Land Commission allocation delays
The Minister said 108,430 acres were held, about 90,440 of them lettable, and that roughly 34,353 acres had been allocated in 1975. He said land should normally be allocated within two years, though exceptional circumstances can delay it; he disputed that eight-year holdings were typical and cited tillage leases and falling acreage on hand.
asked the Minister for Lands the total acreage of land acquired for distribution and which has not yet been allocated.
Comment on this
(Cavan): The total area in possession of the Land Commission at 31st December, 1975, was 108,430 acres, approximately, of which about 90,440 acres were classified as lettable.
Comment on this
Can the Minister give an indication as to when any proportion of that land will be let?
Comment on this
(Cavan): The year just ended, 1975, has been one of the best years the Land Commission has had for many years in regard to both acquisition and allocation of land. Last year the Land Commission, on figures which are not yet checked but which are fairly accurate, allotted 34,353 acres. Taking one thing with another, the Deputy will see that the Land Commission have on hands about two years letting.
39.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Lands the normal time lag between the acquisition and the allocation of land.
Comment on this
(Cavan): There are standing instructions that all lands on hands should be allotted as quickly as possible and in any case should not be retained for longer than two years.
This is not always feasible however —for example where buildings are being erected or other improvements carried out, or where the preparation of resale proposals must be deferred pending the acquisition of other lands so that the scheme of division ultimately settled will be the best possible.
Since I assumed office, the inspectorate staff of the Land Commission has been strengthened with a view to ensuring that there will be no undue delay in this vital sector of the work of the Land Commission.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that there is an idea abroad that the Land Commission are holding land in some cases for as long as eight or ten years? If that is not true, will the Land Commission disabuse those people who are of that opinion?
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am aware that that idea is abroad but I think if we were to break down these cases and came to a situation where the Land Commission had land on hands for eight years we would find that there were peculiar circumstances, either relating to the acquisition of other lands, to the erection of buildings on the land or perhaps some trouble in the locality. I would say that eight years is very exceptional.
Comment on this
Will the Minister accept that there are many such cases of eight years and that when the Land Commission acquire or accept land and set it for tillage in their own minds they are embarking on an idea that the land will not be divided for some considerable time and that it will probably be set for some years? Will the Minister agree that there is a trend of thought abroad that the Land Commission attempt to get back some of the money they paid by setting the land and that when it is eventually handed over it is in a worse state than when they acquired it? I would ask the Minister not to dismiss my question lightly because it is based on experience.
Comment on this
(Cavan): First, I do not agree with the Deputy that eight years is typical or normal——
Comment on this
(Cavan): I am satisfied it is exceptional. Letting land for tillage is very exceptional. It has only come about in recent times in the west where there has been a direct, and I think a reasonable, request that the Land Commission should permit tillage in order to ensure a supply of beet for the Tuam factory. I must say that has my benediction within reason. I will give the Deputy some figures in this matter. In 1972 there were 129,726 acres on hand while at the present time there are only 108,430 acres on hand. The work is going on and it is improving. I want to make it clear to the House that I am exhorting the Land Commission, and will continue to do so, to get rid of land as quickly as they can. It is no pleasure to me to see land being held on hands for a long time but one swallow, or even 20 swallows, do not make a summer. I do not accept that a period of eight or ten years is normal—it is exceptional.