We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Health Services.

Capitation rates for private hospitals

Summary

The Minister said capitation rates for eligible patients in private hospitals and homes rose by 10% from January and would generally be adequate. Haughey argued the rates remained unrealistic and that higher grants could ease pressure on public hospitals; the Minister maintained private facilities did not offer comparable services.

asked the Minister for Health if he will arrange to have the capitation rate payable by health boards in respect of eligible patients in private hospitals, homes and similar institutions increased immediately.

Comment on this

The capitation rates payable by health boards in respect of eligible patients in private hospitals, homes and similar institutions have in general been increased by 10 per cent with effect from 1st January, 1976.

Comment on this

Will the Minister state if he regards the existing levels as satisfactory? Does he think that the levels of capitation rates payable to these homes are fair and reasonable?

Comment on this

A 10 per cent increase is being given with effect from 1st January last and this has been included in the allocations to the boards. The capitation grants very as between the voluntary and the private hospitals. I am quite satisfied that the increase given will bring the capitation grants to a figure that will be adequate in the case mentioned by the Deputy.

Comment on this

Is the Minister aware that the existing levels are: category A, £4.40 per day and category D, £1.95 per day and that these are totally unrealistic levels of grant? Has he received representations from the association of private hospitals and homes on this matter, pointing out that even at his own level he has granted increases of 13 per cent and 14 per cent across the board to compensate for inflation but in the case of these homes and hospitals he has granted only 10 per cent? How does the Minister explain the difference between the 13 and 14 per cent and the 10 per cent—not that even 13 per cent is adequate?

Comment on this

It will not be 13 per cent across the board. I said 13 per cent in respect of the estimate for last year in the full allocation. The Deputy had a question last week with regard to the general medical servoces. In that case they did not get 10 per cent or 13 per cent; they got 19 per cent to ensure that the GMS would be adequately covered. So far as the private hospitals are concerned, I forget the actual figures mentioned by the Deputy but I think the capitation grant in most cases is £4.40 per day.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not accept that if the grants were raised to a realistic level it would encourage persons to avail of the facilities of these homes and hospitals to the advantage of the public hospitals? The appalling admission queues to the public and voluntary hospitals would be considerably reduced if he were prepared to make grants at a reasonable level available to the private hospitals. Does the Minister not consider it would be good business to do that, and that it would be in the overall interests of the health services?

Comment on this

I think anyone who goes into a private hospital and who also gets a capitation grant can be covered by voluntary health insurance. We are not talking of really poor people, or even of people of modest means in the middle income group.

Comment on this

The Minister should forget his class consciousness.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not forgetting his class consciousness.

Comment on this

Incidentally, the Minister's heroine, Barbara Castle, is in a private nursing home at the moment——

Comment on this

The Deputy's heroine is Margaret Thatcher.

Comment on this

Does the Minister not recognise that most people in this category have the option of going to a private hospital or nursing home, to a public hospital or to a voluntary hospital? Would it not be good, sensible administration for him to make it realistic and practical for as many of them as possible to opt for the facilities available in these private hospitals? This would reduce the stress and strain on the public hospitals.

Comment on this

The facilities in private hospitals are not comparable with the range of services provided in the public voluntary hospitals.

Comment on this

These people are prepared to go to them and should be encouraged and enabled to do so. The Minister needs to mobilise all the resources at his disposal.

Comment on this

They can get it through the Voluntary Health Insurance Board if they want and still get a capitation grant.

Comment on this

The Minister is letting doctrinaire considerations interfere with good administration.

Comment on this

No comment?

Comment on this

It is not worthy of a comment.

12.

Comment on this