We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Health Services.

Health-board 1976 funding allocations

Summary

Haughey challenged the shortfalls between health boards’ estimates and their 1976 allocations, seeking assurance that 1975 services could continue. Corish said the difference was not a deficit, that the estimates could sustain 1975 service levels, and that boards had agreed to economies; Haughey disputed the figures and the adequacy of the proposed savings.

asked the Minister for Health the method by which the original shortfall of £3.72 million between the amount sought by the Eastern Health Board to finance its operations in 1976 and the allocation made by his Department was reduced to £0.323 million; the amounts by which the expenditure on particular services is to be cut back; and the effect the cut-backs are likely to have on the services concerned.

15.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the amount sought by the Southern Health Board to finance its operations for 1976; the amount allocated by his Department; the deficit resulting from this allocation; and how he proposes that the board should cope with this deficit.

16.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the amount sought by the South-Eastern Health Board to finance its operations for 1976; the amount allocated by his Department; the deficit resulting from this allocation; and how he proposes that the board should cope with this deficit.

17.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the amount sought by the North-Western Health Board to finance its operations for 1976; the amount allocated by his Department; the deficit resulting from this allocation; and how he proposes that the board should cope with this deficit.

18.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the amount sought by the North-Eastern Health Board to finance its operations for 1976; the amount allocated by his Department; the deficit resulting from this allocation; and how he proposes that the board should cope with this deficit.

19.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the amount sought by the Mid-Western Health Board to finance its operations for 1976; the amount allocated by his Department; the deficit resulting from this allocation; and how he proposes that the board should cope with this deficit.

20.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the amount sought by the Western Health Board to finance its operations for 1976; the amount allocated by his Department; the deficit resulting from this allocation; and how he proposes that the board should cope with this deficit.

21.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health the amount sought by the Midland Health Board to finance its operations for 1976; the amount allocated by his Department; the deficit resulting from this allocation; and how he proposes that the board should cope with this deficit.

22.

Comment on this

asked the Minister for Health if he will now make a revised allocation for non-capital health expenditure available to each regional health board which will enable the board to maintain for the whole of 1976 all the services that were in operation during 1975 at the same standard that obtained in that year.

Comment on this

With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, I propose to take Questions Nos. 14 to 22 together.

Comment on this

I object to this procedure. Each one of the questions deals with a separate health board, a separate budgetary provision and a separate situation. It is a denial of my rights as a Deputy for the Minister to take all these questions together.

Comment on this

As far as I know, I am the only member of a health board present in the House.

Comment on this

The only member of the Labour Party present.

Comment on this

Where are the other members of the health boards? As far as we are concerned on the Mid-Western Health Board our situation is perfect. Deputy Haughey knows nothing at all about us.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair has no control over the method of a Minister's reply.

Comment on this

Deputy Coughlan is anticipating embarrassment for his Minister.

Comment on this

The Deputy drew his gun before but he only had blanks.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not a matter for the Chair as to the method a Minister adopts in respect of replies to questions of this kind.

Comment on this

I understand that and I do not seek to reprimand the Chair. I would not attempt to do that. Would the Chair recognise that there is validity in my complaint and that the Minister is treating the House in a very contemptible fashion by the method he proposes to deal with these questions? It is a negation of democracy.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

It is not uncommon to have a number of questions replied to together in this fashion. We will now have the Minister's reply to Questions Nos. 14 to 22.

Comment on this

I propose, also with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to circulate with the Official Report a statement showing the allocation for non-capital expenditure in 1976 for each of the health boards and the boards' estimates of expenditure for 1976. The table will show that, for all the health boards, the difference between the allocations and their estimates was £10.788 million, or about 6 per cent. It is not correct to describe this difference as a "deficit". As I pointed out in speaking on the Deputy's motion on 3rd March—Official Report, Volume 228, column 1260—it is customary for estimates of bodies such as health boards to be reduced after examination. The examination of the boards' estimates, with a view to reconciliation, has been carried out by my Department with the officers of the health boards.

In the case of four of the boards— the southern, the mid-western, the north-western and the north-eastern, it has been possible to achieve full reconciliation on the basis of repricing of certain items to relate them clearly to 1975 levels and by economies in expenditure on "housekeeping"— including maintenance—on transport services, on replacement of equipment, reducing locum cover and overtime to essential levels and similar items. Increased income to the boards was also provided for, including the increase in charges for private patients which will come into effect on 1st April.

For three other health boards—the western, the south-eastern and the midland—similar revisions of estimates were achieved and these have reduced the differences between the estimates and the allocations to a figure totalling about £1,300,000. Further discussions are proceeding on the elimination of these balances.

The method of reconciliation of the difference in the case of the Eastern Health Board was similar to that for the other health boards. The board's estimate was examined in detail, in consultations between officers of my Department and its officers. The estimate made by the board had not been based strictly on maintenance of 1975 levels and the examination between the Department and its officers resulted in reductions on this account in the estimated figures under several headings. Furthermore, it was agreed that the provision made in the estimates for some items could be repriced. In particular, the provision for overdraft interest was reduced by £200,000 and the provision for receipts was increased by £120,000.

The estimate as prepared by the Eastern Health Board had included provision of £1,900,000 for maintenance works on buildings and so on. It was put to the Board's officers that, in the present difficult financial situation, this figure could be reduced very considerably. A reduction of £700,000 was agreed to in it.

The total reduction in the estimate as originally prepared by the board arising from these discussions was £2,946,000. The "gap" between the board's original estimate and the allocation which I had made to it was thus reduced to £773,000. It was also intimated to the board that I would consider a proposal, which I will be referring to in a reply to another of the Deputy's questions, on the scheme for subsidising drugs for the middle income group and a proposal in relation to charges in hospitals which could reduce this deficit further. In the estimation of the board's chief executive officer this will reduce the difference to the figure of £323,000 referred to by the Deputy. The chief executive officer reported this new position to the board at their meeting on 4th March and the board have accepted the situation as thus reported. Discussions will continue with the Eastern Health Board on the elimination of the remaining part of the "deficit".

As regards Question No. 22, the matter of revising the allocations for non-capital expenditure to health boards in 1976 for the purpose mentioned by the Deputy does not arise.

Following is the statement:

Health Board | Allocation for non-capital expenditure in 1976 | Health Board's estimate of non-capital expenditure | Difference between the allocation and the estimate prepared by the health board

£(m) | £(m) | £(m)

Eastern | 33.59 | 37.310 | 3.720

Southern | 29.43 | 30.360 | 0.930

Western | 25.17 | 27.783 | 2.613

South-Eastern | 19.53 | 20.290 | 0.760

Mid-Western | 17.89 | 18.490 | 0.600

North-Eastern | 13.58 | 14.440 | 0.860

North-Western | 13.21 | 13.610 | 0.400

Midland | 12.10 | 13.005 | 0.905

TOTALS | 164.50 | 175.288 | 10.788

Comment on this

Does the Minister suggest to the House that this is a serious proposal? Is he endeavouring to suggest to the House that the executive officers of the different health boards submitted estimates which were irresponsibly inflated to the extent of £10 million? Is there any other explanation of the fact that officers of his Department are able to go along to the different health boards and reduce the budgets submitted by £10 million simply by examining these estimates on paper? Would the Minister indicate which is the situation? Were the estimates fraudulent in the first place or is the alleged reduction which the Minister now proposes to make fraudulent? Which is the situation?

Comment on this

The estimates are framed and the amounts agreed by the health boards are sufficient to maintain the services at the 1975 level. In this House in the last few debates there was from practically every Deputy who spoke a reference to what they considered to be a certain amount of wastage in the health services and they suggested that economies could be achieved. That appeared to me to be the consensus of opinion among a certain number of Deputies excluding the Deputy who asked the question but as a former Minister for Finance I am sure he will agree that while the estimates may not be described as being inflated there is an inclination towards an element of over-estimation as far as expenditure is concerned. The various health boards were approached through their CEOs. The CEOs in turn consulted the members of the health boards and, as I have indicated in my reply, five of them agreed that these economies could be made without damaging the service. In respect of the others where there still is an outstanding deficit it is proposed to have further consultations with the health boards to see if other economies can be effected.

I have in the course of a recent speech on the Deputy's motion indicated the improvement in real terms in the health services up to 1975. I have no hesitation in saying that we must look for economies in this year where there is undoubtedly constraint. The Deputy can lay the blame on this person, that Minister, or the other Minister but the fact is that the situation does not allow me, does not allow the Government, to make the improvements that all of us would desire but I think in 1976 and without any damage or danger to patient care or to the health services generally what has been agreed with the majority of the health boards and accepted by the actual members of the health boards is desirable.

Comment on this

In view of the reply given by the Minister, are we now assured that what pertained in 1975 will pertain into 1976 and that the wastages that have been made over a long period by health boards and practitioners working under health boards will be curtailed and is the Minister now prepared to make a statement here that he will set up an all-party committee to investigate the working of all health boards?

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Deputy is raising other matters.

Comment on this

Would the Minister say——

Comment on this

Is this a carefully arranged diversionary tactic?

Comment on this

There is nothing arranged. There are no tactics. I come here as a member of a health board for 36 years. I know what I am talking about and the Deputy does not. That is the difference.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. Let us proceed at Question Time today in an orderly manner.

Comment on this

If I do not know what I am talking about, cannot you allow me to ask questions in order to find out?

Comment on this

Stupidity.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Deputy Coughlan. I am afraid the Deputy's interjections are leading to retorts and to disorder. I must insist that we proceed at Question Time in an orderly fashion. I would ask Deputies— Deputy Haughey and others—to put questions briefly and concisely so that we will make worthwhile progress. In the meantime, Deputy Coughlan will not intervene unless he has a positive parliamentary question to put.

Comment on this

He should not be described as a plant. If that is the practice of Fianna Fáil, that is their affair.

Comment on this

I said "diversionary tactic". You are resorting to every trick to avoid answering straightforward questions I am putting to you.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Every Deputy is entitled to put a parliamentary question or a supplementary question. Order.

Comment on this

I have more experience of health boards than either Deputy Haughey or the Minister.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order.

Comment on this

I know what I am talking about, not like the Fianna Fáil goon.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a question.

Comment on this

It was suggested by practically every Deputy who spoke last night, including Deputy Haughey, that consideration should be given to the establishment of a committee, described by some people as an all-party committee and as a committee by other Deputies. This is something that I intend to give consideration to and I will be referring to it in my reply to the Second Stage debate on the Health Contributions Bill. In reply to the first part of Deputy Coughlan's supplementary question, yes, I am satisfied that as far as patient care is concerned 1975 standards can be achieved.

Comment on this

I want to suggest that we are not concerned here with any investigation of the financing of the health services in any sort of fundamental way. We are simply concerned to try to ascertain whether the allocations which the Minister has made for the different regional health boards will enable them to maintain fundamental, basic, community health services at a satisfactory level during 1976. I want to assure you, a Cheann Comhairle, that that is all I am endeavouring to ascertain by this process of questioning. It is a very important question and is one of considerable public interest.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

The Chair will facilitate the Deputy in eliciting this information but I want to dissuade the Deputy at the same time from making statements or embarking on speech-making. I am sure he will not do that.

Comment on this

I have not done it so far. The Minister has indicated that various devices have been resorted to in an attempt to eliminate the deficit of £3.72 million in the Eastern Health Board financial situation. I want to suggest to him that these alleged measures which the Department of Health have worked out in collusion with the executive officers of the Eastern Health Board are illusory and that, in fact, this deficit of £3.72 million still exists. Can he seriously suggest that a figure of maintenance of £1.9 million in the Eastern Health Board can be reduced by £700,000 in a realistic way and is this not simply a device, a bookkeeping affair and that, in fact, the deficit is still there? Do the measures which the Department of Health officials have worked out with the Eastern Health Board officials include, as in the case of St. Loman's, removing cornflakes from the breakfast menu, providing simpler desserts, cutting down on minerals and soft drinks with meals, cutting out patients' cigarette allowances, cutting out newspaper allowances for patients? Are these the sort of economies which his officials have worked out with the Eastern Health board officials or is he still prepared to deny that these restrictions and cutbacks are in force in St. Loman's Hospital, which is typical of this whole exercise carried out by the Department of Health?

Comment on this

These allegations were refuted by me some weeks ago and I still refute them. There will be no diminution as far as the services to these people are concerned. As I said, all this was suggested in some newspaper article by some unnamed spokesman. I resent Deputy Haughey saying that these cuts were done in collusion with the CEOs. The various health boards met and considered this and, in respect of about five of them, the various health boards agreed these economies should be made. Deputy Haughey continues to repeat things he said here about a month ago and I can only come to the conclusion that what he is trying to do is to cause mischief within the health boards. The various allegations that have gone around about cutting out this, that and the other as far as patients are concerned are wrong and will the Deputy not now accept my assurance that, as far as I am concerned, the 1975 level will be maintained?

Comment on this

I can only take St. Loman's as typical of the sort of exercise that is being carried out.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

I want to dissuade Deputies from the tendency to debate these matters at Question Time rather than putting precise questions. Supplementary questions should be brief and specific and they should not be asked in multiples or in omnibus form.

Comment on this

If the Minister had answered my questions in the case of each health board separately and specifically, as the Chair would like us to ask supplementary questions, there would have been no difficulty, but the Minister did not do that. He lumped everything together so that he would not have to deal directly with a particular instance. The Minister has again denied that these cutbacks, these economies, have been put into force in St. Loman's. Is he aware of the fact that the journalist who published the original disclosure in regard to this hospital has since interviewed the executive concerned personally and has been able to ascertain beyond yea or nay that these economies and cutbacks are now in force and, as to 99 per cent, the original articlie he published on the situation there has been verified by him personally in consultation with the authorities of that hospital? Further, is this typical of the manner in which all these alleged economies have been carried out and given effect to and is the whole process of apparently reducing this Eastern Health Board by £3.72 million not simply a fraudulent exercise by the Minister's Department on the health board concerned?

Comment on this

Does the Deputy not accept from me that these economies were discussed with the health board and does he not agree with me that the Eastern Health Board approved of these economies? Does he know that? He may try to cause mischief about cornflakes and newspapers and that sort of thing, but that was a scare article.

Comment on this

It was true.

Comment on this

It was not true.

Comment on this

It was true in every detail.

Comment on this

With regard to the Western Health Board, am I to take it from the Minister's reply that the CEO and the officials of the Western Health Board have agreed they can have no cutback and work on the amount of money they are getting, which is a big cut on the estimate? Am I to take it they have agreed on that? Secondly, am I further to take it that in answer to a question earlier asked by Deputy Haughey the Minister said no direction was issued by the Department for any cutback? I take the Minister's word for it, but he also said they must live within their budget and the budget is not sufficient to carry on the service as it was carried on last year. This is the position: first, the Minister says there will be no cutback and then he says there is a certain amount of money within which they must work.

Comment on this

On a point of order, I want to ask a question. There is no cutback, good, bad or indifferent.

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

That is not a point of order.

Comment on this

I am asking a reasonable question about the Western Health Board.

Comment on this

In reply to Deputy Callanan's first question, the Western Health Board have not yet considered the estimate. I believe the board is due to meet on the 27th of this month.

Comment on this

But the CEO has put forward the cutbacks.

Comment on this

The Minister did not answer my second question.

Comment on this