School transport information disclosed to another Deputy
Donnellan alleged that information about a successful school-transport application had reached another Deputy before he was notified, calling it a breach of privilege and raising concerns about privacy and disclosure. Tunney asked for the case details, promised to examine them and give an honest reply, and denied that such disclosure was the practice; the allegation remained unresolved.
It is a matter of a breach of privilege. It is a matter which concerns every Deputy in this House. I personally want to make a charge against whoever was responsible——
Comment on this
——for information regarding a successful application for school transport being relayed to an individual in the Tuam area although that individual never contacted the Fianna Fáil Minister of State who relayed the information to him. Where else could he have got it but from the Department?
Comment on this
If I could make it in confidence I would make it, but there is no confidence involved.
Comment on this
If the Deputy will be so courteous as to give me the particulars I can assure him in this House that I will have them examined. He can then put down a question later on and I will give him all the details.
Comment on this
If I give the Minister the information regarding the charge I have made, can I have an assurance from him that he will not go and communicate with other people, as has been done in the past?
Comment on this
If the Deputy will give me the information, I assure him I will give him an honest reply. If the Deputy will consult other members of his party he will find that they accept that in respect of the area for which I am responsible the charge he has made has not got any base at all.
Comment on this
Accepting what the Minister has said, that the practice has been long standing, that it existed before he came into the House, does he not think that the continuation of such a practice is an invasion of the privacy of a Deputy in relation to making representations to a Department—that he is entitled to that information and that that information should not be given to other Deputies in the constituency just because an Opposition Deputy asked for it in the first instance?
Comment on this
Deputy Tunney is one of the fairest Deputies in the House, but it happens that when Deputies contact a Department——