We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Solitary Confinement.

Hunger strikes and close confinement

Summary

The Minister said refusing food is a breach of prison discipline that may cost privileges but does not necessarily lead to close confinement; hunger strikers confined to bed are alone in their cells. Brugha warned that isolation could worsen their mental distress, while the Minister defended the practice when prisoners were weak.

Can the Minister tell the House whether involvement or participation in a hunger strike constitutes grounds for solitary confinement or for being kept alone?

Comment on this

Participation in a hunger strike—in other words, the refusal of food—is a breach of good order and discipline in prisons and gives rise to loss of privileges but not necessarily to close confinement.

Comment on this

In the present instance has this occurred?

Comment on this

It would occur to the extent that people who are on hunger strike are confined to bed. In that sense they would be alone in their cells.

Comment on this

Without taking into consideration the merits or otherwise of the reasons for such actions, would the Minister appreciate that the stress of mind which results from a hunger strike can be aggravated considerably by reason of a person being alone?

Comment on this

That may well be but if the prisoners choose voluntarily to refuse food, they are in breach of prison discipline and if they are confined to bed because of their weak condition it is illogical for them to complain of being left alone.

Comment on this