We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Eastern Health Board Expenditure.

Eastern Health Board unauthorised expenditure

Summary

The Minister said the Board had incurred about £700,000 in unapproved capital expenditure, including extra hospital beds, and that officials were consulting with the Department. Members discussed whether board members could be surcharged and the use of supplementary estimates; the Minister said he had information only about the Eastern Health Board.

asked the Minister for Health if he will give details of the unauthorised expenditure by the Eastern Health Board to which he referred on 21st January, 1976.

Comment on this

The funding of health boards is organised on the basis of periodic grant payments to the boards related to annual budgets. These budgets represent, in general, the financial allocations for funding the approved health services administered by the boards. As Deputies will appreciate, control of public expenditure on health services can only be exercised if these allocations are adhered to unless authority is given to any specific additional expenditures. In so far as the Eastern Health Board is concerned expenditures in excess of allocations have been incurred, and in some instances these were on services for which my Department's prior approval had not been obtained. I do not regard it as appropriate to detail these instances since such matters are best dealt with by way of direct consultations between the board and my Department, but they would consist, in the main, of a number of building and maintenance works the funding of which had not been fully agreed with my Department.

Comment on this

I am not very pleased with the reply, as a member of that board. On 21st January last the Minister made an allegation that the board were guilty of incurring unauthorised expenditure. I have now asked him for details of the unauthorised expenditure.

Comment on this

There was unapproved unauthorised expenditure of about £700,000 on capital works. No prior approval had been given by the Department. As far as details are concerned, these will be discussed between the officers of the board and the Department. In respect of one hospital, there was provision for a number of extra beds and this had not been approved. I am not saying they would have been disapproved if application had been made. That would amount to about £700,000 but there is a small number of other projects. Unauthorised expenditure was engaged in in this case. There may be some doubt about it and there will be consultations between the officials of the board and the Department.

Comment on this

Has approval since been given for that expenditure and would the members of the board be surchargeable in a situation where such members authorise payments of that level?

Comment on this

I have heard about surcharges but in my experience of health and other bodies I have not seen them implemented.

Comment on this

Is there provision in law for it?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

This will come up at a meeting of the board on Thursday. They can be surcharged.

Comment on this

I cannot say specifically in this case. All I can say is that there has been unauthorised expenditure and that there are consultations between the board officials and the Department.

Comment on this

The Minister will agree that it should not necessarily affect the officials. It obviously affects members of the board and is it not with them that the consultations should be held?

Comment on this

I do not know whether the officials discussed it with members of the board.

Comment on this

This question arose when we were dealing with the plight of the health boards who owned £8 million and the Minister said this unauthorised expenditure was the cause of the board owing so much.

Comment on this

That is a different question.

Comment on this

Is this question of unauthorised expenditure peculiar to the Eastern Health Board or does it affect all health boards?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I cannot allow an extension of the question which deals only with the Eastern Health Board.

Comment on this

Is it not a fact that Supplementary Estimates come before the Dáil from the different Departments after the expenditure has been made? Can the Minister say if this is not a regular feature of the running of Departments and boards of this nature?

Comment on this

I have information of the Eastern Health Board only, but as far as expenditure of that kind is concerned, there were two Supplementary Estimates to provide for increases in salaries and for increased prices.

Comment on this

Do they come for approval of the Dáil when payments have already been made?

Comment on this

Is it not the case that we clear Supplementary Estimates in the week before Christmas to cover expenditure that has accrued in the course of the year?

Comment on this

The last Estimate was some time in November and immediately it was passed by this House it was passed to the health board.

Comment on this

And there was no over-expenditure by the Department since then?

4.

Comment on this