Taxation of social welfare payments
Lemass asked whether contributory and non-contributory social welfare payments are taxable. Ryan said most cash payments are technically income, but in practice benefits are generally disregarded unless paid for over a year; non-contributory pensioners are not taxed, and tax on contributory pensions usually reflects other income. Lemass cited aggrieved correspondents, and Ryan acknowledged this was typical of tax questions.
asked the Minister for Finance if income tax is assessed on social welfare payments in respect of (a) contributory schemes and (b) non-contributory schemes.
Comment on this
Apart from the children's allowances, which are specifically exempted from income tax under section 354 of the Income Tax Act, 1967, there is no legislative provision to exempt other social welfare benefits or allowances from tax. Strictly speaking, therefore, all social welfare payments in cash, other than the death grant, are in the nature of income and as such would fall to be taken into consideration for tax purposes.
In practice, however, a benefit or allowance is disregarded for tax purposes unless it continues to be paid for a period in excess of one year. Because of the nature of the payments and of the means tests for payment of non-contributory allowances the question of the tax liability of the majority of social welfare payments does not arise.
Comment on this
Is it correct that people living on social welfare benefits or assistance can be taxed in the ordinary way?
Comment on this
The position, technically under the law, is that they can be, but, in practice, because of the exemption limits and so forth, people on non-contributory pensions are not taxed and in so far as persons who may be a receipt of contributory pensions are taxed the tax element invariably arises because they have income other than the contributory pension.
Comment on this
The Minister must be aware that the purpose of this question is as a result of correspondence I have received from people who feel aggrieved about the present situation.