Cost and adequacy of refinery report
Barrett challenged the £40,000 report’s value given its admitted gaps in data and reliance on estimates. Keating said this was a separate question requiring proper notice and research.
In view of the fact that the report is estimated to have cost £40,000 is the Minister satisfied with the contents of it, especially as it admits in some instances that it had inadequate data and in other instances that it had no data at all? The report also admits that most of its findings were based on assumptions and guess estimates. Is the Minister satisfied that the £40,000 involved is well spent in view of these admitted inadequacies by the report?
Comment on this
This is an entirely different question, which asks for an expression of opinion on my part which does not arise out of the two questions I am answering.
Comment on this
It is a matter of £40,000 expended on an important storage location for an oil refinery. Is the Minister saying that the operational costs of the refinery have any reference whatever?
Comment on this
As I said, the scope of his question is out of all proportion. If the Deputy puts down the appropriate questions so that I can have them properly researched and answered I will be happy to do so, but I cannot offer opinions of this kind arising from the sort of questions which relate to times and alleged delays.