Ceisteanna—Questions. Oral Answers. - National Debt.
- National debt per employed person 15 speeches
The debt was estimated at £6,800 per employed person at end-1980. Bruton and Kelly pressed for international comparisons and warned of the burden, while the Minister said the figures were not in his brief and asked for a specific question.
John Bruton, Seán Calleary, John M. Kelly, Padraig Faulkner
- National debt as a share of GNP 17 speeches
The Minister said the 1981 debt-to-GNP estimate could not yet be calculated and gave the 1976 figure as 80 per cent. Deputies challenged him with claims about the much higher 1980 debt, rapid borrowing and loss of creditor status; he rejected their conclusions and defended the country’s creditworthiness.
John Bruton, Seán Calleary, Gerald L'Estrange, Padraig Faulkner
The national debt per employed person is provisionally estimated at £6,800 as at end-1980.
Comment on this
Is the Minister satisfied that this is not an intolerable burden to be paid by the taxpayers of the future? Will he let me know how this compares with the national debt in other countries? Will he not agree that it is probably the highest in Europe?
Comment on this
I have no information on how it compares with the national debt per employed person in other countries. If the Deputy puts down a question on the matter I will answer it.
Comment on this
The Minister can only give information that is in his brief. If the Deputy wishes to know the position he should put down a specific question.
Comment on this
The common form of any Minister's advisers is that where a comparison with the other EEC countries might yield any fragment of consolation to a Minister it will be put down in his brief. If the comparative EEC figures are not in the Minister's brief it is because they would be damning from his point of view.
Comment on this
I can only tell the Deputy what is in my brief. That information is not in it. I have suggested to the Deputy that he should put down a specific question.
Comment on this
The Minister was asked questions about unemployment half an hour ago and, quite gratuitously, he brought in EEC figures. He has done that today and on every other occasion when he thought they lent colour to what he was saying.
Comment on this
We should be honoured to owe so much money for the privilege of having the Taoiseach, Deputy Haughey, and his crew in power. It is too good for us.
Comment on this
asked the Minister for Finance the estimated 1981 national debt as a percentage of the value of the amount of GNP this country produces in a year; and the comparable percentage for 1976.
Comment on this
I presume the Deputy is referring to the size of the national debt at end-1981. It is not possible to provide that estimate as it depends not only on amounts borrowed during the year but also on such factors as movements in exchange rates and the extent to which stocks are issued below their nominal value, which is the amount repayable on maturity and thus the figure used in computing the national debt. National debt as a percentage of GNP in 1976 was 80 per cent.
Comment on this
Is it not the case that at the end of 1980 the national debt, including that owed by State companies, amounted to 116 per cent of GNP? That is much worse than the situation obtaining in 1976 and it is probably worse than that of any other European country with the possible exception of Italy.
Comment on this
Will the Minister not agree that the national debt increased from £3,000 million in 1977 to £7,600 million at the end of 1980? In other words, we have borrowed more in the past three years than in the previous 50 years and if we continue borrowing in this way we will not be a creditor nation internationally.
Comment on this
I am sure the Deputy might like that to happen. The position is that we are a most creditable nation and the fact that we can borrow money is an indication of our creditworthiness in Europe and throughout the world.
Comment on this
Is the Minister aware that Deputy Haughey, the Taoiseach, said on 25 May 1976, "We are no longer a creditor nation"——
Comment on this
He said on that date "We are no longer a creditor nation internationally". He said that in 1976 when he was trying to harm this country.
Comment on this
The Taoiseach made that statement at a time when the national debt was less than half of what it is today.
Comment on this
It is in the Official Report of 25 May 1976 and the Minister can read it for himself.