Hospital referral restrictions as savings
Haughey challenged the Minister over a Western Health Board proposal to restrict referrals to outside hospitals as an economy measure. The Minister said inquiries found no intention to change current practice, while Haughey and Callanan disputed that account and cited the board’s funding shortfall.
asked the Minister for Health if economy measures in the use of hospital services being undertaken by health boards such as referral of patients in the first instance to health board hospitals or other institutions and reductions in the number of patients being sent to outside hospitals may have very serious and in some cases fatal consequences; and if he will issue an immediate directive to cancel all such measures.
Comment on this
I have had inquiries made from each of the health boards. None of them has undertaken an economy measure such as is described by the Deputy.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that a proposal exactly along the lines of the proposals outlined in this question was put before the Western Health Board by the management. of that board as an economy measures? This was forced on the board by the inadequate allocation made by the Minister to the board for 1976.
Comment on this
The only information I have about the Western Health Board is that eligible patients may be referred by general practitioners to Portiuncula Hospital, Ballinasloe, without charge. If they attend Dublin voluntary hospitals without the agreement of the health board they may be charged 50p a day for public ward treatment. I am informed that, if they do that, the imposition of the 50p is never invoked.
Comment on this
Unfortunately I am not allowed to quote at Question Time. If I were permitted to quote I could quote from a report submitted by the executive officer of the Western Health Board to his board proposing exactly the sort of measures which I have outlined in my question, namely, economy measures in the use of hospital services being undertaken by health boards such as referral of patients in the first instance to health board hospitals or other institutions and reductions in the number of patients being sent to outside hospitals, as positive economy measures. If the Minister is not aware of that report I will undertake to get the report and submit it to him.
Comment on this
I have quoted from the information I have. This is a matter for the general practitioners. If the patient elects to go to a hospital of his choice, apart from the health board hospitals, he may be charged 50p a day. That is more theory than practice. If the GP decides that he should go to one of the outside hospitals, say a voluntary hospital in Dublin, that will be allowable for those who are eligible for free hospital treatment.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware of a proposal put forward seriously by the executive officer of the Western Health Board to the board——
Comment on this
I am sorry, Deputy. Could I dissuade the Deputy from repeating supplementaries? I am afraid we are having repetition.
Comment on this
This is a point which the Minister is not clear on. From his answer it appears to me that he does not understand the exact point I am endeavouring to make by way of question. Is he aware that the executive officer has seriously suggested to his board that, as an economy measure, general medical practitioners under the general medical service be restricted in their freedom to refer to certain hospitals? Would he, as Minister for Health, approve of such a restriction?
Comment on this
They can go to outside voluntary hospitals if they want to. Will the Deputy not take my word? He is dragging out all those questions, getting a lot of political mileage out of the matter. I said I have had inquiries made from all the health boards and there is no proposal to change the present system.
Comment on this
I have seen in writing this report made by the executive officer of the Western Health Board to his board making this proposition.
Comment on this
Will the Minister agree that the CEO of the Western Health Board has to put forward certain proposals? He is a man who gives a very conservative estimate. He has to find £500,000 by way of savings. Therefore, he has to put forward the economy measures referred to if he is to live within the estimate.
Comment on this
The Deputy is embarking on a statement rather than putting a precise supplementary question.
Comment on this
The CEO of the Western Health Board has to work within the limits of the money he is provided with.
Comment on this
I have made inquiries and I am informed that it is not the intention of any of the health boards to change the present practice despite what Deputy Haughey says.