Motor vehicle spare parts price margins
The National Prices Commission found a prima facie case that margins on some spare parts are excessive and is preparing a supplementary report. O’Toole challenged the delay and sought action; Meaney said he would examine the report before deciding what to do.
asked the Minister for Industry, Commerce and Tourism if he is aware of the excessive profit mark-up on motor vehicle spare parts as compared with profit margins in Northern Ireland; and the steps he proposes to take to redress this situation.
Comment on this
I am aware that the National Prices Commission in their August-September 1980 monthly report published information on the price of spare parts for passenger motor vehicles which included, inter alia, a comparison with Northern Ireland prices, and that the commission concluded that there is a prima facie case that the margins being taken here on some spare parts are excessive. The commission have, however, indicated that they considered it necessary to pursue the price comparisons further, and I expect to receive a supplementary report from them in the near future. The commission's report has also been referred to the Examiner of Restrictive Practices to enable him to review the trade practices referred to therein.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that long before the commission reported, over three years ago, there was an undertaking given by the Minister's party to investigate this very point, to ensure that this discrepancy did not continue to arise? Would the Minister agree that it has taken a report from the National Prices Commission to refresh his memory, which report he is now awaiting? Is the Minister prepared to admit that in the past three years nothing has been done to redress this imbalance despite the fact that a promise was solemnly given in 1977?
Comment on this
I do not believe what the Deputy has said. As I have said, a supplementary report is due in the very near future. That explains the position.
Comment on this
When we get the report we will act thereon. We shall have to look at the report first.
Comment on this
When one receives a report one must first examine it. One does not announce one's actions beforehand.
Comment on this
I have explained in my reply that there is a prima facie case that the margins being taken on some spare parts are excessive and that is why the report——
Comment on this
I referred the Deputy back, in the course of my reply, to the National Prices Commission August-September 1980 monthly report.
Comment on this
I appreciate that, but I understand that the Minister is now awaiting a further investigation.