Irish Life furniture and carpet contracts
Deputies questioned Irish Life’s decision to source office furniture abroad and sought Irish-made carpets. The Parliamentary Secretary said Irish firms had been approached and only a few could supply complete office-furniture ranges.
(Dublin Central) asked the Minister for Finance if he is aware that the contract to supply furniture for the new offices of Irish Life Assurance Co., of which he is a major shareholder, has been awarded to foreign manufacturers; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
22.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Finance if he is aware that a State-sponsored body, the Irish Life Assurance Company, has placed an order for office furniture with a company (name supplied) in County Dublin which is an importing agency and imports all its furniture from English and German firms and that no Irish furniture manufacturer was asked for quotations for the required furniture; and if he will consider holding an inquiry into this matter in view of the fact that so many are unemployed and Irish furniture manufacturers could have supplied this furniture.
23.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Finance if he will ensure that the Irish Life Assurance Company will place the order for the carpeting of their new building with an Irish manufacturer.
24.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Finance if he will ensure that all carpets and other floor coverings to be used in the new Irish Life Assurance Building will be of Irish manufacture.
25.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Finance whether the Irish Life Assurance Company considered buying English furniture in order to save £39,000 VAT; and whether they went to an Irish importing company only after this matter was raised in the Dáil.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 21 to 25, inclusive, together.
The first occasion on which the matter of the supply of office furniture to Irish Life came to my notice was on 20th October, 1975, when representations were made by Deputy Pat Joe Reynolds to me on behalf of a County Leitrim firm of office and contract furniture manufacturers.
On receipt of these representations extensive verbal inquiries were made by my Department of Irish Life, the IDA and Fóir Teo. My Department were informed that consultants had been engaged, that there were technical problems but that the matter was by no means settled. The company were made aware of my anxiety that everything possible should be done to place the contract in this country. The company's spokesman intimated that they were anxious to buy Irish and said the consultants had discussed the matter at length with the Industrial Development Authority. The company were asked to keep me informed.
On 17th and 20th November representations were made by the Minister for Labour and the general secretary of the Irish Transport and General Workers Union. A letter was sent by my Department to the company on 21st November and further verbal representations were made. The company's reply, received on 2nd December, said the matter was still under consideration and no order had been placed. In supplementary discussions my Department again stressed the importance of buying Irish and inquired if appropriate bodies, such as the IIRS, had been consulted with a view to enabling Irish firms to overcome technical or other difficulties. The company's spokesman gave an assurance that such steps had been taken and said that the placing of the contract was receiving very careful consideration.
On 11th December, in view of the gravity of the situation and notwithstanding the company's reply of 2nd December, another letter was sent on my instructions by the secretary of the Department of Finance to the managing director pointing out that there seemed to be widespread concern that the business might be placed abroad and asking that I be kept informed of developments. On 18th December the Department received a letter, bearing the date 15th December, from the company. Verbal inquiries by my Department on my instructions elicited the information that, although the letter contained the statement "we are in favour of accepting the recommendation of our consultants...", the contract had been placed irrevocably on the same date, namely 18th December, as the Irish Life letter had been received in my Department.
On 5th January the company were informed by my Department of the Government's intense disappointment that they had failed to make the necessary modifications in standards and arrangements with Irish manufacturers to ensure the manufacture of the furniture in Ireland.
Senior officers of my Department and I have on a number of occasions since had discussions with the chairman, managing director and property investment manager of the company. I have been furnished with copies of documentation relevant to the issue, which I have placed before the Government. Government inquiries into the matter are still proceeding.
In the meantime the company themselves, as the House will be aware, announced on 26th January that they were investigating urgently the feasibility of having the furniture in question manufactured in this country under licence. Discussions have taken place between the company and the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and a meeting has also been held with the Confederation of Irish Industry.
The contract does not concern carpets, which are referred to in two of the questions. I understand that it is the company's intention that these items should be purchased from Irish manufacturers.
As regards value-added tax, I wish to point out that imported furniture is liable at the same rate as furniture manufactured in the State.
At all times the best interests of Irish workers and industry, the company and their policyholders have been and will remain my primary concern.
Comment on this
(Dublin Central): Is the Parliamentary Secretary aware that the majority of furniture manufacturers in this country failed to obtain a specification or a tender form long before 9th January? I am told that has been brought to the attention of the Minister.
Comment on this
A number of companies were asked to quote. A detailed examination was made of the Irish furniture industry. I understand 33 firms were approached, of whom 20 are still manufacturing. Only three firms, including five firms in a consortium, produced total ranges of office furniture. These three were invited to tender. One declined and samples of the products of the other two firms were submitted.
Comment on this
Will the Parliamentary Secretary give the names of the two firms who submitted tenders?