Muine Bheag community school site
The Minister said the Department was assessing an alternative proposal involving the local national school, but would not abandon the existing vocational-school building worth £150,000. Governey objected to the proposed site and its effect on playing fields, and sought a decision and timetable.
asked the Minister for Education the position regarding the proposed community school at Muine Bheag, County Carlow; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
As I indicated in my reply to a similar question, No. 50, on December 18th, an alternative proposal, involving the local national school, has been put forward for consideration by my Department. The implications, financial and otherwise, of this proposal are still under consideration in conjunction with the Commissioners of Public Works.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that this matter arose over 12 months ago and he received a deputation as far back as last July and visited the proposed site himself. Would the Minister now agree that the site proposed, namely, the extension to the vocational school, is unsuitable and why is there such a delay in getting the report from the Board of Works? Further, would he state what price he would be prepared to accept for a transfer of the primary school to the vocational school and then build a new school on a completely separate site to which the people would be agreeable?
Comment on this
The Deputy is mistaken when he says this question arose 12 months ago. It has, in fact, been going on for quite a number of years now. On 29th January, 1973, officers of my Department wrote to Carlow County Council as follows:
I desire to inform you that the Department proposes to erect a new Community School at Muine Bheag shortly. It is essential that the new building be sited adjacent to the existing vocational school which was built in recent years so that the accommodation in that school can continue to be used as part of the whole complex. It seems from a survey of the area that the only site that would be suitable under the circumstances is the site adjacent to the vocational school...which we understand is the property of the Council. The Department would be glad, if the Council would agree to sell the site to the Department.
I might add that in addition to a large range of teaching facilities the school will include a Sports Hall and tarmacadam play areas for tennis, basketball etc. We would also hope to purchase additional land in the vicinity for use as playing fields. All the school facilities and recreational facilities will be available to the Community in general.
The officials of the Department would be glad to call to the Council office to discuss the matter further.
That was in January, 1973. In fact, this question goes back to 1970, or earlier, as the Deputy may know. In the first part of his supplementary question he mentioned 12 months ago. Now I take the same view as my predecessor did: the place to put the community school is on the site of the existing vocational school. The delay involved is not something for which I have special responsibility and the question about the price of transferring the national school does not arise at this stage.
Comment on this
The Minister is aware that 12 months ago a public meeting in Muine Bheag were in complete agreement that this was not a suitable site and they wanted the community school on a separate site. The Minister must be further aware that the proposed site is unsuitable because it will take playing fields from the children in Pairc Mhuire. At this late stage would the Minister give an undertaking when he will be able to take a definite decision and let the people know if he is going ahead with the school on the proposed new site?
Comment on this
The difficulties referred to by the Deputy arose more than four years ago and I cannot give any undertaking which would involve me in walking away from £150,000 of good vocational building.