We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Road Transport Bill 1978: Committee Stage.

Contributions 150–307 of 307. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

Bill Road Transport Bill 1978
Enacted

No. 1 of 1978 ›

Before replying substantially to the points made by the Minister, I wonder would he confirm that this is confined to international agreements. Section 5 (1) reads:

Where an international agreement relating to international transport by road to which the State is a party, or an agreement, arrangement or resolution relating to such transport to which the Minister is a party so requires. . .

They are alternatives. It could be either an international agreement or any other agreement. For instance, the Minister could have an agreement with some private group here. He could have an agreement with CIE, and the power conferred by this section could be used in relation to such an internal private deal by the Minister, which could be one with considerable political connotations, one which was not achieved by diplomatic negotiation in international circles where there were proper checks and balances, one which was a back door agreement by the Minister with some vested interest in the transport field here. He would have the power to exempt a class of person from the provisions of the various Acts pursuant to that agreement, a private agreement, without having to seek the approval of the Dáil, or without even having to inform the Dáil that such an agreement had been entered into by him.

Comment on this

No. It relates solely to international transport.

Comment on this

I do not accept the Minister's assertion in the matter. I want to turn my attention not to the Minister's assertion but to what is contained in the Bill. It could be international transport which was being authorised by the Minister not pursuant to an international agreement but pursuant to a domestic agreement.

Comment on this

No. It relates to international transport.

Comment on this

That is not what the section says.

Comment on this

I do not know how it would arise in practice in any case. We are referring here to changes. As things stand at the moment, under EEC provisions I have power to make regulations. I have not got that power in relation to international transport related to ECMT. All I am doing here is taking that power. It relates purely to international transport.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

No. I now come to the main objection made by the Minister to my proposal, which was that he could not enter into effective international discussions unless he could make orders under this legislation by a back door method which did not even involve informing the Dáil about the orders he was making. To my mind that suggestion is ludicrous.

Many if not most international negotiations on EEC matters involve some changes in our law. If one is talking about negotiations on the EEC price package for farm products, if that is approved it will involve changes in our law, because it will involve changes in consumer prices and these will have to be adjusted by a household goods order under the Prices Act. Although they spring directly from and are an inevitable result of negotiations entered into and completed in Brussels by the European Council of Ministers of Agriculture, under the Prices Act those orders can be annulled by resolution within 21 days by this House.

I am not aware that the Minister for Agriculture has complained that he cannot negotiate in Brussels because of the fact that the agreement he enters into may be annulled by this House to the extent to which it affects domestic consumer prices because under the Prices Acts Members of this House have the right to table a motion seeking to annul an agreement. This does not inhibit the Minister in any way. Therefore he is making a very poor argument in opposition to the amendment.

We all know that international negotiations are entered into by the Government in good faith and that if there is involved a change in the law the Government must make the change through the legislature. This is a common feature of international agreements. It is ridiculous for the Minister, with a majority of 20, to express the fear that to inform the House of an order might mean its defeat. There is no problem in regard to his succeeding in having ratified by the House any exemption in relation to the sort of agreement we are talking about, but what is important is that there be some discussion of the agreement before it is passed here. Although the Opposition would not be able to defeat an order they should be given the opportunity of expressing their views on it. Such discussion would give the House the opportunity of ascertaining what was involved in the exercise under consideration. That is what the amendment is designed to achieve. Presumably after a brief discussion of the order it would be passed by the House. This would ensure that Deputies who might object to an order would have the opportunity of tabling a motion to annul.

I cannot see how this very limited power would inhibit the Minister in any way in respect of international negotiations. As I have pointed out, such a provision exists in respect of agricultural negotiations and I have not heard any complaint from the Minister concerned that, for instance, he cannot negotiate in Brussels in relation to food prices by reason of maximum prices orders having to be made by order under the Prices Acts. The area we are speaking of here is less contentious than agriculture, so I do not see any problem for the Minister in agreeing to our amendment.

Comment on this

I believe my argument to be valid. The changes that would be made are relatively minor. Already we have power in relation to the EEC countries in this respect and nobody has found anything wrong with that situation. Neither is there anything wrong in this case. I have explained what I regard would be the difficulties in relation to the amendment. Consequently, I am justified in refusing to accept it.

Comment on this

The Minister is experienced in the area of international negotiation, and from this experience can be illustrate how in practice there could be interference with international negotiations by reason of the existence of a power providing for the laying of an order before the House? Is he suggesting that his fear relates to the possibility of his stance in international negotiations being defeated in this House?

Comment on this

No. If we are to follow the Deputy's argument it seems that the sort of agreement reached would be of no consequence so long as the Minister succeeded in having it passed in the House.

Comment on this

Is the Minister suggesting that the position he is incorporating in this Bill is better in some way than what is contained in my amendment in so far as parliamentary control is concerned? If the Minister gets his way the result will be that these matters can be put through without being discussed here and that in addition there would be no statutory obligation on him to inform the House of what he was doing. The Minister was trying to argue that it would be impossible for him to negotiate internationally if a draft order could not be put through the House. He contends that acceptance of my amendment would tie his hands in regard to such negotiations, but I have asked him to illustrate how in practice this would happen.

Comment on this

When a Minister makes an order that order is published, so there is no question of an order being made secretly. If I am given the power being sought an order would be published after it had been made. What, then, is the problem.

Comment on this

Although the order might be publicised there would be no statutory obligation on the Minister to have the order drawn to the attention of this House. In the Order Paper for each day there is a list of documents that are laid before the Dáil. Today, for instance, we read that the Public Service (Delegation of Ministerial Functions) Order, 1978, has been statutorily laid before the Dáil.

If the section goes through in its present form the Minister will be under no obligation, although an order would be published, to make details of that order available to the

House or to have it placed in the Library for the perusal of the elected representatives who have been sent here by the people to ensure that Ministers do not abuse their functions in any way, nor would there be any obligation on the Minister to provide an opportunity for debating contentious orders. Either of the amendments I am suggesting would provide that opportunity. I wonder what the Minister has to fear from public discussion of the orders he is making under this section. Of course it would be much more convenient if orders could be made with the knowledge only of those directly involved, but the question is not one of convenience. We are considering the exercise by the Minister of delegated functions, functions conferred on him by statute.

I fail to understand the reason behind the Minister's refusal to provide for discussion of the exercise of these powers. It is very rarely that a Deputy seeks to have annulled any order laid before the House, but it is a safeguard to have provision for such a situation. It is my contention that in every case an order should be discussed, but this seems to be more than the Minister is prepared to agree to, and neither is he prepared to accept the much more modest proposal of having the order laid before the House and provision being made whereby a motion could be tabled seeking an annulment of the order. I would be happy to withdraw my amendment if the Minister would assure me that at Report Stage he would introduce an amendment to provide for the 21-day procedure. This would mean that there would be no necessity for a debate but that if anybody wished to put down a motion to annul there would be such provision. In 99 cases out of 100 there would be no such motion and no debate would be required, but the safeguard would exist. If the Minister is prepared to accept that normal and standard provision in the taking of order-making powers by the Minister under statute, I am prepared to withdraw my amendment which goes a little further.

Comment on this

We are dealing with relatively minor matters. I will consider either for Report Stage or the Seanad the suggestion that the order be laid on the table of the House.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): And can be annulled by motion passed within 21 days?

Comment on this

I have to consider. Give me time to consider.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan) : Certainly.

Comment on this

I cannot accept the amendment as it is.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Is the amendment withdrawn?

Comment on this

In the light of the undertaking given by the Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): This is a section to provide that a certificate of a chief superintendent or a superintendent acting as chief superintendent shall be admitted as evidence of certain facts until the contrary is proved. This is for the purpose of clarification. Section 7 (1) (b) says:

that on a specified date or during a specified period a vehicle plate was not on issue to a specified person from a specified vehicle plate issuing station either in respect of a specified vehicle or otherwise.

Is it obligatory on an applicant to apply for the plate in the area in which he resides or in a certain area?

Comment on this

I understand that there is a plate issuing station specified on the licence.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

Would the Minister tell me if my interpretation of the section is correct? There is at least one and there may be more licence holders who have permission to hold up to 15 or 20 licences. I do not remember the precise number. Is it the purpose of the section to prevent them breaking them into 15 separate licences and then multiplying that by six? Can they break them down only to three because each licence must have a maximum of six in it? Is that the purpose—to prevent them taking advantage of the distribution system by breaking their licences down into 15 separate ones?

Comment on this

No, not exactly. Take a man who at the moment has two licences and on one of his licences he has at this given moment two vehicles and on the other he has one vehicle. That means that he could have twelve and six, which is 18. What we decided here was that within the period of one year he could divide them as he wished provided he did not go below six on either one of them.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

Is it a total of 12?

Comment on this

No. He would have a right to a total of 12 on one and six on the other. He could have nine and nine, if that is what he would prefer. He could not have, say, one and 17.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): If he as two on one and three on the other, can he have 18 then?

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

He would have a total then of 30—five sixes or two fifteens. Is that correct?

Comment on this

No. Could I go back on the example I gave? Suppose a haulier at this given moment has two licences. On one of the licences he has a right to have two vehicles and on the other he has a right to have one vehicle. Under the new circumstances, the licence with the two vehicles will entitle him to 12 and the licence with one will entitle him to six. Therefore, he is entitled to have 18 vehicles.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

He cannot have three licences?

Comment on this

No. He cannot have more than two. He might prefer a different distribution of those, and we would consider that provided he would not be entitled to have less than six on either one of them. He could have nine and nine if he wanted to, or ten and eight.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): How nine and nine?

Comment on this

Because he would have a total of 18.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): That would be breaking the two into two separate ones and giving three?

Comment on this

No. He will not have more than two. It is just that, if a person would like to have the number on his licence changed, rather than have 12 and six, he could have nine and nine. I do not know if anybody will want that. We are giving one year to do it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): If he has two on one and here. Would not the reasonable thing be to allow him to increase each to six? Then he would have 12.

Comment on this

I admit that it is a bit complicated. Under the new circumstances, if the Bill goes through in its present form, he would be entitled to 12 on one of his licences and to six on the other. He is entitled in toto to 18 vehicles but might prefer a different distribution than 12 and six. He still will not have more than the two licences. I do not know if anybody will ask for that but we have left it open for a year so that, if a haulier so wishes, he may do so.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

The practical thing to do, taking the Minister's example, if I have two licences, one with one lorry on it and the other with two lorries on it and I intend to expand my fleet to the size the Minister says is most profitable according to the inquiries he has made, that is, between six and ten, is to bulk the two licences to get 18, divide it in two, sell one and still have a nine vehicle fleet. In case someone wants to do that, the Minister is providing for it.

Comment on this

If he wants.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Suppose a person has five on a licence, how many could he put on? Could he put 30?

Comment on this

Thirty, yes.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

He could have three tens, two fifteens, five sixes?

Comment on this

No. If he has only one licence, he cannot do anything with it; he just must take his five sixes but it does not give him another licence. I am only trying to help the person who may have two licences, three licences or four licences to rearrange the numbers on them. It is like Deputy Barry said. If I might just put it this way— suppose he thought the maximum he was likely to operate was ten, he might like to keep one licence with ten on it. If he were entitled to 18 and he has two licences, he could have ten on one and eight on the other and, as Deputy Barry says, he could sell the one with eight if he so wished. We are leaving that open for only one year.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

There should be some sort of example. Somebody must have made representations about it.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Are there many people with more than one vehicle on a licence?

Comment on this

The figures are: 524 have one licence and one vehicle; 107 have one licence and two vehicles; 25 have one licence and three vehicles; seven have one licence and four vehicles; two have one licence and five vehicles; one has one licence and six vehicles; one has one licence and seven vehicles; one has one licence and 18 vehicles. There are further figures where people have two licences and three licences. If the Deputies wish, I will give them a copy.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): These figures may be more relevant to an earlier section. If everybody availed of the full entitlement under the Bill as proposed, how many vehicles would be licensed? The number would be, apparently, more than my figure of 4,500.

Comment on this

The maximum was put there so that the multiple of six would not operate in the case of a person with a large number of vehicles.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

That would apply to only one man.

Comment on this

I have a list of cases where the number of licences were two and three. The ones I have given to the Deputy are cases where persons have only one licence each irrespective of the number of vehicles, but there are instances of where hauliers have two or three licences.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

There is another section catering for companies.

Comment on this

CIE and the Lough Swilly Railway Company are the only companies referred to.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): From the information that has emerged it is apparent now that the figure of 4,500 is too low.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot go back to that section.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): It now appears that that is a considerable understatement and that the maximum number of vehicles being provided for is about 6,500. I do not think there is much difference between 6,500 vehicles and unlimited licensing. This is a peculiarly drafted section. Subsection (1) states that the Minister may distribute the licences as he has outlined and this provision seems to facilitate a person who has two or three licences to build up the number of vehicles he wants for his own use and if he has two licences to sell the other. I am worried whether we are facilitating the sale of licences and enabling people to make substantial profits by the sale of licences through legislation being passed here. Subsection (2) provides that an application under subsection (1) may be made only once in respect of any licence and subsection (3) provides that the section shall cease to have effect on the expiration of one year.

This seems to be a section inserted for a specific purpose and I should like the Minister to tell us if he has any particular case in mind or if any representations have been made to him in this respect. Measures have gone through the House in the past bearing the names of individuals who had made representations. I honestly do not think we should lay down general principles in a Bill like this providing that a person may multiply the number of lorries on a licence by six in one case and then, by a specific section put into the Bill, be enabled to split up the number of vehicles. The purpose appears to be to enable the licensee who holds more than one licence to arrange the licences so that he can have enough lorries under one licence for his own use and then to sell the rest. He should take his chance the same as everybody else. No small group or less than a small group should be facilitated in this way.

Comment on this

Deputy Fitzpatrick is reading too much into this. I will go back to my original instance. If a man is entitled to have one vehicle under one licence and two vehicles under another, he will be entitled to increase the numbers to 12 under one licence and six under another. There is nothing to prevent him selling either the 12 or the six. They are his property and he is entitled to sell ten of the vehicles if he wants to or to sell one on that basis. If he thought ten would be the number he would be able to operate, I do not see why he should not be entitled to change the allocation to ten vehicles and eight vehicles and then to sell the eight.

I should like to tell Deputy Fitzpatrick that I did not get representations about this that I can remember. My reason for having done it in this way is that I had a look at the figures in relation to people who, for example, had two licences, one with three vehicles and one with one. I decided that this meant one licence could have 18 vehicles and the other six, and that if such a man wanted to leave the licences to two sons there could be imbalance because one would get 18 and the other six. The owner of such vehicles could add the 18 and the six and divide by two, giving two twelves. There was no ulterior motive in drafting the section in this way.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

Honestly, did the Minister think that out?

Comment on this

I did.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

It would never have occurred to me.

Comment on this

Such a situation is a possibility. There are numerous instances where people might wish to do that, where persons might wish to change the number of vehicles under different licences. This has nothing to do with the sale of licences. At the moment if a person has two licences he can sell the two or he can sell one. In other words, he can sell the business.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I have no objection to facilitating a person who wants to dispose of his licences within his family by way of gift or that sort of thing. However, there are 524 cases where there is one licence which caters for only one lorry. There is no problem there. There are 107 cases of one licence covering two lorries. The man who has one licence and two lorries can get 12 lorries and the 25 cases with one lorry and three lorries can get 18 lorries, and so on. When we get into the higher ones I am not sure whether this is a facilitating section to enable a person to juggle about with licences which would give him enough vehicles for himself and enable him to sell one which he would not be entitled to do. If the Minister can assure me that will not be allowed to happen I will be happy, but if there is a possibility that that can happen, I am dead against it.

Comment on this

In the instances the Deputy has given the persons have only one licence each. The instances I have given to the Deputy are all in that category. In that case, where a person has only one licence, he cannot do anything with it. There is a problem in relation to the ones the Deputy has given.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): I accept that no matter how many lorries are on one licence, the licensee can simply multiply those by six, but there are a good number in which there are a number of licences and the Minister did not give us all of them.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

The Minister did not give us any of them.

Comment on this

There are a good number in which there are a number of licences.

Comment on this

Would the Minister consider incorporating under this section that where a person sells the licence out of a country that licence can be replaced? In my county we are grossly under-licensed and the bulk of the licences are owned by single people.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I am afraid that is bringing in completely new matter.

Comment on this

It is relevant because I can see a serious situation arising in County Kerry because we are grossly under-licensed.

Comment on this

The situation at the moment is that I am entitled to issue licences but I cannot accept the proposition put by the Deputy because it would create very serious problems.

Comment on this

What can happen if licences are sold out of County Kerry? We have only 26 licences and I can see ten or 12 of those being sold now. The small men cannot even buy the new lorries that they are licensed to buy because of their cost. What will happen then?

Comment on this

The fact that they are sold out of one county to another is something we cannot control.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

It does not make any difference. If they sell over the border from Kerry into Limerick they can still operate into the county if they have an all-Ireland plate.

Comment on this

Already we are short of lorries and we cannot get them.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Deputy O'Connor's fear is that a big area of the country will be denuded of lorries.

Comment on this

There are a considerable number of licences in Cork, Limerick and Kerry and the work is done by these licensed hauliers in all these areas. To replace a licence sold out of a county would be a very difficult operation.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

The removal of the restriction on the 2½ tons will certainly help the situation.

Comment on this

The lorries were sold out of Kerry before. There are licences in Cork and Limerick but in Tralee at the moment a number of people are appearing in the court for employing lorries that are not licensed because either CIE or the hauliers cannot supply them. A number of people around Fenit port got all-Ireland licences but they sold the bulk of them.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

We cannot discuss this matter on this section.

Comment on this

I am only making a point.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy has made the point and I have given him a lot of latitude.

Comment on this

I appreciate and understand Deputy O'Connor's problem. The situation is that people with licences in Kerry now have a right to have six vehicles each whereas before they could have only one. As Deputy Barry mentioned, the removal of the restriction on the six ton laden weight vehicles in relation to licences will also be helpful.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

I asked the Minister for some figures.

Comment on this

There are a lot of figures. There are, for instance, 39 people who have two licences and two vehicles.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

Is that the lot?

Comment on this

No, there are quite a lot. I will give the Deputy the number afterwards if he wishes.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

Does this cover the leasing of lorries, or has that problem yet been solved? If I were to establish a road haulage business and to lease my lorries, I would not own them and therefore I could not be licensed. Is that correct?

Comment on this

Only licensed hauliers, as it stands here, are entitled to lease.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

This is to cater for them leasing?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

Suppose, I as a licensed haulier, go to a company that rents lorries and rather than buying my own equipment I lease it from them, what happens then.

Comment on this

If a rental firm has a haulier licence they will be entitled to lease.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

But suppose I have a haulier's licence and I have one lorry and I have a crash and I then rent a lorry to replace that while it is being repaired, I am not covered, as far as I know, under existing law. I am out of business.

Comment on this

If a person is a licensed haulier he can lease from a vehicle leasing firm.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

Even if the lorry is not in his own name?

Comment on this

A licensed haulier does not have to have his own vehicle. That does not refer just to this Bill.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

As far as I recall that was not the case, that this was one of the problems it was difficult to deal with in this area.

Comment on this

We discussed this on another occasion. As far as the licensed haulier is concerned he does not have to own his own vehicle.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The object of this is to protect bona fide rent-a-truck people who rent a truck to somebody who is carrying exempted goods or to somebody who has a licensed haulier's licence. Is that the position?

Comment on this

Yes, that is the position. What I am also trying to provide is that where a renting firm has a haulier's licence they can lease.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Where a renting firm has a haulier's licence their truck would be operating legally no matter who it was rented to, is that right?

Comment on this

Yes, but it is provided that the carriage is not carriage for reward.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

That is the crux.

Comment on this

What I had in mind generally was this—and I think Deputy Barry touched on it—that one of the things about which we were concerned was the fact that own account people had the vast bulk of the business.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

They are no problem.

Comment on this

No, but what I was hoping would result from this Bill— and I am sure Deputy Barry had the same thing in mind—was that many of the own account people would move over to the use of licensed hauliers. Therefore, where a renting firm has got the licence I would assume that the vast majority of those who would need them would be own account people and they are dealing with their own business anyway.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

No, that is not the point.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): There is really no change in this.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

The person I am trying to cater for is the haulier, to simplify it, who has an accident and whose lorry is off the road. He might even start off his business by leasing rather than buying the truck. The truck is not in his own name but he is going to use it either indefinitely or for a specific period of time during which his truck is being repaired to carry goods for reward.

Comment on this

He is a licensed haulier himself?

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

He is a licensed haulier himself. He does not own the vehicle but will be carrying goods in that vehicle for reward.

Comment on this

There is no problem because he is a licensed haulier anyway. As I pointed out earlier, he does not have to own his vehicle.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

But the Minister appeared to qualify that later by saying that he could not carry for reward.

Comment on this

No, that is a different situation. This is where the lessor has a merchandise licence. That is the group to which Deputy Fitzpatrick was referring. In the 1956 Act a loophole was closed in the transport legislation under which a person with no merchandise licence could nevertheless earn a living from owning a truck by hiring it to other people. Vehicle leasing or rental as an alternative to purchase was hardly known when the 1956 Act was passed. It was not the intention of the Act to prohibit that but it did. Section 9 of the Bill legalises the use of leased vehicles for the carriage of own goods where the lessor holds a merchandise licence and the leasing agreement contains provisions approved by the Minister.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Section 9 agreed?

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Where either the lessor or the lessee holds it is legal now. Is that right?

Comment on this

For the lessee it is and, for the lessor, it will be provided that the leasing agreement contains provisions approved by the Minister.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): A member of the public could be pardoned for walking into a breach of the law under this section when we find it so difficult to understand. Am I correct in thinking, that prior to this section, the leasing would be legal if the lessee held a road transport licence?

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Now the transaction will be legal if either the lessee or lessor holds a transport licence? Is that substantially correct?

Comment on this

Yes, but I can lay down conditions in relation to the lessor.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Is that substantially correct?

Comment on this

That is basically correct.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Section 9 agreed?

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

But there are hundreds of people still in operation all over the country whom the 1956 Act was meant to exclude, that is, people who own licences and rent them out.

Comment on this

I understand that the 1956 Act had nothing to do with that aspect. The 1956 Act was really concerned about the fact that there were quite a number of people who had trucks but who had no licence and who leased them to own account people——

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): And worked for them.

Comment on this

——or to others. In those circumstances it was not legal. The Act blocked that avenue.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Tried to.

Comment on this

At that time there was very little leasing done. It was not as common as it is now. That is the reason for the change here. The case Deputy Fitzpatrick has made is substantially correct.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The Minister visualises a rent-a-truck firm acquiring quite a number of licences and then renting out the lorries.

Comment on this

For own account.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): For own account only.

Comment on this

In those circumstances, yes, and, of course, hauliers can do it too.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

One does not need it for own account.

Comment on this

What was happening prior to the 1956 Act was that people were leasing their vehicles, very often to their own account people, but they were doing it because of a loophole in the Act. That loophole was closed and stopped them doing it. If we are to try to transfer from own account to licensed haulier, or to professional hauliers, CIE included, it is necessary to make this change. The change permits vehicles to be leased now where previously the licensed haulier could not lease his vehicles; he could use them in the normal way only. Now he is entitled to do it, as will the groups referred to by Deputy Fitzpatrick, provided they get licences.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Suppose firm X is a rent-a-truck firm, holds a number of trucks but does not hold any road transport licence; if at present it hires out those trucks to a person to engage in own account haulage, it is guilty of an offence.

Comment on this

The user of the truck.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): The lessee of the truck is guilty of an offence. The only change being made is that if firm X still has a fleet of trucks licensed under the Road Transport Acts and leases those out to individuals those individuals can use them for own account only and they will not be guilty of a breach of the Road Transport Acts, but they cannot use them to carry goods for hire or reward for other persons.

Comment on this

That is quite a substantial change.

Comment on this
Peter Barry Mr. P. Barry Fine Gael

It is meant to confine them to own account category.

Comment on this

Yes.

Comment on this

I move amendment No. 2:

In page 7, line 35, after "Oireachtas" to add ": provided the estimate for the year in question containing provision for those expenses has first been approved by Dáil Éireann."

This is another amendment I have put down not so much because of its specific relationship to the Bill but because I believe it should be incorporated in all legislation to achieve a greater degree of parliamentary control over the expenditure of moneys by the various Departments of State. To make clear what the amendment provides I shall read the existing section 10 which says:

The expenses incurred by the Minister in the administration of this Act shall, to such extent as may be sanctioned by the Minister for Finance, be paid out of moneys provided by the Oireachtas.

And it stops there. I propose to add that the money may be paid out of funds provided by the Oireachtas, provided the Estimate for the year in question, containing provisions for these expenses, has been approved by the Dáil. In the case of expenses to be incurred under this Bill these would be incorporated in the Estimate for the Department of Transport and Power. The purpose of my amendment is to ensure that the Estimate for the Department of Transport and Power for, shall we say, 1979 is considered before that year commences, in other words, during 1978. There are provisions, under the Central Fund Act of 1965, whereby Estimates for a particular year may be considered before the year commences. To my knowledge these powers under the Central Fund Act have not been exercised by any Government. What happens at present is that Estimates, if they are considered at all—and in many cases they are not —are considered during the year to which they apply.

In many cases by the time the Estimate is debated here half the money has already been spent and so the debate is meaningless in so far as half the money involved is concerned. If the debate were to take place before the year in question then the debate would be a real debate because we would be discussing policies and suggestions could be offered as to ways in which the money should be spent and the Minister could accept these suggestions if he found them worth accepting. In many cases there is no discussion at all on the Estimates. Last year the Government spent over £2,000 million and only 3 per cent of that expenditure was actually discussed on the Estimates during 1977. The remainder was not discussed at all. The Estimates were passed in a lump without any discussion. In that situation the Dáil is not performing the function it should, namely, scrutinising the way in which money is spent by the Government. My amendment would require the Estimate for Tourism and Transport for 1979 to be discussed this year and, if it were discussed, that would greatly improve the debate here and Deputies could offer ideas for the better presentation of the Estimate. I would ask the Minister to consider this amendment very favourably.

Comment on this

However well this amendment may sound in theory it would be utterly impracticable. In a previous amendment the Deputy sought to curtail the power of the Minister to deal with certain matters. In this it is the powers of the Oireachtas the Deputy seems to want to circumscribe. The effect of the amendment would be to suspend the implementation of an Act until such time as the particular Estimate had been passed. The Deputy suggests the discussion might take place the year before. The Deputy has had sufficient experience to know this would not be practicable. Such an approach would place an impossible burden on the conduct of Government business. The standard provision in the Bill leaves the matter in the hands of the Oireachtas. It does not derogate from the power of the Oireachtas. That is the most satisfactory situation, and I could not, therefore, accept this amendment.

Comment on this

The Minister says it would not be practicable to discuss the Estimates.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Deputy will have to confine himself to the amendment. He may not deal with when all the Estimates should be taken.

Comment on this

The Minister says it would not be practicable for the Estimate for Tourism and Transport to be discussed in the year prior to its taking effect. I do not agree, because the Central Fund Act provides that Estimates may legally be considered in advance of the year to which they relate. Secondly, all West European Parliaments consider the Estimates in the previous year because they realise, as we apparently do not, that there is no point in talking about money already spent and pretending control over it. The Minister may argue that that would clog up the House. It would not clog if the Estimates were introduced in time and, if there was any difficulty, there is nothing to stop the setting up of Select Committees to consider the Estimates and report back to the House and nothing to stop the House then having a short plenary discussion. In that way the Estimates would go through fairly quickly. In the French Parliament they have to get the Estimates through in three months. There is intensive work by select committees and there is a proper discussion about the way in which the money will be spent. There is no proper procedure here. I appreciate that it would be difficult for the Minister to accept this amendment because other Departments are ininvolved.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

I would remind the Deputy that the Estimate for Tourism and Transport is relevant but not the Estimates for other Departments.

Comment on this

The Estimate for Tourism and Transport is strictly relevant, and I would argue that what I suggest would be practicable if there were a will, and there should be a will if we are serious about Parliamentary control of Government expenditure.

Comment on this

The Deputy knows perfectly well this is not a practical proposition. If he were anxious to put forward an amendment like this one would have expected him to concern himself with the Central Fund (Permanent Provisions) Act, 1965, to which he referred. A basic change like this could not be made in relation to a particular Bill emanating from a particular Department. There are other ways in which the Deputy could deal with this. There is nothing practicable in dealing with the matter in this way.

Comment on this

I thank the Minister for his attitude. It is not unhelpful. He is not unsympathetic. The Central Fund Act already has the provision in it but the Government will not implement that provision. That is the problem.

The Minister will also realise that there are difficulties imposed on the Opposition in introducing legislation. They are not entitled to introduce certain forms of Bills. I intend, without apology, to make these points clearly on every Bill that comes before the House. This is the first occasion I have had an opportunity of doing this, but if the Minister comes here again I am afraid he will have to listen to the same argument until such time as the Government change their practice. It is for that reason that I intend to press this amendment.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When is it proposed to take Report Stage?

Comment on this

Would the Opposition agree to take it now?

Comment on this

I would prefer if it was put back to Wednesday next for the reason that the Minister has given an undertaking, which I welcome, to consider an amendment.

Comment on this

I said I was willing to consider it either on Report Stage or in the Seanad.

Comment on this

We would not have an opportunity of discussing it if it was introduced in the Seanad.

Comment on this

If the Deputy presses the matter I agree to Report Stage being taken next Wednesday.

Comment on this
Thomas J. Fitzpatrick Mr. T. J. Fitzpatrick Fine Gael

(Cavan-Monaghan): Subject to discussion between the Whips.

Comment on this