Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - European Community Representation.
- Northern Ireland representation in EC institutions 17 speeches
O’Kennedy argued that Northern Ireland needed adequate representation in European Community bodies and urged the Minister to raise the issue with Britain. Kelly said formal representations would be inappropriate given British sovereignty, though an informal private expression of the view might be possible; he confirmed no proposals had been made. O’Kennedy criticized the lack of urgency, and the Ceann Comhairle ended the exchange.
Michael O'Kennedy, John M. Kelly, Seán Treacy
- Priority for an adjournment question 2 speeches
Andrews asked that Question No. 4 on the Adjournment take priority over his request concerning Question No. 23; the Ceann Comhairle said the Chair would communicate with him.
David Andrews, Seán Treacy
asked the Minister for Foreign Affairs if, in view of the inadequate personnel representation from Northern Ireland in the institutions and committees of the European Community, he will make proposals to the British Government to ensure adequate representation.
Comment on this
The personnel representation from Northern Ireland in the institutions and committees of the European Community is primarily a matter for the British Government and it would not be appropriate for the Minister to make proposals to that Government in the matter.
Comment on this
Acknowledging that position I should like to draw a comparison between the position there and that which exists in this part of the island where we have ten members on the European Parliament, various Ministers representing our interests and a represeuntative on the Commission—I understand that is a matter of some competition within the Government at present. One can see from that that there is a need to ensure adequate personnel representation from the North of Ireland. Would the Parliamentary Secretary accept that, if their interest within the European Community is to be protected?
Comment on this
I accept on a certain level, but on the level we are talking about, namely the level at which the Government can intervene in such matters. I do not accept the proposal at all. Whether we like it or not there is a certain sovereignty situation in regard to the North of Ireland and the exercise of that sovereignty, whether we like it or not, is vested in the British Government. They make the same decisions in regard to the distribution of their membership of committees and of the European Parliament as we make about ours.
Comment on this
Acknowledging the question of sovereignty I should like to point out that even the Parliamentary Secretary's reply to the previous question acknowledges the matter of mutual interest. Will the Parliamentary Secretary strongly request the British Government to take some steps to represent some personnel from the North of Ireland at any level, at committee level or other level? To illustrate it: there are many people serving on committees of the European Community who are not parliamentary representatives and they give great help. It must be fairly obvious, in view of the breakdown of political activity in the North, that there are many men of potential, commitment and conviction who could serve the interest of that part of Ireland very adequately. Surely the Government must share that sense of urgency and do something about it.
Comment on this
I accept that such people are there and that there is the gap referred to by the Deputy but the ordinary rules which govern relations between countries would make it inappropriate for this Government to make the kind of representations the Deputy is speaking about. Perhaps, it would not prevent the Minister informally, and privately, from expressing the kind of view the Deputy has just expressed but that is the limit he could be expected to go.
Comment on this
The Deputy asked if the Minister would make proposals to the British Government and I can tell him that no such proposals have been made.
Comment on this
I take it, from what the Parliamentary Secretary has said, that the Minister has not made any such suggestions?
Comment on this
That shows, unfortunately, a deplorable lack of urgency and conviction if the Minister has not even raised the matter with the British Government.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle I wish to raise the subject matter of Question No. 4 on the Adjournment. I would ask the Ceann Comhairle to give that question priority over my request to deal with Question No. 23 on the Adjournment.