Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - Waste Dumping.
- Waste dumping south of Fastnet 9 speeches
The Minister said no waste is dumped in territorial waters south of Fastnet; international dumping sites lie 240–300 nautical miles away and are governed by conventions. Asked about industrial and nuclear waste and risks from corroding containers, he emphasized preventing pollution, while acknowledging current practices are difficult to change.
Jim O'Keeffe, Patrick Power, James White
- Monitoring international waste dumping 6 speeches
Quinn asked who monitors dumping under the Oslo and London Conventions and whether results reach Irish authorities. The Minister said countries monitor their own waste, but he did not know how findings were shared and undertook to investigate; he maintained that Ireland monitors its territorial waters.
Ruairí Quinn, Patrick Power
- Adequacy of dumping surveillance 2 speeches
Asked whether current monitoring was adequate, the Minister said he was not making that claim and called for a wider rethink as awareness of the permanence of marine dumping grows.
Austin Deasy, Patrick Power
- Fish stocks near dumping sites 2 speeches
The Minister said dumping occurs at depths of 2,000–4,000 metres, beyond the reach of fishing activity.
Austin Deasy, Patrick Power
- Surveillance of sea dumping 4 speeches
The Minister was reasonably satisfied with current surveillance but promised to improve it if needed and monitor developments at Community level. White noted that surveillance ends once containers are dumped at sea.
Seán Treacy, Patrick Power, James White, Joseph Brennan
asked the Minister for Fisheries and Forestry whether the dumping of waste is occurring in territorial or international waters south of the Fastnet, if so, if he will give details of same and the steps being taken to monitor and control such activity.
Comment on this
No dumping occurs in territorial waters south of the Fastnet. The nearest sites used for disposal of wastes in international waters are 240-300 nautical miles south of the Fastnet. Most of the wastes dumped are containerised liquids whose dilution and dispersion follows from the gradual erosion of the drums on the sea bed.
The disposal of wastes in international waters around Ireland is regulated and controlled by international conventions, namely, the Convention for the Prevention of Marine Pollution by Dumping from Ships and Aircraft (Oslo Convention) and the Convention on the Prevention of Marine Pollution by Dumping of Wastes and Other Matter (London Convention).
Comment on this
The Minister told the House that dumping takes place 240 miles from the Irish coast and I should like to know if that includes industrial and nuclear waste. Is the Minister satisfied that in future years there will be no danger of pollution as a result of some of those canisters opening? I am sure the Minister is aware that salt eats into almost everything. Has this matter been investigated by the IIRS?
Comment on this
In future our attitude will be to prevent pollution rather than to adopt a stand whereby we would allow a certain degree of pollution. My attitude is that we should endeavour to prevent it.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that industrial or nuclear waste will not be dumped in international waters in future?
Comment on this
I am not saying that, but we will need to monitor everything carefully to keep tabs on the part of the sea where any waste is dumped. We should ensure, as far as we can, that dumping is prevented rather than allowed in any way.
Comment on this
What Irish personnel are involved in monitoring the Oslo and London Conventions? If Irish personnel are not involved in such monitoring will the Minister indicate how the results of that process are directly conveyed to the Irish authorities?
Comment on this
In any case where waste originates here in any shape or form it is monitored here. I am sure each country has responsibility for monitoring its own waste. I am not aware if there is a pooling of the results of this monitoring but after I have that matter examined I will bring the details to the attention of the Deputy.
Comment on this
Is the Minister saying that under those conventions waste may have been dumped in the ocean which is deteriorating in its canister form but this country has not any way of monitoring that directly?
Comment on this
Unfortunately, waste does not respect the notional limit around the coast. Is the Minister saying that we cannot monitor that at present?
Comment on this
We have control over and monitor any waste dumped in our territorial waters. There are sites in international waters 240 to 300 nautical miles south of the Fastnet and that is the nearest dumping ground to us. There is a responsibility on the nation originating the waste to have that monitored. I am not aware where that information is fed into the Community machine but I will find out for the Deputy.
Comment on this
Do I take it that the Minister is not satisfied with the level of monitoring which has taken place so far?
Comment on this
I am not saying that but there is a greater awareness in all countries that something dumped into the sea is irretrievable. We will have to have a rethink about this.
Comment on this
To what extent are fish stocks which frequent the area where dumping takes place monitored?
Comment on this
The dumping takes place in 2,000 to 4,000 metres of water out of reach of any fishing efforts.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that he has the necessary surveillance and expertise to cope with the problem of dumping in the sea?
Comment on this
I am reasonably satisfied with the present surveillance. But if on investigation I find that it is not satisfactory I will improve it as far as our country is concerned. I will also keep tabs on what is happening at Community level.
Comment on this
I am sure the Minister is aware that surveillance only takes place before the canisters go into the sea and that there is no way it can take place once they are dumped. That is the problem.