Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Tourism Industry.
- Petrol voucher scheme operation 6 speeches
The Minister described the voucher scheme, guaranteed petrol at designated stations and operating hours. Enright sought monitoring of complaints and voucher-exchange problems.
Tom Enright, Padraig Faulkner, Joseph Brennan
- BBC programme about Irish tourism 4 speeches
Enright criticised a BBC programme about British tourists leaving Ireland. The Minister agreed it was unsatisfactory and said the BBC’s follow-up programme only partly corrected it.
Tom Enright, Joseph Brennan, Padraig Faulkner
- British Rail tourism advice 4 speeches
Barry asked about a report that British Rail representatives discouraged prospective visitors from travelling to Ireland. The Minister had not seen it and said he would look into it.
Peter Barry, Padraig Faulkner
- Vouchers for Northern Ireland tourists 2 speeches
O’Keeffe asked whether Northern Ireland tourists could obtain petrol vouchers; the Minister said he would answer a later question on the matter.
Jim O'Keeffe, Padraig Faulkner
- Petrol stations refusing vouchers 7 speeches
Begley said petrol companies were not honouring vouchers and offered to provide evidence. The Minister maintained that Bord Fáilte’s information showed the scheme was working satisfactorily, prompting a heated exchange.
Michael Begley, Padraig Faulkner, Deputies
- Connacht voucher centres 3 speeches
O’Toole sought the names and number of Connacht centres issuing vouchers, citing difficulties and dissatisfaction in the west. The Minister directed tourists to Bord Fáilte offices for information.
Patrick O'Toole, Padraig Faulkner
- Tourism administration arrangements 2 speeches
Quinn sought to raise the Minister’s administrative arrangements for facilitating the tourism industry on the Adjournment; the Chair said he would communicate with him.
Ruairí Quinn, Joseph Brennan
- Tourism earnings estimates and outlook 21 speeches
Enright asked about 1979 tourism revenue targets and whether they were being revised. The Minister gave the targets and said Bord Fáilte was monitoring the effects of the petrol shortage and communications difficulties; he described efforts to attract visitors and noted that early visitor numbers exceeded the previous year, while acknowledging an adverse downturn. Debate over the projected losses, publicity spending and further promotion ended in a clash between Enright and the Chair.
Tom Enright, Padraig Faulkner, Joseph Brennan
asked the Minister for Tourism and Transport details of any arrangements made to provide tourists with petrol; if he is satisfied that such schemes are effective and being operated satisfactorily; and if he will make a statement on the matter.
Comment on this
A petrol voucher scheme was introduced for motoring tourists from overseas on 1 June 1979. The vouchers guarantee a supply of petrol at designated filling stations throughout the country.
The scheme originally provided for a supply of 20 gallons—16 gallons in the case of cars having tank capacity of six gallons or less. The scheme has now been improved and tourists will receive vouchers for 20 gallons of petrol, or 16 gallons in the case of smaller cars, valid for nine days and those remaining beyond that period may reapply for one further lot of vouchers guaranteeing 20 or 16 gallons, as appropriate.
The scheme is being closely monitored by Bord Fáilte who operate it and my information is that it has been working satisfactorily.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister heard the comment of the Minister for Industry, Commerce and Energy on Radio Eireann last Sunday, and I should like him to give us an assurance that we will not now relax and imagine that everything is fine.
Comment on this
I am asking the Minister, when the Bord Fáilte monitoring has been carried out, to tell us the complaints he has received and the difficulties people are experiencing in exchanging vouchers.
Comment on this
Overseas tourists are guaranteed petrol at approximately 190 filling stations throughout the country. From 20 June these stations will remain open from 9 a.m. to 6 p.m. daily, from 9 a.m. to 12 noon on Saturday and a certain number will open on Sundays. Details will be available from tourist information offices throughout the country.
Comment on this
I trust the Minister will continue to monitor the situation. In regard to petrol, will he or some of his advisers, if he has seen the programme on the BBC dealing with British tourists leaving Ireland, communicate with the British Broadcasting Corporation——
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied with that programme? Most people in the tourism business were far from satisfied.
Comment on this
I agree it was a very unsatisfactory programme. We got in touch with the BBC and they put on a further programme which to some degree rectified the position, but it was still unsatisfactory.
Comment on this
Has the Minister seen a report in this morning's Cork Examiner to the effect that the B+I representatives on the Continent told prospective tourists coming to Ireland that the situation here was very bad and that they should not come? Does the Minister agree that for a company who depend for some of their revenue on people going from and coming to Ireland, this was unfriendly——
Comment on this
Can the Minister say whether petrol vouchers are available to tourists from Northern Ireland?
Comment on this
Can the Minister tell us why petrol companies are not honouring the vouchers when they are presented?
Comment on this
If I can produce evidence for the Minister that such is not the case, will he investigate it?
Comment on this
Yes, but my information is that it is working satisfactorily and it is a very bad business to attempt to suggest in this House that it is not when all the information I have from Bord Fáilte is that it is working satisfactorily. This is sabotaging the efforts of Bord Fáilte to improve the tourist situation.
Comment on this
I can tell the Minister that he is being led up the garden path by Bord Fáilte. He does not know what is happening.
Comment on this
This is disgusting—it is a shame and a disgrace. Bord Fáilte are doing everything possible to counteract the various problems facing the country and it is a scandal that this kind of thing should be indulged in by the Deputy.
Comment on this
There are difficulties in regard to the availability of vouchers. Can the Minister tell me the number and the names of the centres in Connacht where tourists taking out cars can get vouchers?
Comment on this
Although I do not want to continue on the lines which the Minister suggested are disruptive—I want to be constructive—there are certain difficulties in the west and there is grave dissatisfaction.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle I wish to raise on the Adjournment the administrative arrangements made by the Minister to facilitate the tourism industry.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Tourism and Transport the total income estimated for tourism earnings for 1979 indicating (a) the estimated income from the home holiday based section of this industry and (b) the income from Britain; if these estimates are now being revised and if so, the nature and figures of any such revision.
10.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Tourism and Transport the details of any estimates prepared in January 1979 in respect of total tourism earnings for 1979; if these estimates are now being revised; and if so, the extent and nature of such revision.
Comment on this
With the permission of the Ceann Comhairle I propose to take questions Nos. 9 and 10 together.
The preparation and updating of targets for tourism revenue is a matter for Bord Fáilte and the projections for 1979 were set out in the board's Tourism Plan, 1979-83 prepared by them for the trade. The target shown for total tourism for 1979 was £432.9 million, including home holidays and carrier receipts. The revenue targets from home holidaymakers and British tourists were £115.6 million and £80.6 million respectively. The figures were prepared in 1978 terms.
These targets are subject to review by Bord Fáilte and some revision will be inevitable. The board are monitoring developments but are not in a position at this stage to state the extent and nature of the revision necessary.
Comment on this
Will the Minister accept that people involved in the tourism industry, in all its aspects, have been seriously affected by the petrol shortage and the postal dispute? No later than yesterday, the chairman of the Irish Hotels Federation forecast that there will be a loss of £50 million this year——
Comment on this
Does the Minister accept what the chairman of the Hotels Federation has said, that there will be a loss of £50 million? Will he agree there is a serious situation, and will he tell us of the plans he has to try to remedy the position so that the industry can carry on?
Comment on this
I have pointed out that Bord Fáilte are monitoring developments but they are not in a position at this stage to state the extent of the problem. I have told the Deputy that Bord Fáilte are doing everything possible to improve the situation, particularly in relation to petrol vouchers and advertising. Now that the postal strike is over, further efforts will be made to attract visitors.
Comment on this
I put it to the Minister that from the reports seen in the leading national newspapers it would appear that the only amount spent by Bord Fáilte on publicity has been about £130,000.
Comment on this
Bord Fáilte have spent only £130,000 and is the Minister satisfied this amount is sufficient? Does he intend to communicate with our embassies abroad and with CTT, the IDA and our other agencies to try to improve the situation, where a loss of probably 20 per cent——
Comment on this
The Deputy can be assured that every possible effort is being made by me, by Bord Fáilte and by everybody connected with the industry to improve the situation. As I have already stated, the available statistics show that the numbers of visitors and of cars entering the country in the first five months of the year, that is up to the end of May, was higher than the corresponding situation this time last year. On the other hand, I am not trying to mislead the House. There is a down-turn caused by adverse publicity relating to the communications difficulties as has been mentioned here already, and in connection with petrol supplies. These have affected advance bookings. We cannot expect that the increase recorded in the early part of the year will be maintained. Nevertheless, we are doing our utmost in the circumstances to ensure that the information in relation to the petrol situation, which has improved very much, and in relation to the Post Office situation, will be relayed to other countries to ensure that people who would still wish to come here and who might be on two minds as to whether to come or not will come. The petrol situation has improved very considerably, as everybody can see—you do not see any queues at present—and the postal strike is over. In all these circumstances the opportunity is there to encourage more people to come to this country and I have no doubt that we will be successful in all the efforts we are making.
Comment on this
Is the figure mentioned satisfactory? Do the Minister's Department intend to allocate to Bord Fáilte further sums for a publicity campaign to show the good side of the situation now?
Comment on this
The Deputy will not make any such statements regarding the Chair. He rises in his place, ignores the Chair and directs statements across——
Comment on this
When I went to ask my first supplementary question you, Sir, interrupted me. When I asked my second question you stopped me.