We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Prisoners' Welfare.

Prisoner after-care and recidivism

Summary

The Minister said welfare staff can help former prisoners with personal, employment or accommodation problems but will not monitor them after release, citing privacy. He also addressed recidivism information and promised to arrange for the forthcoming report to be sent to Deputies.

asked the Minister for Justice the role of the prison social welfare officer in the after-care of prisoners; if there is any method of monitoring the record of ex-prisoners for a period after their release to assess the success of the prison system; and the rate of recidivism in adult and juvenile prisoners.

Comment on this

In regard to the first part of the question, I would refer the Deputy to the written reply which I gave to Question No. 120 on yesterday's Order Paper.

It would be an infringement on the liberty of an individual and an intrusion into his privacy for the welfare service to keep a watch on him after expiry of his sentence but where a person on release is in need of advice or of help in regard to personal problems or employment or accommodation the welfare service of my Department are available to assist at any time.

A table showing the numbers of persons in prison who have served a period or periods of imprisonment on other occasions is given in the annual reports on prisons. It is hoped to have the reports for 1973 and 1974 published very shortly. Similar figures are not kept in respect of juveniles sentenced to detention and, in any case, it would be inappropriate to classify a juvenile as a recidivist unless he persists in a life of crime beyond the point of maturity, at which point statistics regarding his recidivism become reflected in the adult figures.

There seems to be an implication in the question that the success or failure of a prison system can somehow be measured in terms of recidivism. This, however, is an invalid assumption since, for one thing, we cannot know what a person's conduct would be had he not been imprisoned. Another implication is that recidivism is capable of being drastically reduced, if not eliminated, by changes in the prison system.

Regrettably, international experience and research do not bear out any such assumption. It is increasingly coming to be realised even—or perhaps especially—in those countries which some groups here hold out as having what they term progressive penal systems that the best efforts at rehabilitation have little effect in very many cases. This in no way means that plans and programmes to improve facilities in prisons should or will be put aside or that there is any doubt about the need to do what we can. It is simply to bring a note of realism into the question of what can or cannot be hoped for in this area.

Comment on this

Will the Minister make available copies of the report to each Deputy?

Comment on this

The report will be published shortly and if they are not sent to each Deputy, I will arrange that that be done.

39.

Comment on this