We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Parking of Car.

Erroneous parking fine and threatened imprisonment

Summary

The Minister said the proceedings used the wrong car number, causing the petitioner anxiety; the warrant was stayed while the petition was investigated, and imprisonment was not a possibility. He regretted the error, and the remaining questions were deferred to Tuesday’s Order Paper.

asked the Minister for Justice if he has received a petition from a person (details supplied) in County Meath who was fined £7 for allegedly misparking a car which he claims neither to have owned or parked and who is now facing a jail sentence for an offence of which he would therefore appear to be guiltless; if so, if he will state the outcome of the petition; and, if he has not received such a petition, if he will favourably consider one.

Comment on this

I have received a petition and the matter is being investigated. I shall communicate with the Deputy when my inquiries are complete.

Comment on this

How long does the Minister expect the investigation to take? Is there any fear that this man will be sent to jail while the investigation is going on?

Comment on this

The execution of the warrant has been postponed in accordance with normal practice. I expect to be in a position to deal with it next week.

Comment on this

How did this man get his summons when he did not, in fact, own the car or have the car parked there?

Comment on this

It would appear from inquiries so far made that there was an error with regard to the number of the car. The number put down in the proceedings was not the number of the petitioner's car, which was, in fact, wrongly parked.

Comment on this

Will the Minister see that mistakes of this nature do not arise again, because this mistake has given the family concerned a lot of anxiety.

Comment on this

I have no doubt that the petitioner has been caused anxiety by the mistake and the mistake is regretted. As I say, the petitioner wrongly parked his car but, unfortunately, the wrong number was put on the proceedings.

Comment on this

Does this not open a pretty wide question whereby it is possible to find oneself in jail when one is not guilty of an offence, just because of some mistake being made? Does that not alarm the Minister?

Comment on this

It is not possible for a person to find himself in jail by reason of a mistake. A mistake was made in this case, but nobody went to jail, nor is there any likelihood of anyone going to jail, because there are several remedies available to a person who might be the victim of an administrative error such as this.

Comment on this

In fact, the person was told that he would be brought to jail next week if he did not pay.

Comment on this

The position is that a petition has been lodged on behalf of the defendant and that had the effect of staying the proceedings, and there was no question of him going to jail. In any event, I was aware of the matter from petitions by Deputies Tully and Bruton.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The remaining questions will appear on next Tuesday's Order Paper.

Comment on this