We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Steel Fabrication Contract.

Steel fabrication contract award

Summary

O’Malley challenged the decision to award NET’s £600,000 steel fabrication contract to an English firm, arguing an Irish bidder was similarly priced and capable. Keating said NET and principal contractor Kellogg assessed the Irish firm’s capabilities, and expert advice led him to approve the award rather than intervene. He said he had not changed NET’s decision; he could not explain why a NET director reportedly told Murphys they had won the contract.

asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce why he gave his approval in advance to a decision by NET to award a steel fabrication contract worth £600,000 to an English firm rather than to an Irish firm (name supplied) whose tender was similar to that of the English firm.

Comment on this

Representations on behalf of the Irish firm were made to me before this contract was placed. I investigated the matter fully and concluded that it was not a matter in which I should intervene. I understand that the Board of NET based their decision not to place the contract with the Irish firm on a technical assessment of that firm's capabilities.

Comment on this

By whom was the technical assessment carried out?

Comment on this

It was carried out jointly by NET and the principal contractor, Kellogg.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that in this case the price of the Irish firm was approximately the same as that of the foreign firm, that the Irish firm had done work of this kind in respect of all of this contract except 27 tons out of 700 tons and that on a number of occasions they went to Spain to study the technique that is used in welding five millimetre sheet steel? They, and consultants whom they employed, were satisfied that they were capable of doing the work. In these circumstances was the Minister's decision, rather than that of NET, to employ an outside firm for a very valuable contract of £600,000, not a dereliction of his duty?

Comment on this

There were a number of inferences or purported statements of fact in that long supplementary. In so far as I can respond, without careful analysis of them, I do not agree that any of those imputations are correct.

Comment on this

In other words, the Minister is satisfied that, in a position such as this where the contract is worth more than twice as much as the celebrated Irish Life contract, this contract should go outside the country with his approval even though he was aware that the Irish firm were capable of doing the job?

Comment on this

No, Sir. Nothing I have said would bear that inference. The Deputy should try not to be quite so twisty and a little bit more accurate.

Comment on this

It is easy to understand why the Minister should get so touchy in the circumstances.

Comment on this

The Deputy should be straight.

Comment on this

In the Irish Life case it was stated that the Minister for Finance was not aware of what Irish Life were doing. In this case, it is as well that the House and the country should know the Minister for Industry and Commerce approved of this contract being given outside the country before it was placed.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We are having statements instead of questions.

Comment on this

It has been on the records of the House for some months that I approved of it before it was placed. The Minister for Agriculture and Fisheries approved of it.

Comment on this

The Minister for Industry and Commerce approved of a £600,000 contract going outside the country.

Comment on this

The Deputy should get the amount right. He is twisting again.

Comment on this

Would he agree that the technology involved here will be necessary in relation to oil and gas production platforms? If there was ever a contract which should be placed in this country it is this one.

Comment on this

The technical advice from experts which I received was that the contract should not be placed in this country. After a thorough and careful investigation I was satisfied that was the correct advice and that I would not be behaving in the best interests of NET or the country if I intervened to overturn that advice.

Comment on this

What was the reason for that advice?

Comment on this

If the Deputy listened to the answer given he would know. I said: "I understand that the board of NET based their decision not to place the contract with the Irish firm on a technical assessment of that firm's capabilities."

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Next question.

Comment on this

Why did a director of NET inform the company concerned, Murphys, that they had got the contract?

Comment on this

I have heard that statement also. I am not in a position to say, if he said that in exactly that form, why he said it.

Comment on this

He does not deny he said it. Why did he say it? When the matter went to the Minister the decision was changed.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

We cannot debate this matter today.

Comment on this

Why did Mr. Hynes say that?

Comment on this

The Deputy should get it right. He is making a mess of it.

Comment on this

Mr. Hynes informed Murphys they had got the contract.

Comment on this

Get it right. I did not change the decision.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The names of persons outside this House should not be used.

Comment on this