1976 grants for voluntary hospitals
The Minister said the 1976 allocation was £53.745 million, up 13.5% on 1975, and expected most hospitals to maintain patient care at the previous year’s level. Haughey and other Deputies cited shortfalls and possible service cuts; the Minister said some hospitals faced difficulties and discussions about economies were under way.
asked the Minister for Health the amount provided in the Estimate for his Department for 1976 under subhead G.2. for the voluntary hospitals; how this compares with the total of the budgets submitted by these hospitals; and if the allocations made to them are sufficient to enable each hospital to carry on throughout the whole year providing a full and satisfactory service to the general public.
10.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Health if he will now provide in subhead G.2. of the Estimate for his Department an amount for voluntary hospitals which will enable them to continue to maintain an adequate and satisfactory level of service to the general public during the whole of 1976.
Comment on this
I propose, with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to take Questions Nos. 9 and 10 together.
The total grant allocation provided for public voluntary hospitals in 1976 is £53,745,000, which represents an increase of £6,433,000 or about 13.5 per cent over the revised final allocations for 1975. The allocations notified to the different hospitals were related to the revised allocations which had been made available for 1975 and included additional provision as referred to above to provide as far as possible against certain anticipated cost and other increases in 1976.
As in the case of health boards the voluntary hospitals were requested to frame their detailed budgets within the allocations made available. The question of providing for increased allocations does not arise. It is accepted that in order to maintain services at 1975 levels the hospital managements will require to ensure that all reasonable economies are made. I understand that while most hospital managements will be able to achieve the target set some of them are experiencing difficulty. Discussions are taking place with the authorities of those hospitals.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that in the case of practically every voluntary hospital there is serious disquiet about the level of services they will be able to provide during the year? For instance, in the case of one hospital the management have informed the staff that they are short by an estimated £160,000, that they will not be able to maintain the services at their present level for 1976 and they have elaborated a number of economy measures. Does the Minister not agree that this unsatisfactory situtation derives from the inadquate level of allocation which he has made of £53 million? Will he not seek from the Minister for Finance and from the Government an additional allocation that will enable these essential hospitals, which have a great tradition, to be maintained at levels that prevailed during the years, and which will provide the general public with the services they need during 1976?
Comment on this
I am assured that so far as patient care and the general running of the hospitals are concerned the allocations to most of the public voluntary hospitals will be adequate to ensure that the care for patients during 1976 will be the same as it was in 1975. I have said that some of the hospitals will find themselves in difficulty and, in order to provide for economies, discussions are going on between the hospitals and the Department of Health. The boards are agreed that the 1975 levels can be maintained. Some have difficulties and discussions are being held with those hospitals.
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept that in the case of many of those hospitals there are very serious difficulties? Does he not agree that the way to deal with the difficulties is not to seek further economies which will interfere with the running of the hospitals but rather to make an additional allocation available to them? Is the Minister aware that in the case of one hospital the shortfall is £160,000 and that that can be repeated throughout the hospitals? There is a real need for additional allocations to rectify the situation.
Comment on this
Will the Minister state why the practice of receiving estimates from the voluntary hospitals was discontinued this year? They were just given a blanket coverage of a certain precentage increase over their outlay last year. There is a voluntary hospital in Waterford that had a deficit of £28,000 in starting 1976. Will the Minister state if there is any possibility that this problem might be considered? Those hospitals have given a good and genuine service during the years.
Comment on this
If every Minister for Finance were to accept estimates from the various Departments and semi-State bodies it would cost many millions of pounds.
Comment on this
Will the Minister state if he has been informed that one voluntary hospital in the city—it is one of the oldest, and it is also a teaching hospital—will not be able to keep open the wards during the coming summer unless they get more money? Not only will the patients suffer but the young doctors and nurses being trained there will also suffer because of a lack of tutorial study.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy please put a brief question? There should not be any speech-making at Question Time.
Comment on this
The board of govenors of the voluntary hospital cannot keep the wards open unless they get more money from the Department.
Comment on this
I have not heard any suggestion to the effect that any ward will be closed. I do not know the name of the hospital the Deputy has in mind but if he gives it to me I will have the matter investigated.