Motor insurance premium increases
The Minister put the cumulative increase since June 1974 at 73.6 per cent, with earlier loading reductions, and compared longer-term premium changes with the consumer price index. Kitt and Davern questioned the comparison; the Minister said premiums had risen faster since 1974 but more slowly over 12 years.
asked the Minister for Industry and Commerce the total percentage increase in motor car insurance premiums since June, 1974.
Comment on this
The total cumulative increase in basic motor insurance premium rates since June, 1974 was 73.6 per cent, but against this reductions in loadings equivalent to 10 per cent of overall income were made in conjunction with the 1974 increases in basic rates.
Comment on this
Does it not seem from the very large increase which the Minister has indicated that the insurance companies are dictating terms and rates and the unfortunate motorist has to suffer as he has had to suffer in the recent budget?
Comment on this
The increase in the period referred to in the Deputy's question is, as I have indicated in my reply, 73.6 per cent, but I think it is fair to put the increase in motor insurance premiums into a longer time frame. If one takes the period from 1970 to 1975, over a five-year span, the consumer price index increased in that time by 93.09 per cent, whereas the motor insurance premium increased by 90.96 per cent, in other words a lesser increase for motor insurance premiums than for the consumer price index over that period. If you take the period 1962 to 1975, a longer period still, we find that the consumer price index went up by 190 per cent, whereas motor insurance premiums went up by 147 per cent. Therefore, taken over a 12 year period, the increase in premiums has been slower than the increase in the consumer price index, though it was particularly dramatic over the period——
Comment on this
Is it not true also to say that in taking the period from 1962 the rise would be far more exaggerated on a percentage basis than in taking 1974? The 1974 prices were high but the 73 per cent increase on that would be far greater than on the 1962 figure.
Comment on this
The point I was making was that if you compare the increase in the consumer price index with the increase in insurance premiums since June, 1974, then motor insurance premiums have gone up much more rapidly, but if you take it over a 12-year period, they have gone up less rapidly than the consumer price index.