Time for questions and lengthy replies
Deputy MacSharry and Deputy O’Kennedy complained that lengthy replies left too little time for questions and supplementary questions; the Ceann Comhairle rejected their points of order and defended the Chair’s efforts to expedite business. Another Deputy argued that fuller replies could themselves prompt complaints, and the exchange ended without agreement.
On a point of order, we have been 72 minutes on 18 questions, four minutes per question.
Comment on this
Yes. We have not sufficient time for questions and this side of the House have not an ample opportunity today to have replies to the questions they had asked or to have sufficient supplementary questions because of the long-winded replies.
Comment on this
Could I ask the Ceann Comhairle if he will refer to the printed record of to-day's proceedings to confirm what Deputy MacSharry has said, particularly the inordinate length of the replies to supplementary questions and the fact that——
Comment on this
Order. This is not in order, Deputy O'Kennedy. The Chair appealed to Members today to expedite business.
Comment on this
Some four of the Deputy's questions took almost half an hour. Does he disagree with that?
Comment on this
Is it not correct to say if the Deputies on the Opposition got a very brief reply without the information they sought that they would then register a complaint saying that the Minister was not giving them sufficient information? Now when they are getting a full volume of information——