We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Liquor Tax.

Tax reduction on beer

Summary

The Minister estimated that cutting the tax content of a pint by 3p would cost nearly £15 million annually, based on the Revenue Commissioners’ latest figures and estimates that account for demand changes. Deputies challenged the estimate and disputed the Minister’s denial of a 40% fall in consumption; he gave no direct commitment to reduce the tax, referring instead to the Government’s position on the Finance Bill.

asked the Minister for Finance the nett financial loss to the Exchequer if the tax on the pint of beer or stout was abated by 0.03p on the retail price.

Comment on this

It is estimated that the net cost to the Exchequer resulting from a reduction of 3p a pint in the total tax content of a pint of beer would approach £15 million annually.

Comment on this

Could the Minister tell me if the figure he has given is based on consumption prior to or at the time of the budget, or on consumption in or around this time?

Comment on this

It is taken as the estimated loss of revenue if a reduction in the tax content were reflected at this time.

Comment on this

The Minister has not answered the most relevant matter raised by Deputy Murphy, that is, on what basis were the calculations and estimate made on which he now tells us there would be a £15 million loss if there were a 3p reduction in the price of a pint?

Comment on this

The most up-to-date figures available to the Revenue.

Comment on this

Since the up-to-date figures would not have been available to the Revenue Commissioners when the budget was being put together, what would be the impact now of reducing by 3p, 4p or 5p the price of a pint? Would it have the effect of restoring the drop in sales of approximately 40 per cent? Was that 40 per cent drop envisaged by the Minister and the Revenue Commissioners at the time of the budget?

Comment on this

There is no evidence that there has been a 40 per cent drop in consumption of beer as a result of any tax increases.

Comment on this

The Minister must be out of his mind if he thinks that. People are being laid off all over the country, bottlers, wholesalers and so on. The Minister should ask these people.

Comment on this

Perhaps those who put on increases in the price of beer, which is of no public benefit, might want to consider whether they should reduce——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Order. There is a measure before the House on which Deputies can elaborate their viewpoints.

Comment on this

How can one elaborate on something for a Minister for Finance who does not even know there has been a drop in beer consumption around the country?

Comment on this

Had the Deputy been here this morning he would have learned the details. Any tax increases that have been imposed in the budget will all be returned to the public. Other increases which have been imposed since the budget may have gone to Deputy Blaney's friends——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Interruptions must cease.

Comment on this

Nobody is being codded by this. The Minister should cop himself on——

Comment on this
Seán Treacy An Ceann Comhairle Labour Party

Please, Deputy Blaney.

Comment on this

Whatever the reason for the drop in consumption it is notable that the Minister did not contest the fact that there was a drop in consumption. Am I right in assuming that the figure of £15 million the Minister gave was calculated on the reduced consumption now existing? Did the calculation take into account the likely increase in consumption in the event of a drop in price of 3p per pint?

Comment on this

In all estimations made by the Revenue Commissioners full account is taken of buoyancy in demand or restriction in demand consequent on changes in tax rates.

Comment on this

Could I ask the Minister one simple question: will he take 3p off the pint?

Comment on this

Had the Deputy been here this morning when I spoke on the Finance Bill he would have heard what was the Government's position.

Comment on this