We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Curragh Camp Prison.

Army personnel as Curragh prison warders

Summary

Power questioned whether the prison would make soldiers serve permanently as warders and argued that they resented the role. Donegan said the minimum number served willingly and would stop when their duties were no longer necessary, while defending the facility as a state necessity in an emergency.

asked the Minister for Defence if the erection of a high security prison in the Curragh Camp will mean that members of the Defence Forces will always have to be employed in custodial duties there.

Comment on this

Members of the Defence Forces will be employed on custodial duties in relation to civilian prisoners transferred to military custody under the provisions of the Prisons Act, 1972, for so long as such transfers continue to be necessary.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not agree that those enlisting in the Defence Forces do so in the hope that they will be soldiers and not have to act as warders? Does he agree that Army personnel resent this duty, that they look upon the building of a high security prison in the Curragh Camp as a sign that these duties will be perpetuated? Is this a proper situation?

Comment on this

I do not agree with the Deputy. My experience of enlisted men in the Army is that whatever tasks they are asked to perform in this time of subversion, death, murder and pillage they will do in the name of the State. They would stand by the oath they took when they entered the Army. I should like to say that the minimum number of them are involved in the duties referred to by the Deputy but they are doing them freely. I have seen non-commissioned men promoted for what I would call, if not acts of heroism, acts beyond the ordinary call of duty in the course of their duty. The prison referred to by the Deputy is there because if there is a necessity for the incarceration of people who would murder, pillage and destroy we must have some place to put them. There is no desire on the part of the Government to put anybody in there nor is there any desire to employ one more soldier than is necessary in dealing with people of this kind. More than 1,400 people have been killed since 1969 and that imposes duties upon us all. It imposes a duty not only on the Army, whom I compliment on the excellent nature of their services, but on every citizen to go to a soldier, or a garda and tell them anything about subversive acts going on in their area.

Comment on this

Would the Minister not agree that the decision to have this type of prison in the Curragh Camp, and to deny the opportunity to civilians to act as warders within the Curragh Camp, means that soldiers who enlist as soldiers will have to act as warders as long as that prison is there and operative? Does the Minister not consider that an undesirable situation?

Comment on this

The exigencies and demands of the State at this time, when democracy must be preserved, fall upon the Defence Forces, notably the Garda and the Army. What the Army is asked to do is done gallantly since I became Minister for Defence. I commend them and I do not accept that they complained. The moment it is unnecessary to have them as warders they will not act as warders. To have a place in the Curragh where people could be incarcerated if such were necessary to save human life and try to prevent further murders, robberies and pillage, is a State necessity. It is empty of prisoners at present and please God it will remain so.

Comment on this