the proper approach. Let us not be fooled by the Parliamentary Secretary's attempt on behalf of the Government to con people into believing this will improve the business of the Dáil. It will do nothing of the kind.

Comment on this

May I ask the Parliamentary Secretary a question with regard to the wording of the motion? The motion stipulates:

That notwithstanding anything in Standing Orders the following arrangements relating to business and sittings on Tuesdays and Wednesdays shall apply on and from Tuesday, 3rd February, 1976, until the adjournment for the Easter Recess.

Which Easter Recess?

Comment on this

The Easter Recess of this year.

Comment on this

Should that not be stated?

Comment on this

I would think it is self-explanatory.

Comment on this

Could I have an explanation? The motion simply refers to the Easter Recess.

Comment on this

If I am to take that as a serious question, to put the Deputy's mind at ease I am giving him a positive assurance that the Government's intention in regard to the words mentioned mean the Easter Recess 1976 and he need not be a bit afraid that, when the time comes, the Government will say it is the Easter Recess next year or any subsequent year. It is the Easter Recess, 1976.

Comment on this

In the interests of drafting should the motion not state which Easter Recess is referred to?

Comment on this

No. That is absolutely unnecessary. The motion is quite clear and only someone mulling over it would be thinking this up at this stage after six or seven Opposition Members have spoken on it.

Comment on this

If there is a backlog we might have no Easter Recess until 1977.

Comment on this

Is it not contrary to procedure to ask us to adopt a motion so vague and uncertain in its terms?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair assumes from the Parliamentary Secretary's reply to the Deputy's question that it is the Easter Recess, 1976.

Comment on this

The Chair assumes?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Parliamentary Secretary said 1976.

Comment on this

Are you asking us, a Leas-Cheann Comhairle, to deal with a motion on the basis that the Chair assumes something?

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Deputy asked a question which was answered by the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

I submit it has not been answered by the Parliamentary Secretary. All I got from the Parliamentary Secretary was a gratuitous insult in reply to a perfectly straightforward, valid question by me.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Chair interprets it as being 1976.

Comment on this

That should surely be in the motion.

Comment on this

I want to propose that the year 1976 be inserted after "Recess".

Comment on this

I am perfectly happy to agree to do that.

Motion, by leave, amended accordingly.

Comment on this
John M. Kelly Parliamentary Secretary to the Taoiseach (Mr. Kelly) Fine Gael

I have made notes of a great number of points made by various speakers and I propose now to deal with what seemed to me to be the most important points. Deputy Lalor opened for the Opposition and he said I deliberately left out of my opening statement—this was adverted to by subsequent speakers also—the fact that the Fianna Fáil proposal in the letter to me would have meant longer rather than shorter hours. There were several complaints from Opposition speakers about the headline in The Cork Examiner—I did not see that headline and I did not know about it until it was quoted here —the implication being that Fianna Fáil were responsible for opposing longer hours of sitting and that we were the people pushing for longer sittings. The last proposal made by the Fianna Fáil side did propose longer hours. I did not deliberately suppress that fact. I tried to keep my opening remarks short; they occupied six or eight minutes, unlike many of the subsequent speeches. I am perfectly willing to agree now that the latest Fianna Fáil proposal did involve a certain number of extra hours. We do not propose that now. The original proposal did propose it. I think there will be no need for it once we have this enormous volume of taxation legislation out of the way.

I should like now to recall to the House—this relates to something Deputy O'Malley said; whenever he gets the chance he refers to the informal committee which sat under his chairmanship—the fact that that committee proposed that more special committees should be used. I do not intend to tread on anyone's toes but to date we have got very little co-operation in this regard. Only three Bills have so far been referred to special committees. I may be wrong by a Bill or two, but I believe only three have been so far referred to a special committee. The taxation measures through which we slogged here last year cried out for special committees. They were kept here in the House with the political intention of breaking the Government's neck, and for no other reason, day after day and week after week by the ex-Minister for Finance and a couple of self-appointed Opposition spokesmen, holding the House in Committee day in and day out and week in and week out, a performance that would not be tolerated in any Parliament in Europe. When the Government saw what was going on here last year—the Opposition did not, of course, succeed in breaking our necks—they decided to bring some sense into the Dáil and that is how this idea evolved. Last year for the first time in the history of the Dáil, it broke 1,000 sitting hours. We had something like 110 or 112 divisions last year——

Comment on this

What did it achieve?

Comment on this

These divisions were not asked for by the Government; they were enforced on us by the Opposition. The divisions were four times as many as they had been even in quite active years of the Dáil's existence. It was done for one purpose only, to try physically to wear us down so that we would trip over ourselves and be beaten. However, we disappointed that expectation and we will do so again.

I heard Deputy O'Malley talk about a Pyrrhic victory—it is over-generous of him and Deputy Haughey to warn me in this matter—and he said I would pay for it. That theme was repeated by three Deputies this evening. Am I and the Government to take it that we are being deliberately threatened with obstruction, not in the business of the Fianna Fáil Party but in the people's business? Are we being threatened with obstruction if the Government finally make up their minds what they will do with regard to work in this House? I hope that is not the intention, but certainly some of the expressions used this evening sounded like it. I accept, and I have said so repeatedly in this House, even to the point of being what Deputy Andrews probably calls patronising——

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary should not be nice to me.

Comment on this

The truth is that business is done by a substantial measure of agreement and understanding between both sides at Whip level. I accept that and on umpteen occasions I have paid tribute to the fact that generally it goes very well. I have tried to make it clear that I acknowledge the well-meaning minds which produce that effect in the Opposition. I am afraid to say any more about it in case I am accused of condescending to Deputy Lalor or Deputy Browne, whom I hope we will see soon in the House again. However, there are some matters on which the Government have had nothing but failure with regard to the business of this House, that is trying to secure from the Opposition some kind of reasonable deal in regard to the way business is done.

Deputy O'Malley referred to the proposed Committee on Dáil Procedure with great pride, but he did not say that the body of the recommendations makes it clear that what the committee meant was the very frequent use of Special Committees. Once the sides changed, and Fianna Fáil were on the opposite side, it did not suit them any longer to send Bills to special committees. They would prefer to be in here trying to break the Government's neck, up and down the steps, sitting here night after night with Committee Stage debates——

Comment on this

Individual amendments were debated for up to two days and there were occasions when the Committee Stage speeches from the Opposition were essentially Second Stage speeches. We had a situation where individual Deputies were arrogating to themselves the position of spokesmen to which they were not appointed by their Leader. Last year one Deputy, single-handed, cost this House three weeks' time at the very least——

Comment on this

Is the Parliamentary Secretary referring to the Minister for Posts and Telegraphs?

Comment on this

That is the way we were met with regard to special committees. We were given various excuses. One of the main excuses was that these measures were too controversial to be sent out of the body of the House to what was supposed to be the obscurity behind closed doors of a special committee. I agree the first two taxation Bills were controversial but the last of the Bills was not even voted on at the end of the Second Stage. The Opposition did not even challenge a vote on the Capital Acquisitions Tax Bill but that did not stop them maintaining that in some way they were prevented from permitting it going to a special committee. Many days were taken up in this House dealing with that Bill.

I understand that there are arguments about the "importance" of a Bill. That kind of sanctimonious talk can be made about any Bill or motion, no matter how trivial. I appreciate that argument exists in the case of the Capital Acquisitions Tax Bill. The truth is that most Deputies did not take part in that debate; they could not have done so because they did not know enough about taxation matters to contribute and I concede that number includes myself. I am not trying to pretend that it is only the others who are not able to take part in a fiscal debate. That was a debate that should have taken place in a Special Committee while the body of the Dáil got on with other work.

That was the situation that existed last year. We fought our way through and we are almost out of the far side of the capital taxation package. In addition, we have digested large measures in the last three years that were extremely contentious; I am referring to the Committee Stage of the Planning Bill and the legislation dealing with constituency revision. It may be that we are coming into a period when Bills will not necessarily take up quite that length of time on Committee Stage. I express the hope once again, in spite of many disappointments, that the Opposition will agree to send something like a continuous stream of Bills to special committees. If that were done there would not be any need for sitting the gruelling, inhuman hours we sat last summer and for several weeks before Christmas.

Comment on this

Will the Parliamentary Secretary indicate if backbenchers on his side of the House intend to take part in debate in this House? There was no one when we were debating the Capital Acquisitions Tax Bill and only the Minister has spoken so far on the Criminal Law (Jurisdiction) Bill.

Comment on this

Where a debate is going to continue for weeks or for months it is important to try not to hold up one's own side unduly. I never asked any other Fine Gael Deputy to contribute on Committee Stage on the capital taxation Bills and I would not do so now. To use a word used this evening, I do not see why just for the optics of it I should push into the benches here, if I were able to do so, some Deputy——

Comment on this

It is an indication of a lack of interest in these matters.

Comment on this
Denis F. Jones An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fine Gael

The Parliamentary Secretary should be be allowed to make his speech.

Comment on this

One of our Deputies was so interested in it that he would not vote for it. He understood it so well—although he formed a different view of it from that of the Government —that he did not even vote for it. He contributed a few times, not very much, but that does not say he was not interested.

The Opposition's attitude to Dáil reform forms part of the background against which this measure is being proposed. I have already recited their unwillingness, except in a few cases, to agree to special committees and their absolute unwillingness that the special committees should be used to the extent that the Opposition, when in Government, intended that they should. They were very willing to take the benefit of the Private Members' time, which was given them in heaping measure, compared with anything they gave to the Opposition. They were so willing they made us vote in order to disallow it in budget week. They expected the Minister for Finance to come to the House on budget day and on the day before in order to discuss something that could just as easily be discussed next week —in any case it can be discussed on Thursday morning when the budget debate opens. They will take all but what will they give?

Another sphere in which I have not been able to get agreement, except on rare occasions, is on a timetable. On umpteen occasions I have gone to Deputy Lalor and to the spokesmen on whose behalf he has to act in regard to these matters and I said: "Look, have as much time as you like with this Bill or the other Bill. Write your own timetable, but let us know what it is, so that we will be able to plan something here, so that we will know not just when we are going on our holidays but so that we will be able to draw up a schedule of Dáil business which we can rely on for a period ahead." While I know that Deputy Lalor is sympathetic to that, he has to do the job his party instruct him to do. I was never able to get, except on very rare occasions and in very limited measure, agreement out of him for something which in other Parliaments is taken for granted.

We are at sea here. We are drowning in words, with time being recklessly squandered, and no Government could possibly get through its business; particularly with the difficulties which the Opposition are so fond of adverting to, without occasionally—I use this expression advisedly—taking the Dáil and the Opposition by the scruff of the neck and forcing something to be done within a certain amount of time or according to a certain measure of reason. No Government could do it and if Fianna Fáil were in and did not do it they would be highly culpable.

I have heard them point to their own generosity on one occasion in allowing Deputy Cruise-O'Brien to speak for six hours on the definition of one word. They were at fault in allowing him to speak for that length of time. They should have put a closure on him five hours earlier. They come along now and throw in our teeth their ignorance of where their duty lay when they were in Government and ruled the country and the Dáil simultaneously, and represent as tolerance, what is simply recklessness and witlessness. Deputy Cruise-O'Brien went to town on it, and by doing so he showed up the Government that were at that time sitting here.

Comment on this

Was he right or wrong?

Comment on this

He is now a Minister.

Comment on this

The Opposition asked how we could deal with arrears. I hope they will not build up to the frightening extent they were building up to last summer and in the time before Christmas and once these taxation matters are out of the way, these block-busters, we will be in a period when we have plenty of business but it will be less lengthy in terms of time taken up in Committee. I will also freely admit that in 1974, for reasons which may have had something to do with a change around in Government and policies —I hope this will be taken in the spirit in which it is said—and the fact that Ministers had not got used to making their Departments keep to a timetable there were periods when we were almost free-wheeling when Estimate debates went on from day to day for weeks on end and were interrupted only to make room for further Estimate debates. We were then accused of free-wheeling. Now, there is scarcely time for an Estimate debate because the legislation is so voluminous. We are asked why we are not giving time to discuss the immense sums of money being paid out. Naturally an Opposition cannot easily be made happy and they would not be a good Opposition if they were made happy.

During parts of 1973 and early 1974 we were free-wheeling in the Dáil. That all ceased about the beginning of last year and we have seen what an inhuman schedule has been worked since then. I hope, as I said, that we will come into a period when that will not be quite so necessary. If extra hours are needed they cannot any longer come out of Wednesday morning but without inflicting on Deputies any inconvenience—not on those who spoke against it because they seem to like these hours—they can be extended by stretching business up to the old hour of 10.30 on Tuesday and Wednesday. That alone would give us four extra hours in the week. I hope that will not be necessary but it can be done without any severe inconvenience and certainly without an inconvenience which anybody is not accustomed to.

Deputy Brennan, in a way, made the most straightforward point from the other side when he said that he did not see why he should be asked to make things easy for the Government. It is quite true that a substantial part of the motives, and for me even a decisive element in the motives, behind this motion would be to make life easy for the Ministers who bear a burden which four or five Deputies on the far side this evening must remember very well. I do not apologise for seeking to make life easier for them—I naturally understand that Deputy Brennan does not see why he should be asked to contribute to this effort—I do not apologise for trying to do this. We should not forget—the people on the far side will remember this from their own experience—that when 7 o'clock in the evening comes, which is the hour we proposed in the original proposal which got such opposition in the Committee on Procedure and Privileges, the average Minister has a ten-hour day already behind him. He is not any longer a very young man. He is not even necessarily a man in the best of health and he is asked, just because he may be required to pass through the Division Lobby, to sit around here for a further three-and-a-half hours. He cannot work because although his room is comfortable it does not provide the facilities of an office. He cannot fit in all the officials he may wish to see. He cannot keep his entire Department hanging around here in the anterooms. He cannot relax and he cannot see his family or sample the cultural activities of the city. He cannot do anything except sit around here. I make no apology for saying that that is a grinding and indefensible waste of the time of a man who, even though you may dislike his party or him, deserves because of his office some consideration. If this Government consisted of people who were lazy I would be ashamed to make that argument. I am glad to say that no Opposition Deputy thought of making that argument. Not one of them had the gall to allege that under the expression "making life easier for Ministers" what was really meant was "accommodating lazy men". They are not lazy and everyone in the House and outside it knows that. It may be that many of them spend a lot of their time as has been alleged——

Comment on this

Parliamentary Secretary Flanagan would be able to sample the cultural activities of this city.

Comment on this

——in political, as distinct from official, work. That is something the former Government did as well and the one before that. That is an unavoidable part of politics. It is even a part which I guess many office holders do not even like and never liked, but it is unavoidable. It is there for better or worse. It is part of the democratic process about which there were so many sanctimonious tears shed. Any man who becomes a Minister in this or any country has fought his way to the top through a gruelling political process and a gruelling personal process. It has made horrible demands on his health, on his happiness very often and on his relations with his family and friends. When he gets to the top, whatever one may think of him, his party or his policies, he is somebody who demands and deserves consideration. I make no apology for saying that men who have reached that situation and who carry that terrible responsibility ought not to be treated in the way I have to treat Ministers night after night who come into my office grey with exhaustion, some of them almost dropping with exhaustion, and asking if in God's name they can be let go home and I have to say to them: "I am very sorry, you cannot because we could have a vote at 10.25. Please do not go until the screen goes blank". That is the truth of the matter about Ministers and I make no apology for expressing it vehemently. I most certainly will not pretend that in my book at least it is not a major part of the motives behind this motion.

That is not to say that the other arguments which I mentioned this evening are only shadow arguments or were not seriously intended. I intend them absolutely seriously. It is hypocrisy for a Deputy to pretend that he is not interested in press coverage. I am sure that every Whip who was ever in my job has had the experience of finding a Deputy very anxious to speak at four o'clock or five o'clock, even perhaps still anxious at six o'clock, but no longer still anxious once seven o'clock comes and still less anxious once eight o'clock comes and absolutely unwilling, although he may be a man whom you want to get to speak, once nine o'clock arrives. Why? Not necessarily because he is tired, but because he will not reach the people he wants to reach. There is no use talking sanctimoniously and ponderously about "this House". Who is "the House" at that stage? "The House" is a bored Minister and a bored Opposition spokesman. That is the reality of the matter. Not Deputy O'Leary writing his letters four storeys up or Deputy Callanan, and not the Press gallery, because even if they are there, there is a limit to what they can do for this Deputy, no matter what he has to say, at that time of the night. I have seen Deputies from both sides of the House with very fine and important speeches to make being blotted out the following morning, not through any ill-will on the part of the Press, but because the material cannot be written, edited and printed at that time of the night.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary will be well published tomorrow morning.

Comment on this

I believe I enjoy the support of the Press on this motion if on nothing else. It is dishonest to pretend that coverage in the Press does not weigh with Deputies. It weighs with every Deputy who ever came into this House. To pretend that the Press does not exist is a polite fiction, which we have taken over from the English, like so many other things, and is also dishonest. Daniel O'Connell, one of the greatest Irish parliamentarians ever bred, said that the Press gallery had become the Fourth Estate of the realm. He did not put a tooth in it.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary is denigrating James Dillon.

Comment on this

He knew their importance. It is childish to pretend that importance is not there, and it is childish to represent an argument based on the exigencies of printing the daily Press as being of no importance or as something I should have been ashamed to introduce here.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary does not understand this House.

Comment on this

I hope I will get through it with fewer scars than the Deputy has collected.

Comment on this

I will survive my scars and if it is left to the democratic process I will be here longer than the Parliamentary Secretary.

Comment on this

Deputy Brennan said he was not opposed to the rational review of procedures in this House. I am delighted to hear that, but what procedures in this House would he like to change, in what direction, and how far would he go to meet anything the Government want to do? That is what I would like to hear. If he has anything in his mind about that, perhaps he might pass it on to Deputy Lalor and we can talk about it the next time we meet.

Comment on this

At the Committee on Procedure and Privileges.

Comment on this

Deputy O'Brien followed him and supported me. As time is getting on, I will not deal with what he said. Deputy Haughey made the point that the Committee on Procedures and Privileges was the body to deal with matters of this kind. I agree that that committee conventionally have the job of dealing with matters of this kind, but I do not agree that the Government are doing anything against the letter or the spirit of Standing Orders or the conventions of this House in making up their own minds, after lengthy discussions and negotiations and even lengthy and bitter debates in the Committee on Procedure and Privileges, in coming directly before the House with this motion.

The Standing Order which Deputies quoted from earlier refers to the rule of the Committee on Procedure and Privileges and says, among other things, that it is the committee's job to recommend amendments and additions to Standing Orders. We had a quibble here a half an hour ago about why 1976 was not filled in in the motion. I will give a quibble that will to that. This is not an addition or an amendment to Standing Orders, it is a temporary arrangement which will override Standing Orders. I completely agree that if it were intended as an addition in Standing Orders which would be printed in the book, then what is proposed this evening could not, under any conditions, achieve that status. If it were that, it would be the business of the committee to make a recommendation on it before this House acted, although even then I would maintain the right of the Government to bring forward a motion without a recommendation. I agree that were a formal permanent amendment or addition being proposed it would, under Standing Orders, be the job of the committee to make a recommendation, even though I do not agree that the Government could not act in the absence of such a recommendation.

Comment on this

Why did the Parliamentatry Secretary not go back to the committee.

Comment on this

I could deal with that but I have not very much time and I want to get this finished if possible.

I have already dealt with some of Deputy O'Malley's points. In referring to the Press he gave a severe spanking to The Cork Examiner for what they said about his party. Although, as he kept telling us, he is in politics much longer than any of us on this side, he seems to have a much thinner skin than those of us who are junior to him have developed. He then went on to talk about Press commentators in general.

I will tell him something about Press commentators which is highly relevant to this motion and the amount of understanding which is brought to bear on the business of this House. Some time last autumn I read a commentator who was lecturing me along the following lines: it was my job to twist the arm of the Opposition into accepting a special committee for the Committee Stages of these taxation Bills. I said to myself, there is a man who has been sitting in the Press gallery and has been around this House for some time and I would like him to tell me, or any Government Whip, how one goes about twisting Deputy Lalor's arm when it is being held rigid by Deputies O'Malley, Haughey, Gibbons and every other Fianna Fáil man who sees in a proposal about Dáil procedure from this side only a means to obstruct and annoy people they are hoping to put out politically. I have never succeeded in being able to twist that arm and I do not believe that any other Whip in my situation would have any greater success. That is what the Press think I should be doing, persuading, cajoling or even bullying the Opposition into agreeing to a special committee on taxation Bills, even though they may not wish to agree to do so. That degree of understanding of a Whip's job does not augur very well for the degree of understanding which may be brought to bear on Dáil procedure as a whole. I can only hope and pray that the arguments advanced here on both sides this evening have made sense to that commentator.

Deputy Enright mentioned an argument which I had forgotten. It is perfectly true that a Minister stuck in this House on successive days, Tuesday and Wednesday, with a long Bill on Committee Stage or Report Stage will want to consult his officials at the end of one day and before the next day begins. Of course, that is true and Deputy Enright was right to make that point. The Minister will now have an extra two hours—and a more civilised two hours—than was previously the case to do this.

Deputy Callanan said he could not get home at night. I was glad of his intervention because he was man enough to admit the point I was trying to make at another stage in my opening speech. He said—and I wrote down what he said—"you can do a lot if you can go home at night". This is an advantage which Deputy Enright admitted and will be shared by Deputy Lalor. Deputy Enright lives two hours from Dublin but to suggest that it will not be an advantage to an enormous number of Deputies who live that same distance, is to neglect the realities of geography and politics.

Comment on this

Deputy Andrews thought it was very wrong to talk about business-like hours. He seemed to have high scorn for businessmen and the way they operate. I cannot see anything wrong with taking a leaf out of the businessmen's book. They work when it is light and relax when it is dark.

Comment on this

The Government have proved that they are not businessmen.

Comment on this

To imitate the businessman, whom Deputy Andrews seemed to think was below imitation, would be no bad course for this House to take. Because Deputies have more irregular hours and more calls on their time than businessmen, I do not see why that should be an argument for imposing extra burdens on Deputies, for wasting time around this House when they could be doing something more useful elsewhere. I do not see why that is something that should be maintained.

Comment on this

We have been very gainfully employed for the past hour or so.

Comment on this

The last thing Deputy Andrews said was that he did not believe these hours would become widely acceptable. He seemed to be pressing me for a more exact statement of what I meant by "widely acceptable", or what the Government meant by it. I want to make it clear that I am not giving any kind of undertaking that the perpetuation of these hours, if they are perpetuated, will depend on unanimity. I am absolutely not giving that undertaking.

I will give the following undertaking. If the Government, on what I hope will be a fair understanding of "generally acceptable", come to the conclusion that these hours have worked well, and look like working even better coming into the long evenings of the summer, and do not receive sensible representations to the contrary, the Government will probably want to build them into the Standing Orders. If they wish to do that, naturally I will bring the matter back to the Committee on Procedure and Privileges. Lest it be cast in our teeth later on, I want to remove any suggestion that I am making any kind of promise that unanimity will be necessary in this regard. It will not be necessary. Governments do not operate by unanimity with the Opposition in matters of Dáil procedure or anything else. I have never experienced that happy state and I do not suppose it is reasonable to expect it. I do not want to be taken as giving any guarantee of that kind.

This has been a reasonably peaceful debate; I have enjoyed it in spots. I hope Deputies on all sides will receive some benefit from these hours and that they will try to see the good side of them. If there are serious arguments for improving them or for adapting them in directions we did not think of, any more than the Opposition did, I hope the Opposition will be open-minded and constructive enough to bring them forward according as they occur to them, so that we will get the Dáil into a more rational way of doing its business and one which at least does not only have the argument in favour of it that it has been done in the same way for the past 40 years. I commend the motion to the House.

Comment on this

May I put a question to the Parliamentary Secretary? I put it to him already and asked him to refer to it in his reply. The motion states:

...under Standing Order 123 shall have concluded and the Dáil shall adjourn not later than half an hour after the interruption of business.

I asked the Parliamentary Secretary if it was clear that would not interfere with votes which could take place after 8.30 p.m.

Comment on this

I understand that to refer to Standing Order 123 (3) which reads:

If at the time appointed for the interruption of business proceedings under this Order are in progress...

that is, divisions and estimates——

...the Ceann Comhairle shall not effect such interruption under the proceedings in connection with all divisions and questions outstanding shall have been completed.

Comment on this

The point I made was that the words "the Dáil shall adjourn not later than half an hour after the interruption of business" cuts across Standing Order 123 (3) which the Parliamentary Secretary quoted to show that it oversides everything else. My reading of this motion is that it would override Standing Order 123 (3).

Comment on this

As I understand it the reason for paragraph (1) of the motion being drafted in that way is that the last two lines and a bit are adapted from the intention of the Standing Orders in regard to adjournment debates.

Comment on this

Standing Order 123 (3) provides that if at the time appointed for the interruption of business proceedings a vote is going on it has to be allowed to be completed. The motion refers to half an hour after the interruption of business. If two votes were postponed from the previous Thursday and are being taken at 8.30 p.m. on Tuesday night, business could continue for more than half an hour. As I see it, the motion cuts across and negatives Standing Order 123 (3) to an extent.

Comment on this

Any outstanding votes will be taken in succession and thereafter there will be half an hour for an adjournment debate if it has been conceded.

Comment on this

If I were on the Government side I would not like to try to sell that. However, if the Parliamentary Secretary is happy about it that is all right with me.

Comment on this
Division

Motion, as amended, put.

Tá 65
·
Níl 62
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?