Building Societies Bill, 1975 [ Seanad ]: Committee Stage (Resumed).
Contributions 130–265 of 265. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.
No. 32 of 1975 ›
The Deputy suggested it. The registrar will be given a lot of authority and he will decide where the funds will be invested. The only time the Central Bank, the Minister for Local Government and the Minister for Finance would come in to it would be when a list of suggested investments would be drawn up. I can see no great socialist plot to go in on private enterprise in this. The money we are talking about is money invested in the main by people with small amounts to invest throughout the country. Deputy Dockrell, who knows a lot about building societies, confirmed what I said earlier. The societies see nothing wrong with this.
Deputy Moore was not comparing like with like. He related section 35 controls to those under sections 37 and 38. Section 35 covers matters of routine day to day administration and is appropriate to control by the registrar. Sections 37 and 38 deal with highly important matters impinging on national housing and financial policies in which Ministers, answerable to the Dáil and Seanad, must concern themselves to the limited extent proposed in the Bill. We are considering financial institutions which will lend this year about £100 million of the savings of Irish investors and will finance the purchase of about 12,000 houses, new and old. It could not be accepted that important issues should be subject only to the control of a public official whose decisions cannot be reviewed or influenced by the Dáil or Seanad or by the Minister responsible for these houses, for national financing and housing policies. We have put in this section for the purpose of giving a wider range to the societies, and nobody objects to that. We have also agreed that there will be a list of investments and we give the registrar the right to decide the amount which can be put in each. What are we arguing about here? I am sure everybody agrees that there should be somebody other than the registrar to select where the investment should go? The registrar will decide the amount.
This matter was fully discussed in the Seanad and most of my explanations were acceptable. I introduced certain amendments and I do not see why we should have the same thing again. I am not saying that Deputies have not the right to raise these matters. Deputy Faulkner faulted me for saying that I would not be prepared to accept amendments. The reason is that I am sure the way we are doing this is correct. I am sure the Opposition, when they consider this, will agree.
Comment on this
The fact that this matter was discussed in the Seanad does not preclude us from discussing it here. If we feel we can elaborate and clarify our views on this matter, we are entitled to do so. Deputy Dockrell has a simplistic approach to it. He thinks that, because the Minister for Finance, with due financial advice, operates the control of ratios between assets and liabilities and the investment of surplus funds, everything will be all right. That Deputy is aware that, if the Minister was short of funds at any time and made a regulation whereby certain changes to his advantage could be made in relation to financing of projects, that regulation could be discussed here but not changed. The majority would troop in behind the Minister.
Comment on this
This cannot be done. No Minister for Finance will have the right to direct where the funds go. That will be done by the registrar.
Comment on this
I should like to return to the point in relation to the control of ratios, the proportion of the liquid assets as against total assets. These liquid assets include Government stocks. The Government could insist on a higher ratio and demand that the extra money should be invested in their stocks. This might help the Minister in the short term but it could create considerable problems for building societies. What the Minister said in relation to our amendments and the sections would pertain irrespective of whether the Ministers were involved or whether the registrar was in charge. He said the building societies had not objected to this provision. That was a rather negative way of putting it.
After Deputy Dockrell spoke the Minister said that his contribution was proof that the societies were satisfied but, so far as I am aware, that is not in accordance with the facts. The building societies were from the beginning totally opposed to the amount of interference which would result from the Bill. They were concerned that so many different bodies— the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Local Government, the registrar, the Central Bank and, through the registrar, I suppose the Minister for Industry and Commerce—were involved. Understandably that was causing them very considerable concern. I asked initially why all these Ministers and so on needed to be concerned. The Minister said the Minister for Finance lays down the conditions for trustee funds. I accept that that is true, but I cannot see what difference it would make if the registrar in charge saw to it that the conditions were fulfilled. I cannot see why all these other Ministers and the Central Bank should be involved.
We should get back to basics and ask ourselves what is our purpose in regard to this Bill? What is one of the most important purposes, apart altogether from ensuring that rogue building societies and societies which cannot stand on their own are refused permission to continue in operation? Our purpose ought to be to ensure that the inflow of money is such that we can attain the objective we have, namely, that the societies should play an even greater part in the provision of housing. Money is a very sensitive article and the fact that the Minister can intervene or interfere, even if he does not do so, could result in investments being made which were not as good as the society might believe they should be and this will affect those who are investing and less money will inevitably be invested. It is very important that we should ensure that there will not be any interference and, irrespective of what the Minister may say, I still believe that the Minister in one way or another will be able to influence to whatever extent he may desire in difficult financial circumstances the investment of the surplus funds. He will also have too much power in relation to the control of ratios between assets and liabilities.
We are not trying to score political points. I do not think that would be possible in regard to this Bill. What we are trying to do is impress on the Minister that we have very strong feelings in relation to these two sections and we believe it would be wise to take that fact into consideration and try to meet the points we have made. The amendments we have tabled may not be as perfect as they should be but if we can reach a situation where we can be assured that the registrar will be the person in control of the administration, with considerable control in relation to financial matters, subject to the Minister for Finance, and that there will not even be a suspicion that the Minister for Finance could intervene or interfere as the exigencies of his own situation arose, then we would have a better Bill and a more satisfactory Bill where the building societies are concerned, where we on this side of the House are concerned and, I am sure, on the other side also, and also where those who will be anxious to borrow money to build houses for themselves are concerned.
Comment on this
Deputy Faulkner is on the wrong argument. The Minister for Finance cannot dictate where the funds go. If the Deputy reads the section again he will realise this is so. It is, of course, a matter of opinion. Deputy Faulkner and his colleagues may feel they have the right of it. At the outset I said this is not a political Bill. This is a matter of opinion and the House must decide. I would be shirking my responsibilities if I said I would amend this because I believe this is the right way to deal with this matter. I am sorry I cannot meet the wishes of Deputy Faulkner and his colleagues but I believe the right decision has been taken and I must stand over it. I have gone into this as fully as I can. I showed I was prepared to improve the Bill, but to do what is suggested would make it not a better Bill but a worse Bill, and so I cannot possibly accept the amendment.
Comment on this
Look at section 38. Subsection (1) provides:
The Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister and the Central Bank, may prescribe the investments in which a society may invest such portion of its funds as are not immediately required by it for the purpose of the society.
That very clearly specifies that the Minister for Finance, while he consults the others, makes the decision and prescribes the investments in which the society may invest. This circumscribes the situation. We would regard the two sections as being the extreme from the Minister's point of view and possibly he would regard the amendments as the extreme from our point of view. Could we not meet somewhere in the middle and reach a conclusion which, while not entirely satisfactory to both, would be at least satisfactory to some extent?
Comment on this
No. I agreed to modifications in the Seanad and those modifications are now in the Bill. Deputy Faulkner is missing the point completely. Subsection (3) provides that the registrar, after consultation with the Minister, the Minister for Finance and the Central Bank, may fix limits in respect of investments in securities or in a specified class or classes of securities and the registrar will be able to classify the investments with regard to different limits for different classes of securities. Someone must say what the money may be put into and, after consultation, the Minister for Finance specifies what this will be and the registrar then decides what proportion of the money can go into a particular investment.
Comment on this
Yes. The only major change is the amount will be specified and the securities in which investments can be made are very much wider than at present.
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance must lay down the ratio of control. That is the only reason why it is there. That is why I mentioned it did have an effect on the trustee status of the societies.
Comment on this
The Minister mentioned several times that building societies did not object to certain things and I accept that.
Comment on this
They were satisfied that the amendments made in the Seanad met their point of view as far as was possible.
Comment on this
I would encourage any building society to make known their views on the matter. However, subsection (4) states:
The investments which the Minister for Finance may prescribe under subsection (1) may, with the consent of the Central Bank, include Central Bank Reserve Bonds and in such a case section 48 of the Act of 1971 shall, notwithstanding subsection (3) of that section, apply to a society as if it were a bank.
To the man in the street the Central Bank reserve bonds will be regarded as a Government issue.
Comment on this
The registrar will decide the amount but I should like to know why he cannot decide the entire matter.
Comment on this
We do not consider the registrar the right person to decide which investments should be included in the list.
Comment on this
I do not agree but I accept that the Minister is entitled to his point of view. It would be a simpler and a better Bill if the amendment were accepted.
Comment on this
It is clear from subsection (1) that the Minister for Finance, after consultation with the Minister for Local Government and the Central Bank, may prescribe the investment in which a society may invest their funds——
Comment on this
The Minister for Finance consults with me and with the Central Bank and he then stipulates——
Comment on this
He makes the declaration as to what is included and what is not included after consultation with others. The registrar decides what money goes into it.
Comment on this
My point is that under this section the Minister for Finance takes the initiative. Why could the registrar not take the initiative?
Comment on this
Somebody makes a decision and the registrar decides what money will be put in. If the registrar made the decision he would be taking all the action, exactly what Deputy Faulkner is suggesting in his amendment and which I do not think is right. The section states that after consultation with the Minister for Local Government and the Central Bank the Minister for Finance makes a decision. The registrar, taking that list, decides where the surplus funds can be invested and the amount that can be invested. This will not be done in a day. The declaration may be made once a year or it might not be made for two years. The Minister will simply update it and that is the only reason for the change. I cannot understand the objection to this.
Comment on this
Would the Minister not agree that occasionally surplus funds could accrue to a building society and that it would require some initiative on the part of somebody? Would not the registrar be in a better position to deal with the surplus than anybody else? I know the Minister will say that the Minister for Finance will have laid down for the registrar how the investment should be made but what will happen if the registrar has knowledge of a better investment?
Comment on this
If a better form of investment comes to light, it will be considered by the people responsible and it will be added to the list. If it was laid down that the registrar, without consulting anybody, could invest surplus funds in something that was not included the result could be that he might invest in something he considered good but which the Central Bank and the Minister for Finance knew was not worthy of such investment. If the undertaking went wrong, the registrar would have more than a red face.
Comment on this
I will withdraw the amendment with the proviso that I will study what the Minister has to say.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 18:
In page 28, line 25, to delete "prescribed" and substitute "fixed".
The purpose of the amendment is simply to correct a drafting error in the text. To use the word "prescribed" in this subsection would mean prescribed by the Minister for Finance in accordance with the definition in section 2. The powers under the subsection are intended to be exercised by the registrar and it is necessary to correct the matter by the substitution of "fixed" for "prescribed".
Comment on this
This section provides that a director of a society who is in any way, directly or indirectly, interested in a contract or proposed contract with the society shall declare the nature of his interest at a meeting of the board of directors. The section details how and when the declaration is to be made and provides for the keeping of records of declarations made by directors. This is a new provision and follows closely the lines of section 194 of the Companies Act, 1963.
Comment on this
I support this section. It is somewhat on the lines of disclosures in relation to the Planning Bill and the same principle applies. It is worthwhile and I support it.
Comment on this
Subsection (1) states:
Every annual return of a society submitted to the Registrar under section 70 shall contain particulars showing the amount of any loan made by the society during the financial year to which the return relates to—
Is this the section one would look to to get details of loans, whether issued for housing and so on?
Comment on this
This section deals only with loans to directors. Section 70 covers the area the Deputy has mentioned.
Comment on this
Subsection (1) states:
It shall not be lawful for a society to pay a director remuneration (whether as director or otherwise) free of income tax or otherwise calculated by reference to or varying with the amount of his income tax or to or with the rate of income tax, except under a contract which was in force on the 5th day of December, 1975 el
Obviously, the Minister regards the payment in those circumstances to be anti-social. If so, why is it being continued for certain individuals?
Comment on this
The reason for it is that it prohibits payment of remuneration free of tax to a director or otherwise. The main objection to the tax free payments is that the tax element has to be borne by society and it is inevitable that the cost to be borne by society for a director's services should vary with the director's income from other sources. Furthermore the members may be unaware of the real cost, including tax, of a director's services where a tax free scheme of remuneration applies. It is new to building societies legislation but it is similar to section 185 of the Companies Act, 1963. Subsection (1) provides that it shall be unlawful for a society to pay to a director a remuneration free of tax except under a contract which was in force on the 5th December, 1975, the date of the publication of the Bill.
Comment on this
Yes, because the contract must have provided expressly for such payments and was not dependent on the rules of the society. There is a similar provision to that in section 186 (1) of the Companies Act, 1963. It is a legal contract which it is not possible to alter at this stage.
Comment on this
Subsection (2) provides that any rule of the society or any contract other that a contract referred to in subsection (1) provided for payment of a director's remuneration tax free shall in future be interpreted as if it provided for payment as a gross sum subject to tax of the net sum mentioned. This does not apply to existing contracts coming under the scope of subsection (1). It is similar also to section 185 (2) of the Companies Act, 1963.
Comment on this
It would have to because it would be assumed it was a legal contract entered into before that date and could not be altered before that date.
Comment on this
I agree entirely with subsection (1) of this section but I would like the Minister to spell out the special circumstances he has in mind in relation to cases where the registrar could dispense with this subsection.
Comment on this
A case arises where a society had a very long list of directors and due to death, retirement or otherwise the reprint of stationery which would have at all times a correct list of directors would cause an unusual burden on the society. It would be exceptional.
Comment on this
Does subsection (1) of this section mean that a person who was a member at the end of the previous financial year before the date of the meeting can vote even though he may not at the specific time the meeting takes place be a member?
Comment on this
No. He must continue to be a member. He must continue to hold shares. He must have been a member before the end of the previous year.
Comment on this
It says a "member" here. Should it not say "shareholder"? An ordinary depositor would not have the right to attend a meeting.
Comment on this
A person entitled to attend the meeting of the society shall be a member who at the end of the last financial year held shares.
Comment on this
I know that but I wanted to clear the matter, in relation to certain comments made over the weekend, that a depositor has not voting rights.
Comment on this
Is there no way of checking a proxy vote? The Minister brought in a provision last year in relation to proxy votes at a general election. Is there any procedure to be gone through in relation to proxy votes?
Comment on this
There is a better chance of ensuring that the person who is entitled to the proxy vote or to the written vote votes.
Comment on this
It could happen but it is not likely to happen. The people who run building societies have fairly sharp eyes about those things and it would be in their own interests to ensure that they did not fall into the wrong hands. Might I suggest that sections 54 to 69, inclusive, are entirely non-controversial? They deal with procedural matters, holding of meetings, keeping of records, passing resolutions, the formulation of annual accounts, directors' reports and the appointment of auditors. We might be able to get over those fairly quickly.
Comment on this
We have to go back to section 51 to get that. The provision is made. All members must be notified. The fact that they do not get it was one of the matters raised in the Seanad. With the big number of people involved there is no way in which it would be possible.
Comment on this
This is the question of displaying a notice. It is the same as in the Central Bank Act, 1971.
Comment on this
I pointed out to the Minister that I had seen some of the accounts of the building societies and they seemed to be fairly difficult to decipher. Will the registrar have them put into a form which will be easily understandable by the ordinary member?
Comment on this
Section 2 of the 1894 Act empowered the chief registrar to direct the form of the annual account and statement, either generally or with respect to any society or class of societies. It required that the account should include particulars of mortgages.
In the interests of flexibility, it is proposed that the registrar will have power to direct the form of the accounts rather than have them prescribed in regulations. He may give directions either generally or in relation to a specified class or classes of societies.
In fixing the form of accounts the registrar will have available to him the particulars called for in the Sixth Schedule to the Companies Act as well as recent recommendations of the consultative Committee of Accountancy Bodies—Ireland. I think we can take it in future accounts will be more readable.
Comment on this
Yes. Sections 66, 67 and 68 deal with the appointment, removal and qualifications of the auditor. The Deputy can take it that he will have to be the bee's knees.
Comment on this
This section provides that a society shall submit an annual return to the registrar and shall submit such other information and returns as the Minister or the registrar may require from time to time. A society will be required to submit the annual return within 21 days of its annual general meeting and to attach an auditor's report on the contents of the return. Every member and depositor of a society shall be entitled to receive a copy of the society's most recent annual return and the auditor's report on it.
It will be noted that annual accounts under section 60 are prepared by a society chiefly for the information of its members and depositors. The annual return to be submitted to the registrar under this section will be on the lines of the annual accounts but will contain much more detailed information. The annual return will constitute the most important source of information available to the registrar to enable him to exercise practical supervision over societies.
Comment on this
Does this mean the society will take responsibility for an offence committed by an officer of the society?
Comment on this
The section precludes the rules of a society from exempting or indemnifying an officer or auditor of a society against liability for negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust. Any such indemnity now in existence will apply only in respect of things done or neglected to be done prior to the commencement of this section. The purpose of the section is to ensure that an officer of the society bears the proper penalty for his own negligence or default and that the funds of the society are not used for that purpose. The section is based on section 200 of the Companies Act, 1963.
Comment on this
Would section 71 (1) in any way involve an officer who vetted a loan on a house and a defective house was sold to a person?
Comment on this
The Deputy is referring to two different things. We are talking about the rules of the societies. Many people make this mistake. The provision of the fund to purchase the house has nothing to do with the state of the house. A bank or a local authority who provided money for the purchase of a house could not be deemed to be responsible for the state of the house purchased with the fund made available.
Comment on this
He would be an officer of a society who had vetted the house and said it was worth £x.
Comment on this
I do not see any of these people knocking around who would do so if the house was not up to the mark. Usually these people are very exact about these things.
Comment on this
For the purposes of this section an auditor of a society is deemed to be an officer of the society by definition. Subsection (1) provides:
Any provision (whether contained in the rules of a society or in any contract with a society or otherwise) for exempting an officer of a society from, or indemnifying him against, any liability which by virtue of any rule of law would otherwise attach to him in respect of any negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust of which he may be guilty in relation to the society shall, subject to subsection (2), be void.
This is as provided in section 200 of the Companies Act, 1963. It is the practice in drafting rules for a society to provide for the indemnity of officers or auditors against costs, losses and expenses incurred in the discharge of their duties. The purpose of the subsection is to ensure that they are not protected in the case of negligence, default, breach of duty or breach of trust. If somebody inspected a house and charged the person borrowing the money for a report, this would be a different situation altogether. The person Deputy Moore is talking about is called a surveyor.
Comment on this
This section provides that a register of the names and addresses of members must be kept by the chief officer of the society. If a member should request the list from the society, must the society make the list available to him?
Comment on this
The section provides, briefly, that a society shall keep a register of the names and addresses of its members. Any member may provide a communication relating to the affairs of the society and request the secretary of the society to issue the communication to all members. If the secretary is satisfied that the application is made in good faith, he shall comply with the request. The secretary may refuse to comply with such a request but must give the member the grounds for such refusal. The member may then refer the matter to the registrar as a dispute. Provision is made so that the registrar may, having heard the representations, direct the secretary to comply, subject to such limits or conditions as the registrar thinks fit.
It will be noted that the purpose of the section is to provide a formal procedure to enable a member to communicate with other members. In practice, however, it is almost certain that the members would simply place an advertisement in a newspaper and thus avoid the formalities and cost of printing and postage of, possibly, thousands of notices.
If this were not provided, somebody could go in just to be a nuisance. The societies had to be protected against that, and this is being done.
Comment on this
This section requires information to be kept on other directorships held by the directors of a building society. Would information on holdings not be more appropriate?
Comment on this
This section places an obligation on a society to keep a register containing specified particulars relating to the directors of the society and also makes provision for the inspection and obtaining copies of the register by members and other persons.
Since building society directors act as the custodians of the savings and deposits of the public, it is only right that existing and potential investors should be able to obtain reasonable particulars of the persons who manage the affairs of the society.
These provisions, which are new to building society legislation, are based generally on section 195 of the Companies Act, 1963. The following particulars must be kept: his present surname and forenames and any other former names, and his present residential address. It will be noted that this section requires not only the current name and address of a director to be included in the register, but any other former names as well. It is not considered necessary to make exemptions in the case of certain former names as is done in section 195 (12) (d) of the Companies Act, 1963.
Subsection (2) provides that a register under this section shall also contain the following particulars relating to each director: his business occupation, if any; and any other directorships held or bodies corporate incorporated in the State. That is what Deputy Faulkner is talking about. They must also keep those.
Comment on this
Not a record of holdings. It would be desirable that persons looking at the list of directors should be in a position to ascertain the names of other bodies corporate of which they are directors. Requirements similar to the above are contained in section 195 (2) (d) and (e) of the Companies Act, 1963, except that to be in line with EEC requirements, the requirement that the nationality of directors be stated is omitted.
Comment on this
Section 75 (1) prohibits the giving of commission in consideration of or in connection with the introduction of mortgage business to societies. Does this stand on its own? Is it apart altogether from the rules of the society or does a society provide for such requirements in its rules?
Comment on this
It stands on its own. Section (1) provides that a society shall not give commission in consideration of, or in connection with the introduction of, or an undertaking to introduce, mortgage business. The purpose of this subsection is to prohibit a society from paying commission to any person, such as a broker, for introducing mortgage business or for undertaking to do so. In the normal course of events, demand for mortgages exceeds the supply and it is therefore not necessary for a society to pay commission to attract customers for that sector of building society business.
It is not unusual that somebody would set himself up and that a person looking for money to build a house would go to this person who would introduce him to a society and get a commission for doing so. That commission does not come from the society. It comes from the unfortunate person who is buying the house or borrowing the money. Since he or she could do that simply by going to the society, it is not considered a good idea that somebody should use what could be referred to as his influence to get it for the borrower.
Comment on this
Section 75 (6) says that an officer, solicitor or surveyor shall not accept any commission and so on. It would appear to me that the definition of an "officer" in section 2 does not clearly cover staff. I am just wondering if a branch manager, for example, would be included in "officer". Could he, for example, receive commission?
Comment on this
It would depend on the facts of his case, whether he was or was not an officer. It includes a manager or a secretary. The section prohibits an officer, solicitor or surveyor from accepting commission in connection with the effecting of an insurance policy, including life assurance when the policy is used as additional security for a loan, where the society makes an addition to a loan to enable payment to be made of a premium on the policy, where the policy is taken out to comply with the terms of the mortgage. This is in line with section 74 (3) of the British Act of 1962. That Act stipulated that the prohibition applies if the policy was effected through the society or if the society nominated or selected a person by whom the policy is to be issued. The idea again is to prevent people cashing in on those who are borrowing money, getting money which should not be required.
Comment on this
In general, no, but the structures of the societies are not always the same, and it is a question of deciding where his standing was in the society. I think it is covered, but I am not quite sure in what section. Deputy Faulkner referred to the definition section and said it is not quite covered. I think it is covered.
Comment on this
Normally a branch manager would not be covered but there would be exceptions, where he might be a branch manager plus something else.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 21:
In page 46, lines 24 to 29 to delete subsection (1), and substitute as follows:
"(1) The Minister may, in the interests of the orderly and proper regulation of building society business and having regard to the demand for loans for house purchase, on the recommendation of the Registrar, make regulations in relation to the purposes and amounts of loans by societies.".
Section 77 is, in my view, very controversial, and I think the building societies themselves are concerned about it. It proposes to give the Minister power to regulate the purposes and amounts of the loans made by societies. Specifically he could regulate the maximum amount of a loan, the purposes for which loans could be made, and the maximum amount which may be lent to a body corporate. These powers are new. As far as I could gather, the Minister had intended going somewhat further by regulating the conditions on which loans could be offered.
I suppose in one sense—it depends on the way you look at it—the new powers could be looked on as a back door to nationalisation; in another sense they could be regarded as a necessary response to abuses which have crept into the operations of building societies in recent years. I would like to emphasise that we deplore as much as the Minister or anyone else the granting of loans on business premises, of loans to companies or, in fact, of any loan which does not help to house a family. We also have sympathy with the view that the resources of societies could be spread a bit wider by giving more loans for smaller houses.
However, we have learned, and I think the Minister has also learned, of the pitfalls of endeavouring to regulate loans too closely. When the Minister, because of the power given to him over the societies for the granting of the subsidy, regulated closely the amounts and the types of loan, at one stage, a completely false housing market was created, where the demand for secondhand house collapsed and this had a severely damaging effect on the market for new houses, because many prospective buyers could not sell the houses in which they were living.
I think this was a mistake and that it is now recognised as a serious blunder which had a detrimental effect on the building industry. The interference referred to earlier was not in the best interests of the societies, the investors and the buyers, although a small number did benefit. To avoid the risk of a recurrence of such decisions this section should be amended by placing the initiative with the registrar who will not be motivated by short-term political considerations. During the passage of the Bill through the Seanad the Minister conceded something similar. We did not oppose section 76 because of the Minister's concession. I would ask the Minister to consider the amendment which reads:
The Minister may, in the interests of the orderly and proper regulation of building society business and having regard to the demand for loans for house purchase, on the recommendation of the Registrar, make regulations in relation to the purposes and amounts of loans by societies.
The amendment was specifically framed to overcome the objections to amendments in the Seanad in that only the Minister can make regulations. We would prefer to have the regulations made by the Minister so that they could be discussed in the House. It is very important that it should be seen that the Minister cannot interfere in the manner in which he could interfere under the Bill as it stands and that the registrar should make recommendations and the Minister make the necessary regulations.
Comment on this
The effect of the amendment proposed by Deputy Faulkner would be to delete all reference to the Minister for Finance and to secure that any regulations under the section were made "on the recommendation of", rather than "after consultation with", the registrar. The amendment would also seem to imply that these regulations would be a more common feature of building society business than I had in mind. It is fair to say that in drafting the amendments Deputy Faulkner took a look at section 76 where he found that regulations under that section would be made "on the recommendation of the registrar".
It is a simple matter to justify the position of the registrar in section 76 because that section deals with the administration of the societies themselves and it is the registrar's function to oversee these matters. Section 77 is a different matter, where we are concerned with the availability of funds for the housing programme. The section has been drafted in a very deliberate way so as to give due weight to the authorities that are involved. The Minister for Local Government is empowered to make regulations with the consent of the Minister for Finance and after consulting the registrar regarding the amounts and purposes of loans. I should say here that I do not envisage a permanent requirement for regulations of this nature. They would only be made in the circumstances outlined at the commencement of subsection (1)—when the Minister considered it expedient and when the interests of the orderly and proper regulation of building society business and the demand for loans warranted it.
Deputy Faulkner referred to the period when interference by the Minister for Local Government dried up the secondhand house market. If Deputy Faulkner was as close to it as I was at the time he would realise that it was necessary action. When it became possible to change the regulation it was done with very good effect. If the situation had continued, the money being given to the societies for house building would have wound up financing houses for those who were not as badly in need as those who actually benefited. The Minister for Local Government is the Minister charged with responsibility for the housing programme and in discharging that responsibility he has to have regard to its financial implications and to the contributions which will be required from the various financial sources if the programme is to be implemented.
The Minister for Finance is involved since he is the person with responsibility for the provision of State funds for all services including housing. As regards the registrar, he will be in close touch with the societies and will have readily available to him a steady flow of information on the affairs of the societies. He will know, for instance, the pattern of the societies' lending programmes, the level of inflow to societies, the extent of the demand for loans, the extent to which they make loans for new or previously occupied houses, the percentage of the purchase price which the average loan represents and other information relevant to the consideration of whether it would be expedient to consider the making of such regulations at any time. To adopt Deputy Faulkner's amendment would require the registrar to be an expert not only on building society affairs but on the overall housing programme and its financing. We have heard a great deal about the need for a strong and independent registrar and I am fully in agreement with that, but to burden him with responsibility for the housing programme as a whole is going too far.
I would ask Deputy Faulkner to withdraw his amendment. The type of regulations to be made under this section might include regulations to ensure that a society did not, for instance, have a high proportion of their mortgage assets tied up in a small number of large loans or devote an unduly high proportion of funds to business lending. The intention is to ensure that commercial lending policies are not adopted by societies but that due regard is had to the demand for home loans of moderate amounts.
During Committee Stage debate in the Seanad I stated that the societies have in the main been very conscious of their social responsibilities in regard to the amounts and purposes of loans, and I stand by that statement. The present Bill is intended to last a long time and to cater for almost any foreseeable circumstances. I feel that justice would not be done to this comprehensive legislative measure if the provisions of this section were not included. I am strengthened in this conviction by the inclusion in the British Building Societies Act of 1962 of the very elaborate provisions relating to special advances. Those provisions were intended to limit the making of large loans and the making of loans to bodies corporate to within 10 per cent of a society's total lending. Although the method adopted in the British Act has come in for some criticism, the purpose of the provisions is obvious.
Prior to March, 1973 no controls were exercised over the lending policy of building societies in this country. As from 23rd March, 1973, controls have been exercised administratively in conjunction with the operation of the composite tax arrangement and the payments between May, 1973 and February, 1976 of the special subsidy on shares and deposits.
Deputy Faulkner said that the building societies were very much opposed to this. We have no evidence that that is so. We have been in close contact with the building societies during the preparation of this Bill. The Bill was not drafted for the purpose of pleasing building societies. We want to ensure that the building societies will be able to work within the regulations. To be fair to them the building societies are now doing a good job in regard to providing money. Up to £100 million will be provided this year. To say that the building societies would not be pleased with a particular section is no argument for deleting that section. On reflection, Deputy Faulkner will agree with this.
Comment on this
I should like to refute any suggestion that the building societies were responsible for my contribution.
Comment on this
It was suggested that I was acting for the building societies because I said that the building societies would not like it.
Comment on this
I could not accept the reasons given by the Minister for the manner in which he interfered with the provision of loans. His point was that, if he had not interfered, people who were already housed would get houses rather than those who were in need of houses. This action so upset the market that there was total confusion. A change had to be made in order to introduce some regularity.
Comment on this
If the Minister wants to start that I will ask him how he managed to build as many houses in 1976 as in 1974 with 12,000 fewer workers? If the Minister would like to go into the political aspect of it, we will deal with that too.
Comment on this
The Minister said he could not unload the whole responsibility for the housing programme on to the registrar. That is not what is intended here at all. The Minister said that if he were to do so it might happen that all the money would be poured into a few very large houses. I would take it that the registrar appointed would be a fully qualified and intelligent person, one who would recognise the function of the building society, that its business was to get in as much money as possible in order to loan it to people for the building of houses. I have no doubt but that he would perform that function. He would know what were the objectives of the building societies and would ensure that the money was expended in the manner one would expect. I want to underline the fact that there was interference by the Minister and, as the Bill stands, he can do it again. Perhaps, for the purpose of housing statistics, he might feel it more important to have a number of houses built rather than ensuring a steady flow of house building.
To get away from the political aspect of it, I put forward this amendment for the same reasons as those put forward in relation to sections 37 and 38, that is, to have as little State interference as possible. We recognise the need for control. We recognise the right of the State to control to a considerable extent the activities of building societies. But we felt it was overdone in this Bill, that the Bill would be much more effective—one in which the public would have much more confidence— were there to be less control exercised by various Ministers. We would not have tabled the amendment had we not thought it would make the operation of the Bill more effective.
Comment on this
Deputy Faulkner and his colleagues have been quite reasonable in their approach to this Bill so far. But I am quite sure he will agree with me that we could not allow a situation to recur which did obtain when I first took an interest in these matters officially, when there was at least one building society lending more money for the purpose of purchasing land, hotels and pubs than for house building. Nobody would suggest that this should be the situation. Although it is most unlikely that anything like that would happen again—certainly I am sure present building societies would not become involved—they, like myself, will not be there forever. I believe it necessary that we have this type of control, that we have it in this way and that it will be administered in a reasonable manner. We would not be doing our duty if we allowed a loophole in the Bill which permitted that type of thing to recur. There is no question at all that the registrar will not be consulted. But the registrar will not be somebody sitting, waiting day and night to advise building societies on every facet of their business. There will have to be some means devised by which a general policy will be handed out, that will operate in the normal way and I believe that the section as drafted, does that. The amendment suggested by Deputy Faulkner would weaken the section and it would be a mistake if it were accepted.
Comment on this
Surely Deputy Faulkner's amendment rather than weakening the section would strengthen it. I believe building societies have a very important role to play in the housing drive. I agree with the Minister that these regulations are necessary to ensure that they do so. We do not want to weaken the Bill in any way.
If one looks at amendment No. 23, to section 78, one will see that it would tie building societies down to giving loans only on residential property. I believe that Deputy Faulkner's amendment would achieve what the man in the street wants to see done—designate the type of loan, the amount, and ensure that every possible penny is loaned for house building only. Certainly we would never advocate loans being given for the building of hotels, publichouses, supermarkets and so on. We want building societies to play the role intended for them, that is, to help in the housing drive. Deputy Faulkner prepared his amendments after long consultation and study of the deliberations in the Seanad. The Minister has said that we have been very reasonable. I suggest that the Minister might take another look at this if not now then overnight. I know the Minister will contend that he did so in the Seanad but the Bill would be strengthened in its passage through this House by the inclusion of these amendments and prospective householders' interests also would be better safeguarded. I am sure the Minister will agree with me that our whole purpose for being here is to push the housing drive. Therefore, we cannot miss an opportunity on any Bill of ensuring that every possible penny goes into housing. I assure the Minister of the sincerity of this side of the House in relation to these amendments.
Comment on this
I am anxious to be co-operative about this, but, before the Bill ever saw the light of day, there was a great deal of work and research put into it, and discussions were held with various people involved in building societies, with the whole provision of housing and so on. Then, in the Seanad, we had a very useful debate, on which I have already complimented Senators. Nothing new has been introduced here this evening. Since that is so it would be a mistake for me—having told Senators I could not accept their amendments—to decide now that I could accept an almost similar change to that suggested by them. I am not being unreasonable but I believe that the section, as it stands, is a better one than if Deputy Faulkner's amendment was accepted.
Comment on this
I move amendment No. 23:
In page 46, after line 56, to insert the following:
"(3) A society may make loans only on residential property."
I do not think this is an amendment with which anybody could disagree. It sums up our total commitment on this Bill, that of seeking to provide more dwellings. Despite what the Minister said about having built so many houses in the past few years— and I have always felt we should take housing out of politics—here is an opportunity for this House to endorse the wishes of most of our citizens who are interested in housing. We could ensure that the building societies will direct their considerable assets on to the housing drive and this would supplement to a great degree the great part being played by local authorities and housing agencies. This would surely strengthen the Bill and would be a very popular amendment. Despite the many houses that have been built over the years, we are still very short of houses and the private sector which accounts for most of the building needs every incentive that can be given and every penny we can spare. To invest in housing not alone brings financial reward but it brings satisfaction to a person when he knows that he is making his money do the most good. I can see no objection to this amendment. I strongly recommend it.
Comment on this
The Minister in opposing the previous amendment stated that one of the problems was that one building society had issued loans for various things apart from housing and, therefore, if the Minister is anxious to tie up that situation this amendment offers the opportunity.
Comment on this
The situation is that the last section having been passed there is no necessity for this. Another objection to this amendment is that at the present time as Deputy Moore said, and for some considerable time to come, we have a situation where all the money that can be provided from building societies will be necessary for house building but we could reach a stage before the end of the life of this Bill when more money would be available than would be necessary. The last Building Societies Bill lasted nearly 100 years so within the next 100 years who knows what is likely to happen? Deputy Faulkner's amendment would mean that in the event of such a thing happening no money would be spent on anything except as the amendment says "a society may make loans only on residential property". Under the previous section the regulation will be made that that is what must be done. We would be right to say that in 30, 40 or 50 years' time if there was a surplus of money in building societies which was not required for housing they should have to hold on to the money, that they could not spend it or loan it on anything else except residential property. I would ask Deputy Faulkner to look at that aspect of it.
Comment on this
I cannot imagine a situation in future where we may have too much money for houses. The fact is that the Minister wanted to refuse the previous amendment on the basis that it might be used for purposes other than the purpose of residential property and now the Minister is changing foot by not accepting this amendment. Having listened to the Minister's argument, I must say I am not thoroughly convinced.
Comment on this
This section states:
A loan made by a society shall not exceed the valuation in accordance with section 79 on the freehold or leasehold estate offered as security for the loan.
I understand that it has happened in Britain that people who had good salaries but had no capital were given a grant which was higher than that but I do not know whether I can make a very strong argument on that.
Comment on this
Subsection (1) provides that a loan made by a society shall not exceed the valuation of the property on the security of which the loan is made. Subsection (2) provides that, in determining the amount of a loan, a society may take into account the value of any additional security other than freehold or leasehold estate offered in respect of the loan. This is a re-enactment of section 3 of the Building Societies Act, 1942.
Subsection (3) empowers the registrar to issue a direction in relation to the classes of additional security, other than freehold or leasehold estate which may be taken into account by a society in determining the amount of a loan, and to direct the conditions or arrangements which shall apply to the taking into account of a specified class or classes of additional security. Existing law does not lay down any requirements regarding the classes of security that may be taken as additional security. In the British Building Societies Act, 1962, the permitted classes of additional security are set out in the Third and Fourth Schedules to the Act. Powers are conferred on the chief registrar in section 26 (5) of that Act to extend or vary the classes of additional security. The proposal in the subsection is more simple and flexible and is so worded that it can take account of the types of security and arrangements that are within the ambit of the British Act. That meets Deputy Faulkner's point of view.
Comment on this
One of the most important functions in the management of a building society is the assessment of the adequacy of the security offered for a loan. The purpose of this section is to ensure that satisfactory arrangements exist for the valuation and assessment of the security being offered for a loan and that such a valuation and assessment is carried out in an impartial manner. This section will place a responsibility on every director to satisfy himself as to these arrangements.
There are two distinct elements involved in the arrangements: firstly, a written valuation report on the property involved must be prepared by a person who is not an officer of the society and, secondly, the assessment of the adequacy of the security must be carried out by an officer or officers of the society, by reference, inter alia, to the written valuation report. A valuation report prepared by a person who has a financial interest in the disposal of the estate may not be accepted.
Deputy Moore asked about this earlier and Section 79 is where it comes in. Existing legislation is silent on the detailed arrangements to be made in connection with assessment of the adequacy of security taken by a society and of the persons who may report on the value of such security.