Equal pay extension and worker exemptions
The Minister said he could not estimate how many firms or women would be affected by the proposed exemption. It would require agreement by unions and employers, authenticated by the Labour Court, where immediate equal-pay implementation threatened jobs; without an exemption, the Act’s equal-pay requirement would apply. Members challenged the policy and sought clarification on employers’ obligations and enforcement.
asked the Minister for Labour the number of women workers who are affected by the Government decision to curtail the operations of the equal pay extension; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
To be within the scope of the Anti-Discrimination (Pay) (Amendment) Bill the trade unions and employers in a particular firm will need to agree formally that the introduction of the principle of equal pay in the firm or business would lead to unemployment. The Labour Court will also, after investigation, have to authenticate the agreement of the trade unions and employers. The agreement of trade unions or workers is therefore necessary before any proposal to defer equal pay can be successful.
It is not possible at this stage to estimate the number of firms involved or the number of women workers who are likely to be affected by the Bill. My own view is that because of the extremely stringent conditions the number of workers will be very small.
Comment on this
Does the Minister think the Bill will do anything to restore the credibility of the Oireachtas after the Minister's complete failure in this whole matter?
Comment on this
I do not know if the Deputy was listening to the reply. The amendment will give power to the trade unions in a firm in which the workers organised in that firm feel there is a threat to their jobs arising out of the immediate implementation of the Act to veto the immediate implementation of the Act. If the Deputy is saying they should not have that power that is another matter.
Comment on this
All the Minister is doing is holding up Parliament by his silly antics. The point is on 1st August last year——
Comment on this
Parliament agreed to your measure and for some reason the Minister opted out of the whole thing and threw it over on the trade unions and workers.
Comment on this
I think the problem the Deputy has is that his supplementary questions are based on a different estimation of the whole matter.
Comment on this
Would the Minister explain, first of all, what will happen in the event of no agreement being reached? Secondly, how can he hope to defend the case that will be taken to the European Commission in view of the fact that so little information appears to be available to him as to the number of workers involved in the private sector? Does it not appear that no research has been done either by him or his Department into the problems that exist in this area?
Comment on this
No. I think it is better sometimes in the interests of accuracy to describe things as they are. The exemption gives power to unions in firms where jobs are threatened to avail of the exemption. It is not for me to say how many firms will avail of this exemption. That is a matter for the organised workers to say. In relation to the other part of the question relating to agreement with Brussels, this necessity is of course there and, if the authorities in Brussels think it should not be there for organised workers, then of course the Act will apply to the full extent.
Comment on this
This trying to project that somebody is denying something to organised workers is a futile exercise. Is it not true to say the Minister and his Government have reneged on the legislation passed in 1974? That is basically what we are talking about now.
Comment on this
I think the Deputy should consult a different script. What he has been saying is not applicable to the answer I have given.
Comment on this
I do not think the Minister answered the first part of the Deputy's question. What happens in the event of the employer being unable to pay and the unions being unwilling to accept the employer's offer?
Comment on this
As I explained, if the organised workers do not agree there is a case for exemption the Act applies.
Comment on this
If the employer pays too much will he not contravene the Act and, if he does not want to pay too much, what effect will the Act have on him?
Comment on this
The amendment simply gives authority to organised workers to seek exemption from the full implementation of the legislation. That is the only right it gives them. If they do not seek such a right then the Act applies.