Sample surveys in question No. 4
O’Keeffe asked how many sample surveys had been conducted, referring to question No. 4. Amid disagreement over the conduct of Question Time and whether answers could be heard, Lalor offered to repeat the answer to that question.
In relation to the reply to question No. 4, which was whispered, could I ask the Minister of State how many sample surveys were conducted at the present Administration?
Comment on this
We are on question No. 6. It is only with the Minister's concurrence that I will allow the Deputy's supplementary to be answered. If the Minister wishes he may answer.
Comment on this
The coalition were never once guilty of this type of smart alec performance. Never once in four-and-a-half years did a Minister refuse to repeat an answer.
Comment on this
Shouting "84 seats" will not get us anywhere. I am asking about question No. 4. The order of the House requires that when questions are called the answers are given in an orderly manner and not rushed through so that nobody can hear them and that an opportunity is given for a supplementary question, which in this case was not given. I accept that the fault is by no means confined to one side of the House. We must have an orderly method of answering questions.
Comment on this
I thoroughly agree with what the Deputy said but there are circumstances prevailing over which the Chair does not have any control. The Chair cannot control Deputies, like Deputy Fitzpatrick today, who persist in speaking against the ruling of the Chair. When I called questions Deputies did not listen; they kept shouting. Seven questions in 30 minutes is not the kind of progress we expect to make at Question Time. The Chair cannot be blamed for the disorder in the House if Deputies refuse to——
Comment on this
In the last Dáil, the present Minister for Labour trampled on the Chair, day in and day out, and never once did a Minister refuse to repeat the answer to a question. This is a disgusting performance.