We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil
‹ Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Archaeological Excavations.

St Mel excavation and reporting

Summary

Bruton questioned the storage, public access and conservation of finds from the 1967 excavation, and pressed the Minister on the missing statutory report. The finds are at UCD and reportedly available for inspection, though the Minister could not say where or when; he proposed no action over the reporting failure.

asked the Minister for Finance in respect of the archaeological excavation carried out at the Church of Saint Mel in Longford in 1967: (a) where the objects found in the excavation have been lodged; (b) the amount of State grant paid towards the excavation; (c) if he has received any report on it; (d) if a report has been lodged in accordance with section 23 of the National Monuments Act, 1930; (e) if the objects found may be inspected by the general public; (f) if they have been adequately conserved; and (g) if a report on the excavation has been published.

Comment on this

The few portable objects found in the excavation at the site of the Church of St. Mel at Ardagh, County Longford are retained in University College, Dublin, where they can be inspected by the general public. They did not need conservation.

A grant of £3,600 was made towards this project by the Commissioners of Public Works. A report has not been lodged in accordance with section 23 of the National Monuments Act, 1930. The excavator furnished the commissioners with a report but no report has been published on the excavation.

Comment on this

What action does the Minister propose taking in view of the fact that the report was not lodged in accordance with section 23 of the National Monuments Act, 1930? Furthermore, can the Minister say how the public may gain access to these objects in UCD, whether they are on continuous public display, or are in a drawer somewhere?

Comment on this

They are on display in UCD.

Comment on this

Where?

Comment on this

I do not know.

Comment on this

Is there a place for exhibitions in UCD?

Comment on this

They are in UCD at present.

Comment on this

On display?

Comment on this

Where they can be inspected by the general public.

Comment on this

How may they be inspected? The Minister is responsible for the information——

Comment on this

I have given the Deputy the information; I presume they may be inspected with one's eyes.

Comment on this

Are they available in a public place, for public display, or are they a private collection——

Comment on this

They are available for public inspection in UCD.

Comment on this

How may they be seen?

Comment on this

With one's eyes.

Comment on this

With or without notice; does one have to give notice if one wishes to see these objects?

Comment on this

I have given the reply, that they are available for public inspection at UCD.

Comment on this

With or without notice?

Comment on this

If the Deputy wants information regarding times and places then he should put down a question to that effect, but they are available for public inspection there at present.

Comment on this

What action does the Minister propose taking in view of the fact that the provisions of section 23 of the 1930 Act have not been complied with?

Comment on this

The excavator is not obliged to publish a report of an excavation.

Comment on this

That is not what the section is really about. Section 23 is about reporting within six months of the finding of objects and the Minister has stated already that the provisions of that section were not complied with. I am asking what action he proposes to take in the matter.

Comment on this

It is not easy to take any action.

Comment on this

Why not?

Comment on this

Because it is for the Garda Síochána and the National Museum, that they must report under section 23.

Comment on this

Has the matter been reported to the authorities who are competent to take action?

Comment on this

But it is understood that the archaeologists in question read a paper on the subject at the Royal Irish Academy.

Comment on this

I am asking about the reporting within six months of the finding of objects, not the publication of a scientific paper. I am asking the Minister what action he proposes taking about the failure to report the objects being found.

Comment on this

None at present.

21.

Comment on this