Government policy on state enterprise
O’Malley asks whether a Parliamentary Secretary’s speech reflects Government policy and how it fits with other Labour views. The Taoiseach describes it as advocating community self-sufficiency and careful appraisal, declines to reconcile competing opinions, and says the broader question of state versus private enterprise cannot be answered briefly; Faulkner quips that the Coalition cannot answer it.
asked the Taoiseach if the speech of his Parliamentary Secretary at Rathfarnham on 29th March, 1976, represents Government policy on State enterprise in industry.
Comment on this
I read the Parliamentary Secretary's speech as an exhortation towards community self-sufficiency and as urging the full appraisal of proposals before action is taken on them. I would recommend the speech for consideration by every Deputy and constituent.
Comment on this
Is the Taoiseach aware that the principles enunciated in the speech are in direct conflict with those enunciated on behalf of the Labour Party about a week previously by Senator Brendan Halligan; and can the Taoiseach reconcile the two diametrically opposed views and tell us which, if either, is the view of the Government?
Comment on this
I have no obligation to reconcile any views of Deputies or Senators. This is a debate on economic planning and obviously it is a matter on which different views are bound to be expressed. Indeed, as the Deputy is aware, his own Leader expressed somewhat similar views to those of the Parliamentary Secretary in a speech some days later.
Comment on this
What is the policy of the Government in relation to this whole question of State enterprise vis-à-vis private enterprise?
Comment on this
Even the Deputy's experience would enable him to realise that that cannot be answered in reply to a short simple question.