We use Google Analytics to see which pages are read and how the site is used, so we know what to improve. This only runs if you accept. See our privacy notice for details.

Dáil

Agricultural Prices: Motion.

Contributions 153–346 of 346. This sitting's record is too long for one page, so it is split into 2 parts.

That is because we produced a six point programme and Fianna Fáil knew that we intended to do that. I have the programme——

Comment on this

——for the abolition of all rates for all farmers. It was only because Fianna Fáil were afraid of losing the farmers' vote that they agreed to go ahead with derating.

Comment on this

The Deputy only picked this point out of the paper because it was being discussed.

Comment on this

We will honour anything we put on paper, unlike Fianna Fáil with their manifesto. Before the Minister came in tonight I read out point after point; Fianna Fáil broke every primise that they made to the Irish electorate in that manifesto.

Comment on this

Today the Minister spoke about mountain lamb extension schemes and so on. He did not tell us anything about the ewe scheme. Those of us who were down in Donegal heard the Fianna Fáil Ministers on every platform in Donegal promising the small farmers that if they voted for Fianna Fáil they would get £7 per head for every ewe they kept. The little man on the mountain was saying, "Oh my God, I have 50 little ewes at home; that is £350 if I vote Fianna Fáil. Why would I not vote for Fianna Fáil? " Another little man might have 100 ewes and that meant £700. What has happened to that? We were not told anything about it here today. The Minister knew at that time, but he did not tell the farmers what was in the small print, that they would be getting only 70p to 90p. They misled the farmers then as they have misled them since.

Comment on this

That is not correct.

Comment on this

It is correct. The Deputy knows it is correct. The Minister has also claimed credit for suspending the disease eradication levy giving a direct saving to farmers of almost £10 million in 1981. That was another promise made in our six point programme. Who put the 10 per cent levy on the farmers?

Comment on this

Deputy Mark Clinton.

Comment on this

The present Government put it on at the dictates of the unions, just as they imposed the resource tax.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would Deputy L'Estrange make his own speech and not respond to any offerings from the other side?

Comment on this

It is very difficult not to respond.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Deputies in the House remain silent? If they would remain silent for a few minutes we would get the whole job over.

Comment on this

Despite the fact that the Government promised in 1977 to remove all the taxes we had imposed, they imposed three or four new taxes. They imposed the 2 per cent levy which was an unfair and unjust tax because it did not take into consideration the ability of people to pay. They imposed a resource tax which is an unfair and unjust tax because, again, it did not take into consideration the ability of people to pay. They are now looking for credit for removing taxes that they imposed on the farmers a few years ago and which helped to ruin the farmers of this country. In the manifesto the Government proposed to give a 3 per cent subsidy on interest rates for farmers.

Comment on this

Is the Deputy sure that Gemma did not write that speech?

Comment on this

The Minister stated here today that since 1975 well over £1,000 million has been invested in land improvement, buildings, machinery and so on and that we have not yet seen an adequate return on that investment. Unfortunately we have not. When Deputy Clinton was Minister for Agriculture he encouraged the farmers to invest. They invested at that time because they had confidence in the Government and they continued to invest. Many of those people who borrowed money when it was at 9 or 10 per cent are being crucified in the last few years by the action of the present Government who have increased interest rates to 19, 20 and 21 per cent.

Comment on this

And Fine Gael will be able to change all that.

Comment on this

The unfortunate thing about it is that it was the good, progressive farmers who borrowed and are in trouble today, the farmers who went to the agricultural schools, who attended the 100 hours agricultural courses. Bank managers and agricultural instructors went to the CEO's and asked them for a list of those people and they went and offered them money, and many of those people who borrowed at 8 per cent are up to their eyes in debt. Some of them have to sell part of their farms. Others have applied to the Land Commission for permission to sell part of their land and have been refused permission. Others have had to sell their farms altogether. What have the Government done for them? There is not a single thing in this package for those unfortunate people in whom they were supposed to be interested when they were in Opposition. Those people are the salt of the earth. Deputy Keegan knows some of them in my county. At the present time they cannot sleep and some of them and their wives are attending mental hospitals because their nerves are gone. The farmer has always been a proud man. He has always tried to pay his way and repay his debts. Unfortunately, he has not been able to do this over the last few years because farmers have been neglected.

The Minister stated this evening, and I quote:

In the development of our economy in recent years, the farming sector has been an area of particular concern to the Government. The problems which farmers have had to face have been fully recognised by the Government and we have spared no efforts to find adequate solutions.

What solutions did we get until the Minister came back from Brussels with this package? We got nothing worth talking about. I remember many Fianna Fáil speakers, and one in particular, stating that when we entered the EEC our standards of living would be aligned with the standards of the other states. Unfortunately, the gap between the standards of living of our farmers and those of people in the other countries of Western Europe is getting larger and larger every day. If you read the statistics which were published recently, the gap has widened to such an extent that people living in Hamburg and Bonn are six times better off than the average person living in the west of Ireland.

Comment on this

There are two million people unemployed in Germany.

Comment on this

They are six times better off than our people in the west of Ireland.

Comment on this

The Deputy would want to go back again to Germany and have another look.

Comment on this

We were told that the gap would be narrowed. Instead of that it is widening because of the Government's complete neglect of our agricultural community over the last few years.

Comment on this

Was it the Deputy's new Vice-President who told him that?

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Now, now, we have heard enough about his Vice-President. Would the Minister please stay quiet?

Comment on this

I wonder if Fianna Fáil realise the extent of the poverty among farmers and what they have had to live on in the last two years? According to the Agricultural Institute's farm management survey for 1979, published on 1 October 1980, the farm income for half our farmers was less than £2,000 per year. Do the Government deny that? That is less than £40 per week and that is the income of half our farmers.

Comment on this

Would the Deputy give us the figures for 1973 and 1974?

Comment on this

And for 1975?

Comment on this

It was then a lot higher than it was last year and the previous year.

Comment on this

When farms could not be disposed of.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy cop on?

Comment on this

It is time Deputy L'Estrange copped on.

Comment on this

Will the Deputy cop on? I will give him a tanner to cop on. Fianna Fáil were in power in 1973, we were not. He should not be questioning his own Government.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange is wrong there. His Government were in power at the start of 1973 and we came in later in the year.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy Keegan, if the Deputy speaking is wrong, that does not matter two hoots.

Comment on this

It took us a little while to rescue ourselves from the down pattern.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange is entitled to be wrong when he is speaking. That is fair enough.

Comment on this

The average income for all farmers in that particular year was £2,816 per annum, less that £55 per week. Remember, a farmer was supposed to pay more than that to an agricultural labourer. Let us take the average income at the end of December 1979. For those in manufacturing and other jobs, male and female, it was £4,555, or £87 per week. Therefore, the average income of other sections was £32 per week higher than the average income of the farmers, who were supposed to be the principal producers and whom Fianna Fáil tell us that they are interested in.

Comment on this

It has got worse still.

Comment on this

The Deputy is not able to count.

Comment on this

I am quite well able to count — 55 from 87 is 32. I do not know what school Deputy Keegan went to, but that is the figure I arrived at. If the Deputy wants further figures, I asked a question in the Dáil on Tuesday, 3 March 1981. According to the reply I got the farmers represent 20 per cent of our population. When we were in office in 1977 they were receiving 18.2 per cent of the national income. In 1980 under Fianna Fáil they received less than 12 per cent of the national income.

Comment on this

What is your solution?

Comment on this

Take your medicine now.

Comment on this

I should like to quote some other figures. We talk about farmers and the land and we are all interested in agriculture. We would like to see more people on the land. In 1977 there were 193,600 people on the land, in 1979 the figure was down to 182,300 a drop of 11,300 in two years. The number of agricultural labourers in 1977 was 29,500 and in 1979 it had dropped to 26,400. It is reckoned that it dropped by a further 4,000 since then which means that we have over 8,000 fewer agricultural labourers today than when Fianna Fáil took office. Is that bringing back prosperity to rural Ireland? Does the Minister think so?

We must also remember that one of the greatest crises now facing agriculture is the fact that factories that are giving employment are having to lay off workers. For example, in the meat factories 3,000 workers have been laid off in the past few months. It is reckoned that another 3,000 may have to go in the near future because due to the poverty of the farmers they had to sell cattle last year that they should have kept and fattened this year; they had to sell 500,000 milk cows many of them in calf and which they should have kept to produce more cattle. Tractor sales last year were down by 60 per cent; farm machinery sales were down 50 per cent, farm building materials down 60 per cent, compound feeds down 22 per cent, cattle feeds down 20 per cent, fertiliser sales down 20 per cent, and veteninary medicine sales down 15 per cent. This is a most serious matter for the whole economy.

During all that time the Government stood idly by while there was a complete loss of confidence among Irish farmers. I suppose they were agreeing with Lord Melbourne's dictum: "Ponder, pause, prepare, postpone and end by leaving things alone; in fact earn the people's pay by doing nothing every day". That is how the Government fooled the farmers of the country for the past few years.

Comment on this

"And still the wonder grew that one small head could carry all he knew".

Comment on this

Ill fares the land to hastening ills a prey, where rates and taxes accumulate and men decay.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

When we have done with the poetry session let us get back to the business before the House. We do not need any more western poets.

Comment on this

The present crisis in agriculture underlines the urgent need for a long-term and realistic programme and policy for agriculture. Its problems need commonsense and practical solutions, not gimmicks, such as I mentioned earlier, like opening cow byres in the west of Ireland or unveiling plaques.

The present Government are muddling along from crisis to crisis. The ship of State seems to be heading for the rocks and the captain seems to be lost in the mist. Proper action is needed immediately. If we do not have it now it may be too late. Unfortunately, it is too late for many farmers. As I said earlier, it would take at least £400 million to restore prosperity. People may ask where the money is to come from. But if the Government could find £90 million for Nítrigin Éireann, if they were able to find an extra £70 million for the teachers, if they could find £72 million for CIE and all the other millions for the various other sections, is it not only right to ask why they cannot find money for the farming community? We have heard a good deal during the past few months about the package that the Minister brought back from Brussels.

Comment on this

That was because it was a good package.

Comment on this

We are entitled to ask why the details of that package were kept secret. Surely they should have been made known to the farmers' organisations and to the people generally. Not even the farmers' representatives who were travelling to and from Brussels were let in on the secret, whereas if they had been made aware of what the Minister was looking for, they would have been in a position to help him. Indeed, if the package had not been kept secret we might have got much more from it.

The Minister of State has told us that he expects to be meeting again with the farmers' representatives for the purpose of reviewing the situation in the light of the Brussels decision. We are delighted to hear this because it represents a change compared with the past. I am thinking particularly of when the present Taoiseach as Minister for Agriculture had the farmers sent to jail because they had been walking up and down outside the gates of Leinster House to protest against conditions and to demand a fair living for themselves in their own country. Since then I have seen members of illegal organisations camp outside the gates of this House without any attempt being made to arrest them. Neither was there any attempt to interfere with them when they climbed the gates of Leinster House and burned a flag. This was quite a contrast to the situation in which law abiding farmers were arrested and lodged in Mountjoy.

It might be no harm to put on record what was said by a great friend of the Minister for Agriculture, Mr. Joe Rea. He said that pretence and promises are not sufficient, that neither the Government's sympathy nor the Minister, Deputy Ray MacSharry's always open door nor the understanding of the Taoiseach would pay farmers' bills and keep bank managers happy.

I am very pleased to know that the Taoiseach and the Government recognise the farmers' organisations now. I recall 1976 when every day for three long weeks the farmers sat on the steps of Agriculture House and were ignored by the Government.

Comment on this

Were the Deputy's party not in Government then? Of course Deputy L'Estrange was the silent man at the time. He had been sealed up by Deputy Cosgrave.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Would the Minister of State please allow Deputy L'Estrange to conclude?

Comment on this

Our farmers are entitled to a fair deal. They are entitled to fair compensation for their work but the situation is that their income has dropped by 60 per cent in the past three years. To that extent we welcome what is in the package though it is not sufficient to restore prosperity to the farming community who have received such a battering during the past few years of Fianna Fáil Government.

Comment on this

They got a fair old wallopping from the Deputy's Party.

Comment on this

They survived it.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister for Agriculture to conclude the debate.

Comment on this

Would the Minister for culture behind him keep quite?

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy L'Estrange and all the others keep quiet?

Comment on this

The Deputy should practise what he preaches.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

If these two Deputies from the same constituency would go outside and hammer this out we would get on much better.

Comment on this
Raymond MacSharry Minister for Agriculture (Mr. MacSharry) Fianna Fáil

I want to say how disappointed I am at the contributions of Deputies from the opposite side of the House. We have not had one concrete suggestion from either of the two parties.

Comment on this

Resign.

Comment on this

Before I go on to reply to the debate, such as it was, I want to refer to the hypocrisy of the Opposition here today on the Order of Business and indeed at many other times over recent months in relation to the time being made available by the Government. At the request of the Opposition the Government made five hours available today to the two parties and arranged a time for each of them for their contributions. We find that the party who do most in claiming time for various topics opted out of the time available to them this evening to contribute to this debate. I hope that that fact is noted outside in the same way as the comments made here on the Order of Business in recent months.

Comment on this

Name the party.

Comment on this

It is a disgraceful situation and proves beyond doubt the hypocrisy of the Opposition during the discussion on the Order of Business today.

Comment on this

We occupied the full five hours.

Comment on this

They had to send for Deputy L'Estrange to come in and speak on the debate.

Comment on this

We had not.

Comment on this

Why?

Comment on this

Because the Labour Party opted out.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister, without interruption.

Comment on this

The Minister is completely wrong. As Chief Whip, I do not speak——

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

As Chief Whip the Deputy should remain silent at this stage.

Comment on this

It is a good job the Deputy is here as Chief Whip to fill in.

Comment on this

We had half a dozen to fill in.

Comment on this

Where are they? The usual old jobs.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is entitled to be heard the same as everybody else.

Comment on this

I do not make false charges.

Comment on this

I want to come now to the content of the debate, to the Opposition and what they have been saying in relation to their attitude, and the way they see things as affording little hope of improvement for agriculture, when they claimed that there would be a further reduction in farm incomes in 1981. I am not as pessimistic as they are. The EEC agreement on prices and related measures, coupled with the aid provided by the Government is providing the foundation for a turn-around in agriculture. I am confident that the bottom of the agricultural recession has been passed and that recovery has begun. This is not my view alone, but that of my Party, the Government and of many independent commentators, some of whom, when they made statements in the recent past, found there were various organisations and Opposition spokesmen prepared to publicise those statements when it suited them. I should like them now to take note of what is being said by those independent commentators who are saying that there will be a significant increase in farm incomes this year. That, in itself, is tremendous progress considering the very serious drop there has been in the last two years. It was also contended by those independent commentators that the maximum financial benefit and incentive available in the Brussels negotiations were achieved by the Irish Government.

I want to refer briefly to something that has been like a game of draughts or snakes and ladders over the last number of months. In the months of September, October and November various figures were mentioned as to what was required to restore farm incomes. In September last commentators were mentioning a figure of £155 million. The Government took action in September in relation to expenditure of £34 million or £35 million on the items mentioned at that time. Lo and behold, as soon as we did, the £155 million became £250 million by 29 November. The Government continued to have discussions with the farm organisations and to examine ways and means of assisting them. We took measures in the budget. As soon as we did, lo and behold, the £250 million became £300 million and within a month it was £550 million.

The point I have been making—and it is generally accepted, although some people still refer to hundreds of millions of pounds which they know are not available here or in Brussels—is that when these discussions began with the farm organisations on the very serious problems which existed in Irish agriculture the figures being talked about were £100 million to £200 million. Since then with the measures the Government have taken in September, in the budget, and in the price negotiations in Brussels, the total amount of money earmarked in that short period to help the income situation and the general recession in agriculture is upwards of £300 million. That is a tremendous achievement having regard to our present very difficult financial constraints.

Deputy D'Arcy said the agreement is of little benefit to the farming community. Surely £215 million cannot be ignored and swept aside. I suggest the Deputy should ask some individual farmers what they think of it——

Comment on this

I have asked them.

Comment on this

——and how it will affect them. He asked me how much of the £215 million will reach the farmer's pockets. Largely this will depend on the farmers themselves and what they produce. The price conditions are there. They are well above last year's level and the way is open to getting even more than the £215 million. There are guranteed prices, guaranteed markets and great scope and potential for an increase in output.

This is very important for all of us who are interested in contributing to agriculture. We in political life are well aware of the opportunities which present themselves for people to make what might be described as political capital. My attitude is — and I hope those who are interested in agriculture will adopt the same attitude—to try to improve the situation because of the importance of agriculture to this economy.

I am glad Deputy L'Estrange has come back into the House because I did not want to refer to him in his absence. He referred to the ewe premium. I heard him trot this out in the Dáil on a few occasions when I did not have an opportunity to reply. I will use this opportunity.

Comment on this

I heard the promise made.

Comment on this

At no time in Donegal or anywhere else did any member of this party say that in the period from October to April of this year there would be a ewe premium of £7 available.

Comment on this

I heard Deputy Allen say it four times.

Comment on this

What was said was that from October to October, a 12 months period, if sheep prices went down they would be made up by a £7 a ewe premium. Let us look at what is happening?

Comment on this

I heard it said four times.

Comment on this

Deputy L'Estrange has to take his medicine whether he likes it or not. Because of the organisation of the sheep market——

Comment on this

I will listen to the truth.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange, please.

Comment on this

I heard the Minister of State, Deputy Allen, say it four times.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister is entitled to speak.

Comment on this

The prices for sheep meat have increased by 40 per cent. As a result of that the subsidy of £3.50 that could have come into effect because of the increase in prices in that period from October until now became 92 pence.

Comment on this

The £7 became——

Comment on this

Because of our concern for the farmers in Donegal and in the western and disadvantaged areas and the fact that they had sold their sheep when the bigger prices arrived, we, the Government, decided that we would give, along with the 92 pence, a premium of £2 additional headage grant payment this year——

Comment on this

They needed it.

Comment on this

——bringing the total payment to £2.92 as against the £3.50 that was possible if prices had stayed at their levels, but prices at the same time went up by 40 per cent. I am sorry that Deputy L'Estrange does not like it.

Comment on this

I would like the truth.

Comment on this

That is the truth and we have to accept it.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange, please.

Comment on this

Is it paid out yet? It is not paid in Wexford and Wicklow.

Comment on this

I heard him at three Church gates saying that there would be £7 for every farmer——

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange, please.

Comment on this

In a full year, I said.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy L'Estrange should not come in to obstruct the business of the House.

Comment on this

All they got was 92 pence. Deputy Allen has let the Minister down now.

Comment on this

Deputy Allen said "in a full year".

Comment on this

He has admitted.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Please, Deputy L'Estrange. The business of the House should be allowed to proceed.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy D'arcy should not get in on it either.

Comment on this

Deputy D'Arcy questioned the benefit of the full green pound package. I find this very surprising. It was not so long ago that various interests here were pressing me to secure a green pound devaluation of the amount of the 1.5 per cent franchise. If such a devaluation were of benefit a few months ago surely it is of some benefit now.

Comment on this

That was not the point I was making.

Comment on this

The Deputy cannot deny the point he was making.

Comment on this
Seán Browne An Leas-Cheann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Deputy D'Arcy, please.

Comment on this

The Minister is misquoting us all the time.

Comment on this

I assure Deputies that the price increases that we have outlined are factual and any effort by the Opposition or anybody else to try to devalue them is a futile exercise because already this week the additional price increases will flow into the farmers' pockets.

Deputy D'Arcy was also concerned about lime usage but he seems to overlook that a subsidy is already contained in the special measures which we secured last week.

Comment on this

The Government took it away for the last four years.

Comment on this

I was struck by the lack of a positive or constructive suggestion from the other side during this debate. There was no mention of what funds would be needed to give help and of where those funds might be had. The funds available to the Government are not unlimited but despite this we provided as much as £75 million to help agriculture. Taken together with the £215 million of the price proposals for 1981 we are talking in terms of nearly £300 million since last September in aid for Irish agriculture. Nobody in their wildest dreams would have thought last September that it was possible, with the resources available, to provide the kind of money that has been provided.

Comment on this

There will still be a reduction of 4 per cent in farm incomes.

Comment on this

Deputy D'Arcy said that more aid to farmers is needed and that his party will provide it. But he did not specify what aid would be provided.

Comment on this

After the general election he will tell the present Government.

Comment on this

I am still waiting for specific indications. I would refer to the hypocrisy of Fine Gael in their presentation of a Bill to this House on 27 November as if they had spent months thinking of ways and means in which they could assist agriculture. Discussions had begun in August and September with the farming organisations and the subject matter of these discussions was widely publicised. Then, lo and behold, out of the blue, Fine Gael came out with a Bill talking about the six new ideas that Fine Gael would implement if they got the opportunity, the abolition of resource tax, on which a commitment had already been given months before by the Taoiseach——

Comment on this

Selective wealth tax.

Comment on this

——the repeal of the bovine diseases levy Act, a point that was number one on the agenda of the farming organisations as far back as August, the abolition of rates on agricultural lands and buildings, which was number two in the discussions of the farming organisations——

Comment on this

The Government did not do it.

Comment on this

——allowance for capital expenditure on breeding stock, infrastructure relief for certain farms——

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister without interruption.

Comment on this

Fine Gael must have spent a lot of time finding out those new ideas to help Irish agriculture. They were on every single newspaper for months before that. On 27 November last Fine Gael decided, because there was so much publicity about this, it was better for them to put the six points together in a Bill and present them to the Dáil. Every single item mentioned there was in it.

Comment on this

I made a speech in September with the six points in it.

Comment on this

The Government have had discussions and taken positive action on every single one of those items and we are still waiting to see what Fine Gael have in mind for the farming community.

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy L'Estrange please allow the Minister to speak?

Comment on this

Five hours were provided and they failed even to fill that time. Notwithstanding the fact that we asked for it, we still have not had one single suggestion from that side of the House. They are the people who say that they are capable of governing the country if an election is called in the near future. They have not a suggestion to put forward. They have had many opportunities but we have not heard one thing from them.

Comment on this

What about the 5 per cent interest subsidy we supported?

Comment on this

Deputy D'Arcy referred to the price increases in the different member states. He seemed to want different rates of increase for the various countries. He wanted a special higher price for Ireland. Does the Deputy really want to go along that dangerous road? Maybe his leader sitting beside him could give him some idea of the fundamental principles and the mechanisms of the CAP. If Fine Gael are not in favour of this the people are entitled to know. As long as this Government are here, in our efforts with the EEC, we will do everything we can to protect the fundamental principles and mechanisms of the CAP. If Fine Gael are not in favour of that will they say so?

Comment on this

The CAP has brought us tremendous benefits over the years. We should be very careful about endangering it in any way. Now that Deputy D'Arcy has put it on the record of the House, I challenge Fine Gael to say if they protect and will fight to protect the CAP or they will not do so?

Comment on this

We always did.

Comment on this

The Deputy should withdraw what he said tonight.

Comment on this

Deputy FitzGerald was in favour of it.

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy L'Estrange please allow the Minister to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

I am glad the Deputy reminded me of that because I know that Deputy FitzGerald was in favour of it. I want to come to a point which the Deputy has reminded me of, which was raised by a number of speakers during this debate, the so-called tremendous price increases that were obtained from 1973 to 1977. The price increases that were obtained between 1973 and 1977, which Deputy D'Arcy referred to, were as a result of green currency devaluations plus price increases of 4 per cent and 5 per cent, not 9½ per cent or 13½ per cent. I want to say quite clearly so that Fine Gael will understand it, that most of those price increases were obtained because of what was negotiated by Fianna Fáil in our entry to the EEC and, because of the inactivity of the Government in 1974, 1975 and 1976 and the drastic situation which developed, there have been tremendous difficulties ever since. It is only now that we are getting to the situation of turning that around. It is ludicrous for Deputies to come into the House and start talking about the price of cattle, the price of calves and the absence of a calf subsidy.

Comment on this
William O'Brien Mr. W. O'Brien Fine Gael

Why are the farmers going on the streets?

Comment on this

The Deputy did not contribute to the debate. The Chief Whip had to be called on. The Labour Party gave Fine Gael Deputies plenty of time and showed their hyprocrisy in looking for time to debate important measures. They were not even prepared to put up speakers, and not many Deputies have been in the House during this debate.

Comment on this

There were plenty of speakers.

Comment on this

The last people in this country to talk about the price of calves are on the Opposition benches because in 1974-75 there were no prices for calves and they could be swapped for a chicken. What did the then Government do about it? Absolutely nothing.

Comment on this

The farmers had an income then.

Comment on this
Joseph Brennan An Cheann Comhairle

Deputy D'Arcy should allow the Minister to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

Calf prices have risen this week and if Deputy D'Arcy sold his calves cheaper it was probably in order to make a bogus point.

Deputy Bermingham talked at length about exports of live cattle and about the effects on the meat industry. At a meeting of the beef management committee on Friday last it was decided to increase the level of refunds on exports of fresh and chilled beef to third countries as well as on live cattle. These increases were a direct result of the price decisions. The increases in the export refunds are approximately 15 per cent for live cattle, 17 per cent for beef and 25 per cent for boneless beef. The latter increase was as a result of representations from my Department to the Commission. While I accept that the disadvantage on exports of boneless beef to third countries is not entirely removed, this must be seen as a step in the right direction. My officials will continue to press the Commission to eliminate completely this disadvantage. The new refunds should enable exporters to sell more of the middle range cuts in third country markets.

Comment on this

Why are the factories closing down?

Comment on this

Live horse and you will get grass.

Comment on this

Last year approximately 2,000 tons of fresh boneless beef were exported to third countries and I hope in the future that amount will be much higher as a result of the new increased export refunds.

I wish to stress that I am speaking only about trade with countries outside the Community. In the case of trade with other member states, who provide a market for some seven million tons of beef per annum, boneless beef is not suffering a disadvantage under EEC arrangements. If anything, it has an MCA advantage over carcase beef and live cattle. Canned beef imports to countries such as Germany and the UK have a very definite advantage over live cattle and carcase beef and there can be no question of so-called anomalies hindering the processing of meat here.

Regarding live exports to North Africa, which is the market for the bulk of our live exports, I am satisfied that the export refund system does not favour live exports by comparison with carcase beef.

I am happy to see that some Irish companies are beginning to exploit market opportunities in this area and I hope that the new refunds will give impetus to this development.

Regarding Deputy Berminghan's suggestion that we should impose a calf levy, I must remind him that we are part of a Community in which free trade in agricultural products is a major benefit to us. If we imposed levies on imports or exports, so could the other member states. He also said that we should halt calf exports. Since last November there has been little or no exporting of calves because of the tremendous prices available here for calf producers.

Deputy Bermingham mentioned cross-Border exports of cattle. One of the benefits of last week's settlement is that the discriminatory elements in the UK variable premium has been eliminated. This means there is no special variable premium incentive to send cattle over the Border instead of slaughtering them here. That is a very important point in relation to the negotiations, but the Opposition are anxious to ensure that these very important points are disregarded.

Comment on this

We welcome them for the farmers.

Comment on this

I am glad to hear that. Live exports in 1980 were little different from the average level of recent years. What has occurred is that the destination of much of our live exports has changed from Britain and the continent to North Africa, with little change in total numbers.

On the question of the calf subsidy, Deputy D'Arcy referred to phasing it out for Italy. As I said in my opening statement, the Commission and some member states want to abolish it completely. The Commission put forward a formal proposal to phase it out over the next few years. What has happened is that the rate of subsidy has been cut by about one-quarter and we can be certain that a further reduction will be sought next year.

When at the end of the negotiations we withdrew our request for a calf subsidy we got a very definite and positive commitment from the Commission not only to do something new about cattle production before 15 July, but we also got a positive commitment from the Commission to look at the social and regional areas arising from the very serious drop in farming incomes.

Comment on this

Live horse and you will get grass.

Comment on this

The Deputy has said that about six times tonight. All I can say is that since last September a lot of grass has been provided, £300 million. That is the position. It is not a question of live horse and you will get grass.

Comment on this

Substantial and very positive measures have been taken by the Government at home and in Brussels to alleviate the very serious situation that existed over the past two years.

Comment on this

There has been a 50 per cent drop in farmers' incomes.

Comment on this

Deputy D'Arcy seemed to regret that in this year's budget we suspended the disease levy and also granted extensive rates relief.

Comment on this

No.

Comment on this

These were two very valuable benefits for our farmers——

Comment on this

Imposed by Fianna Fáil.

Comment on this

——and I do not think many of them will agree——

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

Will Deputy D'Arcy allow the Minister to continue without interruption, please?

Comment on this

He does not like what we have done, but we are glad because of the benefit which will accrue to the farmers concerned. Deputy D'Arcy was critical of the fact that we do not have a bigger sugar quota than 182,000 tonnes.

Comment on this

I never mentioned that.

Comment on this

A little more than a year ago we were all concerned about the Commission's proposal to cut back our quota to 164,000 tonnes.

Comment on this

I never mentioned that. The Minister is misquoting me all the time.

Comment on this

Now our growers will have every opportunity to expand. I am glad to see the success the farmers' organisations and the Sugar Company are having in regard to increasing the sugar beet acreage this year.

Comment on this

You jailed them a few years ago for marching outside the Dáil gates.

Comment on this

Deputy D'Arcy and Deputy Bermingham expressed concern about farmers who borrowed heavily. The Government too, have been most concerned about farmers who are finding it difficult to meet their financial obligations.

Comment on this

But the Minister is not doing anything about it.

Comment on this

We have had a series of meetings with the banks and the ACC. Out of these meetings came various measures of assistance. We arranged for loans at a reduced rate of interest with the benefit of Exchequer cover for residential exchange risks. We arranged with the banks that they would restructure loans for farmers in serious financial difficulties. Liaison committees, representative of the banks, the ACC and the farm organisations and with official representation, were set up to monitor the situation. Discussions with the financial institutions are part of an ongoing process and, as I said earlier, we will be shortly meeting farmer representatives again. The great progress that has been made by the banks and the ACC in restructuring many thousands of loans has been a very positive advantage to many farmers.

Comment on this

Is that why they are selling their land?

Comment on this

We all accept that there are a number of farmers who for one reason or another find themselves still in serious difficulty and that is the reason we have had the discussions, chaired by my Minister of State, Deputy Smith. We will be discussing that aspect with the farming leaders in the next number of days.

Comment on this

It is good that the Minister is talking to them. It is a change from some years ago. At one time they had to await for three weeks on the footpath outside the Minister's door.

Comment on this

We are, notwithstanding the fact that at the Fine Gael Ard Fheis, and tonight, the Fine Gael spokesman on agriculture tried to put it into the mouths of farmer representatives not to talk to the Government.

Comment on this

I suggested that they call the Minister's bluff. The Minister has been bluffing for two years and he is bluffing tonight.

Comment on this

The discussions have been very fruitful and helpful to both sides. The fruit of them can be seen in the combination of measures at home and abroad amounting to £300 million. Nobody in their wildest dreams thought that was possible a few short months ago, and that is not the end.

Comment on this

It was £215 million a few moments ago.

Comment on this

If we are here much longer it will be £400 million.

Comment on this
Padraig Faulkner An Ceann Comhairle Fianna Fáil

The Minister should be allowed to continue without interruption.

Comment on this

Deputy D'Arcy referred to the EEC price increases during the period of the National Coalition. He admitted, however, that those figures included green £ changes. Of course, if we allowed the Irish currency to depreciate in the way that occurred during that period we could easily obtain green £ changes of the same scale, but that is not our attitude to this question.

Comment on this

What about sterling and the fact that the Irish pound is only worth 70p in England?

Comment on this

We are doing everything possible to contain inflation and have sought to help farmers in other ways by the good price settlement, the green £ change was secured without any adjustment to the Irish currency by a package of special measures to Ireland and by securing a further commitment to have further measures discussed and agreed by mid-July next.

Comment on this

Here we go again.

Comment on this

Live horse and get grass. Hills far away are green.

Comment on this

Deputy Kenny referred to the western package and sought to minimisè its value. That is a very easy thing to do. I live in the north-west and I am aware that there is tremendous interest in this proposal. When the western drainage scheme came in we had similar statements from the Opposition.

Comment on this

We will drain the Shannon this year. It will be drained before the general election. I have listened to that for 40 years.

Comment on this

We have a five-year drainage programme and we heard similar Opposition statements in relation to that programme. The situation now is that in a short time we have almost committed the entire expenditure and the possibility is that that five-year programme will be finished within three years. I have already begun discussions with Brussels to have that renewed before the end of the five-year term.

Comment on this

Apparently, there is no shortage of work but there are still 127,000 people unemployed.

Comment on this

I have done so because of the demand by farmers in the west for participation in this scheme. I can see the same situation arising in relation to the measures proposed under the western package. Deputy Kenny wants to see that as well, but he seeks to minimise the effects. It is the duty of every representative interested in the agricultural industry to be open, frank and honest in regard to what is available in the new price proposals. If they have alternatives let us hear them. We have spent five hours today debating this motion but not a solitary constructive suggestion has been made by them.

Comment on this

Poor stuff.

Comment on this

This little green document tells a little story about what Fine Gael have in store for the farmers — of course they have not discussed this with Labour, as a Deputy behind me has said. The sum total of their support for agriculture is contained in this six point paper.

Comment on this

It is only a short-term rescue package.

Comment on this

These matters, all of these items, have been under active discussion between the Government and the farming leaders. They were specifically looked after by the Government in proposals made in September, in the budget and in the Brussels package. There is not much more I have to say except to repeat that I am disappointed with the response from the other side.

Comment on this

Not as disappointed as the farmers are with the Minister.

Comment on this

Innocents in Europe, that is all they are.

Comment on this

As I said at the beginning, every day since this Dáil assembled we had their hypocrisy on the Order of Business calling for debates on certain measures, but as the Taoiseach said this morning, when they got the opportunity they wasted it. The proof was there tonight. We had five hours for this motion. The people who kicked up most about allocation of time for debate were the Labour Party but tonight they did not attempt to use the time available to them. Fine Gael had to go out, because there was not a Deputy in the House but Deputies D'Arcy and Kenny, to try to get a speaker to fill up the time. It was then arranged between the Whips that Deputy L'Estrange would conclude the debate for Fine Gael. I am glad a spare was here because it saved Fine Gael to some extent. However, the concern of the combined Opposition for the agricultural community, exemplified tonight, amounts only to trying to throw water on the positive, constructive steps taken by the Government on behalf of the agricultural community. The farmers know that their future lies solidly and squarely with this party and with this Government.

Comment on this
Division

Question put: "That the words proposed to be deleted stand."

Tá 52
·
Níl 26
Result Carried The question put was agreed to.

Do you agree with this result?