Ferenka dispute and threatened closure
Mitchell pressed the Labour Minister on efforts to settle the dispute and protect jobs at Ferenka, while the Minister said settlement efforts were continuing and public discussion could prejudice them. O’Brien challenged the Government’s handling and alleged the matter was being ignored; the Chair repeatedly tried to move to the next question. The Minister said he was closely monitoring the situation and shared concern for the jobs.
asked the Minister for Labour, in view of the threatened closure of Ferenka Ltd., Limerick, the action that has been taken by his Department or agencies thereof to help find a settlement to the dispute; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
I would refer the Deputy to the statement made by the Taoiseach yesterday as to the possibility of further initiatives within our industrial relations framework, and to the view he expressed that in those circumstances questions and answers in the House might not be helpful.
I want to assure the Deputy that efforts towards a possible settlement are continuing and I would repeat that discussion on the situation in the House at this time could be prejudicial to these, or any other efforts at settlement.
Comment on this
This side of the House are anxious to expedite a solution. Would the Minister disassociate himself from a scurrilous inference in the Taoiseach's statement yesterday where he implied that we were only concerned with making political capital? What further action has the Minister taken following his initiatives over two weeks ago after our attempt to raise the matter in the House?
Comment on this
As regards the first part of the question, I am not sure that I know what the Deputy is referring to. Secondly, I have said to the Deputy that I do not believe further discussion in public is any help to a difficult and delicate situation. I would appreciate the co-operation of the Deputy and the House in that respect. The Deputy will have an opportunity of questioning me further at a more appropriate time.
Comment on this
I welcome, as I said earlier, the Minister's intervention in this dispute. Our only concern is to expedite a solution. The Minister's intervention was of a very flexible nature. It allows scope for change. Has the Minister put forward any amended proposals to get discussions going? Are any discussions going on between the parties involved?
Comment on this
I am disappointed the Deputy should be pushing this so hard. I have impressed on him the delicate nature of this matter.
Comment on this
The Deputy sounds aggrieved. There is a delicate situation here and I advise the Deputy in the public interest to allow the discussion to end at that. The Deputy will have plenty opportunity in the future of pressing the matter and asking me questions.
Comment on this
Can we take it that the Minister is doing something about the matter at this moment?
Comment on this
The Minister is very concerned about the situation and keeping in touch with it hourly.
Comment on this
I do not think this is a matter which should be passed over. It is a serious matter.
Comment on this
I am in charge here. If the Deputy does not obey the ruling of the Chair, I will have to take other action. The Deputy is giving information not seeking it. I will not permit that.
Comment on this
Has the Minister washed his hands of this particular problem and handed it over to the Minister for Industry, Commerce and Energy? Apparently the spokesman for this particular problem seems to be in that area. He said it was not a matter for the Government, that it had to be resolved between the people involved. This is a serious matter. The jobs of Ferenka is one thing but the future development of the IDA is another matter. If we do not resolve this in the very near future, future job creation will be hampered.
Comment on this
Will the Deputy please resume his seat? If the Deputy does not resume his seat, I will have to ask him to leave the House.
Comment on this
I permit the Deputy to ask a question at all times when it is relevant. I will not permit a statement.
Comment on this
May I ask a further question because it is a serious matter? I regret there have been differences on this subject. I want to be sure that the answer the Minister has given is not an excuse for inaction on his part. I want to be sure that the Minister, his Department or agencies under his Department are actively pursuing a settlement because of the seriousness of this dispute. Will the Minister satisfy me on that point?
Comment on this
I have told the Deputy that the situation is being closely watched and that it is a difficult, delicate situation. I share the concern expressed about those jobs. I have shared that concern for many weeks. I appreciate the Deputy's statement of support at my intervention but because of the delicacy and the difficulty of this situation Deputies would be well advised not to discuss the matter further at this particular time.