Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - High Court Decision.
- Defence Forces Discharge High Court Decision 4 speeches
The Minister says an appeal to the Supreme Court has been lodged and, because the case is sub judice, declines to discuss the discharge or possible effects on other personnel.
Joseph Dowling, Patrick S. Donegan
- Handling of Sub Judice Questions 10 speeches
Mr. Lynch questions why the current question was allowed when an earlier question of his was not. The Ceann Comhairle says the office had not been informed that the current matter was sub judice; the exchange does not establish whether the Taoiseach informed the office about the earlier matter.
Seán Treacy, John Lynch, Desmond J. O'Malley, James Tully
asked the Minister for Defence if he will make a statement on the result of the High Court decision on 17th December, 1975, relating to the discharge of a member of the Defence Forces (name supplied) and on the comments (details supplied) made by the Court.
Comment on this
The judge on that occasion indicated that the discharge of Private Gleeson constituted a denial of natural and constitutional justice. Could the Minister indicate if there were other personnel discharged from the Defence Forces on the same basis previously because it would seriously affect the gratuity of short-service personnel? If there is to be an inquiry as a result of the High Court case, would the Minister let us know the outcome?
Comment on this
Pending a decision by the Supreme Court the matter is sub judice and discussion of the case would not be in order.
Comment on this
May I ask the Chair to relate the reason why this question was allowed to appear on the Order Paper when it affects a matter which is clearly sub judice when a matter I raised last week which was not then sub judice was not permitted?
Comment on this
It would have been disallowed if my office had been informed that the matter was sub judice. We were unaware of the matter.
Comment on this
In that event, were steps taken by the Minister to whom I submitted the question, the Taoiseach in this case, to inform your office that the matter was sub judice last week?
Comment on this
In that event was your office given information by the Taoiseach last week to the effect that the other matter was sub judice?