Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Desertion Statistics.
- Deserted wives’ allowance statistics 4 speeches
The Minister provided age-group figures for deserted wives’ benefit and allowance, and answered a supplementary question with the total for those aged 18 to 30.
David Andrews, Frank Cluskey
- Survey into marital desertion 15 speeches
Andrews pressed for a survey into the causes and effects of desertion, asking who might conduct it and whether the AIM group could receive funding. Cluskey favoured an independent specialist organisation, said proposals would be considered, and referred to the ESRI’s earlier study; procedural exchanges followed.
David Andrews, Frank Cluskey, Seán Treacy
- Whether desertion is permanent 5 speeches
Andrews asked whether the 18-to-30-year-olds counted as deserted were permanently deserted; Cluskey said permanence could not be determined, as a husband might return. The Chair then moved on.
David Andrews, Frank Cluskey, Seán Treacy
- Remarriage after permanent desertion 4 speeches
Andrews asked whether the Government would amend the Constitution to allow a permanently deserted wife to remarry. Cluskey said the matter was outside his Department’s remit, and the Chair ruled that it could not be debated.
David Andrews, Frank Cluskey, Seán Treacy
- Government responsibility for deserted wives 12 speeches
O’Kennedy argued that desertion was a critical social problem and that the Government had responsibility to address it, rather than deferring to unnamed organisations. Cluskey accepted the problem’s seriousness, criticised the previous Government, and said support had recently been made available for appropriate organisations to conduct social surveys.
Michael O'Kennedy, David Andrews, Seán Treacy, Frank Cluskey
asked the Minister for Social Welfare (a) the number of persons between the ages of 18 and 30, 30 and 40, 40 and 50, 50 and 60, 60 and 70 and 70 and 80, respectively, in receipt of deserted wife's allowance and (b) the total number of dependants living with persons in receipt of this allowance.
Comment on this
As the reply is in the form of a tabular statement I propose, with the permission of the Ceann Comhairle, to circulate it with the Official Report.
Following is the statement:
(a) Number of persons in receipt of de serted wives' entitlement:
Age Group | Deserted Wives' Benefit | Deserted Wives' Allowance | Total
18 to 30 | 226 | 283 | 509
30 to 40 | 483 | 626 | 1,109
40 to 50 | 347 | 549 | 896
50 to 60 | 292 | 827 | 1,119
60 to 70 | 117 | 655 | 772
70 to 80 | 6 | Nil | 6
Totals | 1,471 | 2,940 | 4,411
(b) The total number of dependants living with persons in receipt of deserted wives' entitlement is 6,360.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Social Welfare if he will, as a matter of urgent public importance, conduct a survey into the causes and effects of desertion; and if he will make a general statement on the matter.
Comment on this
While my Department administer schemes under which payments are made to deserted wives, I consider that a survey as suggested by the Deputy might more appropriately be carried out by an independent organisation. In this connection, the Deputy may be interested to know that an exploratory study entitled "Marital Desertion in Dublin" was published by the Economic and Social Research Institute in 1974.
Comment on this
Has the Parliamentary Secretary any suggestions as to what independent group might examine the problem in 1976?
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary name one of these bodies which he considers appropriate in his capacity as a junior Minister in charge of this matter?
Comment on this
As there are a number of appropriate bodies capable of carrying out such a survey it would be inappropriate for me to single out any particular one.
Comment on this
Has the Parliamentary Secretary any idea what form this survey might take or how it might be conducted?
Comment on this
As I implied in reply to the question I think it would be more appropriately carried out by an organisation who have at their disposal people with certain qualifications, such people who specialise in surveys of this kind.
Comment on this
Would the Parliamentary Secretary consider the possibility of encouraging the AIM group to conduct such a survey? Would he give that group financial assistance to do such a survey and to find out the causes and effects of desertion?
Comment on this
Any proposals which come from any organisation will be given suitable consideration by the Department. I should point out to the Deputy, however, that when this Administration took over there were absolutely no funds at all available in the Department of Social Welfare to carry out such desirable surveys and, not only that, but we were not in a position to give any financial assistance to organisations which were carrying out surveys. I am glad that position has improved.
Comment on this
That is very encouraging. I am glad to hear the Parliamentary Secretary say that there will be funds available for continuing such surveys.
Comment on this
A final supplementary, if I may. The Parliamentary Secretary said in relation to Question No. 7 that 500 people between the ages of 18 and 30 are deserted. Can he say if this is permanent desertion?
Comment on this
It would be impossible to say in respect not only of any individual case or any individual instance if desertion is permanent or not. A man could be gone for a considerable time and he could return tomorrow. It would be impossible for me to answer that type of question.
Comment on this
If a wife is found to be permanently deserted and she wishes to remarry, having regard to the situation which exists, that her marriage is basically at an end, is it contemplated by the Government to introduce legislation to amend the Constitution to give effect to the will of that person to remarry?
Comment on this
The Deputy should be but obviously is not aware that that would not be an appropriate matter for the Department of Social Welfare.
Comment on this
Question No. 9. We cannot debate this matter. The Chair has been generous in the number of supplementaries allowed.
Comment on this
I take it the Parliamentary Secretary will agree that this is a critical social problem, particularly having regard to the fact that he has given figures of over 500 between the ages of 18 and——
Comment on this
Assuming he agrees that it is a pretty critical social problem, does he not recognise that the Government—and we are talking of the Government of the moment— have a grave responsibility to discharge in this area, a responsibility which they cannot abrogate by reference to some other organisation which the Parliamentary Secretary is very slow to indicate or nominate.
Comment on this
It is the same question. Does the Parliamentary Secretary acknowledge that the Government have a responsibility in this social area and, if so, how do they intend to discharge it?
Comment on this
I fully accept the statement in the first part of the Deputy's question when he claims that there are many social evils in our society.
Comment on this
I should like to broaden the issue because there are many social evils in our society which affect a number of our people. A deserted wife suffers not only from the fact of her desertion but she suffered, unfortunately in some respects, from a sad and, indeed, criminal neglect in many of these areas by the Deputy's party when they were in Government.
Comment on this
There are a number of social evils in our society and very little is known about the cause of them. Recently, we endeavoured to give assistance to appropriate organisations which specialise in the carrying out of such surveys and which have the necessary facilities to do so. In my original reply I referred to the survey carried out by the Economic and Social Research Institute and that, among others, is obviously an appropriate body to carry out such a survey. Any proposals for surveys by any organisation which come within the realm of aspects of social welfare policy made to the Department of Social Welfare will be given very serious consideration.