Mortgage rates and targeted subsidies
The Minister acknowledged mortgage holders’ hardship but had no plans for a subsidy, agreeing to represent the case to the Finance Minister. He said building societies had held rates steady since 1978 and disputed claims that deposits were falling or that EMS membership had raised rates.
asked the Minister for the Environment if he is aware of the serious hardship being caused to many mortgage holders by the recent major increases in mortgage rates and if it is intended to introduce a selective subsidy for particular groups of mortgage holders who can least afford these increases.
Comment on this
I assume the Deputy is referring to the mortgage rate being charged by building societies.
I am very much aware of the difficulties being caused for many mortgage holders by the present high mortgage rate and I regret that influences beyond our control have brought about the situation where a high mortgage interest rate must be charged. I must in fairness point out that building societies have held their investment rate—which rate directly affects the mortgage rate—at the same level since 1 December 1978, although the rates payable by some other bodies competing with the societies for investment funds, in particular the associated banks, have increased appreciably since then.
As regards subsidising particular groups of mortgage holders, while I have every sympathy with borrowers affected by the present high interest rates, I feel that all available housing moneys should be directed towards assisting those still in need of housing. While there are still numbers of our people in need of proper housing accommodation it would be inappropriate to apply public moneys to assist those already adequately housed.
Comment on this
Does the Minister not agree that there is already a subsidy for people who are housed by way of income tax relief? What is being sought is the Minister's consideration of a scheme that would give preference of some kind to first time mortgage holders or to people of a certain income who have to pay the same interest rates as those with substantially higher incomes.
Comment on this
There may be a case for a subsidy. However, at the moment I have no plans for subsidising mortgage holders. As the Deputy is aware, this matter would not be solely my responsibility.
Comment on this
Would the Minister consider making representations to the Minister for Finance in time for next year's budget? I can assure the Minister that there is considerable hardship for both SDA loan mortgage holders and building society mortgage holders.
Comment on this
Is it intended to introduce interest rate subsidies in the coming year because of the extremely high interest rates which have apparently been caused by the prevailing high interest rates in England? The previous Government introduced an interest rate subsidy. Would the Minister explain to the House why we were given to understand upon entry into the EMS that high interest rates would not prevail?
Comment on this
The building societies have not increased their rates since December 1978. Despite increases in the interest rates of the associated banks and other lending agencies, the building societies have held to their December 1978 rates. This was an achievement on the part of the building societies because there was expectation, even by Members of this House, that their rates would increase by 2 per cent. Their rates did not substantially increase as a result of our entry into the EMS. With regard to the 1 per cent subsidy introduced by the previous Government, the reason why it was made available was to boost deposits. Without deposits the building societies would be unable to make money available for the purchase and building of houses. The main purpose of that subsidy was to boost deposits against other lending agencies.
Comment on this
(Cavan-Monaghan): Can the Minister assure us that mortgage rates will not be increased?
Comment on this
Will the Minister introduce a subsidy in the event of an increase in building society interest rates?
Comment on this
Does the Minister not agree that the interest rates prevailing in England are the highest ever and may force the building societies to increase their rate? If the interest rates are increased above their present level will the Minister introduce a subsidy?
Comment on this
I assure the Deputy that the inflow of money on deposit to the societies has been high throughout the year and has nothing to do with our entry into the EMS.
Comment on this
I can assure the Deputy that it has not decreased. I see the returns of all the offices.