We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Social Welfare Benefits.

Board and Lodging as Unemployment Assistance Means

Summary

O’Kennedy urged a change to stop young people living with parents from being disqualified when board and lodging is assessed as means. Cluskey said each case is assessed individually, sometimes with only a nominal amount counted, but the Government did not intend to change the rules.

asked the Minister for Social Welfare if he will disregard the benefit of board and lodging as means in respect of young people who apply for unemployment assistance.

Comment on this
Frank Cluskey Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Social Welfare (Mr. Cluskey) Labour Party

The yearly value of any benefit or privilege enjoyed by an applicant, such as free or partly free board and lodging, is one of the items which, under the relevant statutory provisions, must be taken into account by deciding officers and appeals officers in the assessment of means of applicants for unemployment assistance and there is no power to disregard this or any other assessable item in particular cases.

Comment on this

In view of the fact that so many people are being disallowed simply because they are living at home while waiting for employment, will the Parliamentary Secretary consider introducing amending legislation so that the question of the board and lodgings which they can get in their homes from their parents will not be assessed against them to disqualify them for unemployment assistance?

Comment on this

As the Deputy is probably aware, this has been the practice for some considerable time. It is not a new innovation. Each case is treated on its individual merits so there is no overall approach to it. Each case is assessed individually.

Comment on this

Allowing for the fact that it may have been the practice for some time, I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary will agree that the matter has become much more critical because of the number of young people who have to stay at home with their parents while they are looking for employment? Does the Parliamentary Secretary not agree that it seems to be almost against the concept of what we hold for the family that if a young man were turned out of his home he would qualify? Because this person stays at home with no income his food and accommodation are assessed as income to disqualify him for unemployment assistance. Is there not a conflict there? If this young person was living on his own and turned out of his home by his family, he would be entitled to unemployment assistance but because he is living with his family he is not.

Comment on this

The situation is not changed. It is the same as it has been for quite a considerable time. As I explained to the Deputy, there is no overall approach to this. Each particular case is assessed individually.

Comment on this

Allowing for that, I am sure the Parliamentary Secretary will recognise that in a number of cases the actual assessment for board and lodgings is made at £10 or £11 which is in excess of the income and those people are disqualified. In view of the number of unemployed people who have finished school who are now staying at home—that situation has changed—does the Parliamentary Secretary not think it is appropriate to change the statutory provisions so that the benefit of board and lodgings, if not ignored, is assessed as income in some way to allow the person to qualify?

Comment on this

As I explained to the Deputy, there are cases where the deciding officer or the appeals officer would consider it appropriate that only a very nominal sum would be taken into consideration in regard to free board and lodgings, depending on the individual circumstances of the case. There is no uniform assessment as such. All the relevant factors of the case are taken into consideration.

Comment on this

The Parliamentary Secretary and I know of many cases of hardship. In view of that, is he prepared to consider amending the statutory provisions so that young people will be put in a better position than they are at the moment?

Comment on this

It is not contemplated to change that situation.

12.

Comment on this