Eligibility for general medical cards
Haughey pressed the Minister to prevent health boards from tightening medical-card eligibility; the Minister said CEOs follow common guidelines, reviewed twice yearly, and denied awareness of proposals to reduce eligibility. Deputies raised concerns about representations from public officials and assessments of farmers’ means. The Minister promised the guidelines would be followed, but the exchanges ended in dispute over whether that was sufficient assurance.
asked the Minister for health if he will issue a directive to each regional health board stipulating that no new limitations on the issue of general medical cards are to be introduced in this year.
Comment on this
Decisions on the grant or refusal of medical cards rest, under the Health Act, 1970, with the chief executive officers of the health boards. I do not think it would be necessary or appropriate for me to issue a directive on this to the chief executive officers.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not recall that on a number of occasions in the House he has expressed pride in the fact that under his jurisdiction the number of people in receipt of medical cards has increased and that the percentage of the population in receipt of general service medical cards has increased? In view of that does he not think it is rather hypocritical of him now to wash his hands of this matter by saying it has nothing to do with him if the executive officers are reducing the level of eligibility? Does he not think he has a responsibility to ensure that medical cards are not taken from people who have them and that the levels of eligibility are not reduced or disimproved?
Comment on this
The guidelines as laid down are adhered to by chief executive officers. When I came into office I discovered that the guidelines varied from health board to health board. I discussed the matter with the CEOs and suggested that there should be common guidelines for the health boards over the whole country. They adopted this. In addition, in consultation with the CEOs, I suggested there should be a review twice a year in order to decide whether or not the guidelines could be eased. This was done. I do not remember putting it forward as a boast when I spoke in a debate here. I put it forward as a fact that there was a big increase in the number of medical cards from the number in 1973 to that in 1975.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not acknowledge that on a number of occasions in the last six months he has taken credit for the fact that, as Minister for Health, the number of persons in receipt of general service medical cards increased under his jurisdiction? In those circumstances does he not think that there is now an obligation on him to ensure that the proposals which have been put forward in the different health board areas for a reduction in levels of eligibility should be set aside?
Comment on this
In the case of the Southern Health Board, the Eastern Health Board and in the case of many other health boards positive proposals have been put forward by the executive officers of the boards to reduce eligibility for general service medical cards.
Comment on this
I am not so aware. The guidelines will be adhered to and they will be reviewed in June next.
Comment on this
To take an example, why does the Minister think the Eastern Health Board felt it necessary to pass a resolution to the effect that when the current medical card scheme is reviewed the basis of eligibility be not worsened? Why does he think the executive officer of the Southern Health Board put forward a positive proposal to reduce the levels of eligibility and, in particular, to take medical cards off old age pensioners?
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that the officials of the Southern Health Board are under strict instructions not to take representations from public representatives into account when considering eligibility for medical cards? Is he also aware that the officials of the Southern Health Board were informed that they are not to refer to representations from public representatives in making acknowledgements and to refer to inquiries only? Furthermore, is the Minister aware that it now appears that the elected representatives of county councils within the Southern Health Board region are no longer allowed to forward cases in favour of applicants for registration in the general medical services register, directly as a result of instructions from his Department and directly as a result of instructions to the CEOs?
Comment on this
Is the Deputy suggesting I told the CEOs not to accept recommendations from public representatives?
Comment on this
I am informed that members of the Southern Health Board were told by the CEO, as per instructions from the Department of Health, that he is not to take into account representations from them or from public representatives, and that public representations so far as he is concerned, and so far as the Department of Health are concerned, are only eyewash.
Comment on this
I am not so aware. I would assume that any CEO is bound to accept recommendations from any public representatives whether Dáil, Seanad or local bodies.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that limitations are imposed at present? Heretofore the health boards assessed farmers' applications on the poor law valuation. Now they are assessing them on the farmers' means since the eligibility was increased.
Comment on this
I am not aware they were ever assessed on the rateable valuation. On the notional income, yes.
Comment on this
Is he further aware that they are assessing the income per cow at £120 in the case of milk suppliers? In many cases this is very high. Compared with the national average in milk production it is very high. Is the Minister aware of that?
Comment on this
I am not so aware. I am not denying what the Deputy said, but I am not aware of the details he has just given.
Comment on this
In view of the reports which all of us are aware have emanated from all the different health board areas, will the Minister take it on himself to investigate this matter and give us an assurance that, in these very hard times, persons who are entitled at existing levels of eligibility to general medical service cards will not be deprived of them as economy measures?
Comment on this
I will give the Deputy this assurance for about the 95th time. The guidelines will be adhered to by the CEOs.
Comment on this
This is leading to argument. Deputies will have a further opportunity of ventilating their grievances on the health services on a measure which is before the House.